Challenges in the detection of gases in exoplanet atmospheres

Abstract

Claims of detections of gases in exoplanet atmospheres often rely on comparisons between models including and excluding specific chemical species. However, the space of molecular combinations available for model construction is vast and highly degenerate. Only a limited subset of these combinations is typically explored for any given detection. As a result, apparent detections of trace gases risk being artifacts of incomplete modeling rather than robust identification of atmospheric constituents, especially in the low signal-to-noise regime. Using the sub-Neptune K2-18 b as a case study, we show that recent biosignature claims vanish when the model space is expanded, with numerous alternatives providing equally good or better fits. We demonstrate that the significance of a claimed detection relies on the choice of models being compared, and that model preference does not in itself imply the presence of a specific gas. We recommend treating model comparisons instead as relative adequacy tests, which should be supported by theoretical predictions and complementary metrics of statistical significance in order to attribute a signal to a particular gas.

Revised title to match published version

References in corpus (39)

• The James Webb Space Telescope
• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Rayleigh scattering in the transit spectrum of HD 189733b
• ExoMol molecular line lists XXXV: a rotation-vibration line list for hot ammonia
• ExoMol molecular line lists - XVI: The rotation-vibration spectrum of hot H${}_2$S
• Early Release Science of the exoplanet WASP-39b with JWST NIRISS
• Mass-Metallicity Trends in Transiting Exoplanets from Atmospheric Abundances of H${}_2$O, Na, and K
• An accurate, extensive, and practical line list of methane for the HITEMP database
• VULCAN: an Open-Source, Validated Chemical Kinetics Python Code for Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• Detection of titanium oxide in the atmosphere of a hot Jupiter
• Identification of carbon dioxide in an exoplanet atmosphere
• ExoMol line lists VII: The rotation-vibration spectrum of phosphine up to 1500 K
• High Tide or Riptide on the Cosmic Shoreline? A Water-Rich Atmosphere or Stellar Contamination for the Warm Super-Earth GJ~486b from JWST Observations
• A reflective, metal-rich atmosphere for GJ 1214b from its JWST phase curve
• ExoMol molecular line lists -- XXXVII: spectra of acetylene
• PICASO 3.0: A One-Dimensional Climate Model for Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
• The interior and atmosphere of the habitable-zone exoplanet K2-18b
• A High Internal Heat Flux and Large Core in a Warm Neptune Exoplanet
• Warm terrestrial planet with half the mass of Venus transiting a nearby star
• The Sonora Substellar Atmosphere Models. IV. Elf Owl: Atmospheric Mixing and Chemical Disequilibrium with Varying Metallicity and C/O Ratios
• Double Trouble: Two Transits of the Super-Earth GJ 1132 b Observed with JWST NIRSpec G395H
• On degeneracies in retrievals of exoplanetary transmission spectra
• The SPHINX M-dwarf Spectral Grid. I. Benchmarking New Model Atmospheres to Derive Fundamental M-Dwarf Properties
• A unique hot Jupiter spectral sequence with evidence for compositional diversity
• Aurora: A Generalised Retrieval Framework for Exoplanetary Transmission Spectra
• A Benchmark JWST Near-Infrared Spectrum for the Exoplanet WASP-39b
• LHS 1140 b is a potentially habitable water world
• Hints of a sulfur-rich atmosphere around the 1.6 R${}_{\oplus }$ Super-Earth L98-59 d from JWST NIRSpec G395H transmission spectroscopy
• On the Application of Bayesian Leave-One-Out Cross-Validation to Exoplanet Atmospheric Analysis
• Assessment of Supervised Machine Learning for Atmospheric Retrieval of Exoplanets
• Methane as a dominant absorber in the habitable-zone sub-Neptune K2-18 b
• Aura-3D: A Three-dimensional Atmospheric Retrieval Framework for Exoplanet Transmission Spectra
• Molecular Simulations for the Spectroscopic Detection of Atmospheric Gases
• A Mini-Chemical Scheme with Net Reactions for 3D GCMs I.: Thermochemical Kinetics
• Insufficient evidence for DMS and DMDS in the atmosphere of K2-18 b. From a joint analysis of JWST NIRISS, NIRSpec, and MIRI observations
• Lava World: Exoplanet Surfaces
• Prospects for Detecting Signs of Life on Exoplanets in the JWST Era
• Enabling Robust Exoplanet Atmospheric Retrievals with Gaussian Processes
• Unraveling the non-equilibrium chemistry of the temperate sub-Neptune K2-18 b

Cited by in corpus (5)

• KRONOS I: The $1-2.8\mu$m JWST Transmission Spectrum of the 23 Myr V1298 Tau c
• The atmosphere of K2-18 b: The role of hazes, clouds and photoelectrons
• Methane on the temperate exo-Saturn TOI-199b
• Three-dimensional transport-induced chemistry on temperate sub-Neptune K2-18b, Part II: the combined effects of atmospheric dynamics and chemical reactions
• Information content of JWST transmission spectroscopy of the exoplanet HAT-P-12b from the optical to the mid-infrared