Revisiting Seismicity Criticality: A New Framework for Bias Correction of Statistical Seismology Model Calibrations
arXiv:2404.16374 · doi:10.1029/2024JB029337
Abstract
The Epidemic-Type Aftershock Sequences (ETAS) model and its variants effectively capture the space-time clustering of seismicity, setting the standard for earthquake forecasting. Accurate unbiased ETAS calibration is thus crucial. But we identify three sources of bias, (i) boundary effects, (ii) finite-size effects, and (iii) censorship, which are often overlooked or misinterpreted, causing errors in seismic analysis and predictions. By employing an ETAS model variant with variable spatial background rates, we propose a method to correct for these biases, focusing on the branching ratio n, a key indicator of earthquake triggering potential. Our approach quantifies the variation in the apparent branching ratio (napp) with increased cut-off magnitude (Mco) above the optimal cut-off (Mcobest). The napp(Mco) function yields insights superior to traditional point estimates. We validate our method using synthetic earthquake catalogs, accurately recovering the true branching ratio (ntrue) after correcting biases with napp(Mco). Additionally, our method introduces a refined estimation of the minimum triggering magnitude (m0), a crucial parameter in the ETAS model. Applying our framework to the earthquake catalogs of California, New Zealand, and the China Seismic Experimental Site (CSES) in Sichuan and Yunnan provinces, we find that seismicity hovers away from the critical point, nc = 1, remaining distinctly subcritical, however with values tending to be larger than recent reports that do not consider the above biases. It is interesting that, m0 is found around 4 for California, 3 for New Zealand and 2 for CSES, suggesting that many small triggered earthquakes may not be fertile. Understanding seismicity's critical state significantly enhances our comprehension of seismic patterns, aftershock predictability, and informs earthquake risk mitigation and management strategies.
36 pages, 7 figures, 5 tables
References in corpus (19)
- Power-law distributions in empirical data
- Sub-critical and Super-critical Regimes in Epidemic Models of Earthquake Aftershocks
- Statistics of Earthquakes in Simple Models of Heterogeneous Faults
- Quantifying reflexivity in financial markets: towards a prediction of flash crashes
- Critical reflexivity in financial markets: a Hawkes process analysis
- Precursors, aftershocks, criticality and self-organized criticality
- Importance of direct and indirect triggered seismicity
- Apparent Clustering and Apparent Background Earthquakes Biased by Undetected Seismicity
- Constraints on the Size of the Smallest Triggering Earthquake from the ETAS Model, Baath's Law, and Observed Aftershock Sequences
- Multifractal Scaling of Thermally-Activated Rupture Processes
- Magnitude-Dependent Omori Law: Empirical Study and Theory
- Objective Estimation of Spatially Variable Parameters of Epidemic Type Aftershock Sequence Model: Application to California
- Branching ratio approximation for the self-exciting Hawkes process
- Limits of Declustering Methods for Disentangling Exogenous from Endogenous Events in Time Series with Foreshocks, Main shocks and Aftershocks
- Vere-Jones' Self-Similar Branching Model
- Is seismicity operating at a critical point?
- Renormalization of the ETAS branching model of triggered seismicity from total to observable seismicity
- Exact asymptotic solutions to nonlinear Hawkes processes: a systematic classification of the steady-state solutions
- Predicting the Future Performance of the Planned Seismic Network in Mainland China