Limits of Declustering Methods for Disentangling Exogenous from Endogenous Events in Time Series with Foreshocks, Main shocks and Aftershocks

Abstract

Many time series in natural and social sciences can be seen as resulting from an interplay between exogenous influences and an endogenous organization. We use a simple (ETAS) model of events occurring sequentially, in which future events are influenced (partially triggered) by past events to ask the question of how well can one disentangle the exogenous events from the endogenous ones. We apply both model-dependant and model-independent stochastic declustering methods to reconstruct the tree of ancestry and estimate key parameters. In contrast with previously reported positive results, we have to conclude that declustered catalogs are rather unreliable for the synthetic catalogs that we have investigated, which contains of the order of thousands of events, typical of realistic applications. The estimated rates of exogenous events suffer from large errors. The key branching ratio $n$, quantifying the fraction of events that have been triggered by previous events, is also badly estimated in general from declustered catalogs. We find however that the errors tend to be smaller and perhaps acceptable in some cases for small triggering efficiency and branching ratios. The high level of randomness together with the very long memory makes the stochastic reconstruction of trees of ancestry and the estimation of the key parameters perhaps intrinsically unreliable for long memory processes. For shorter memories (larger "bare" Omori exponent), the results improve significantly.

30 pages + 5 figures + 10 tables

References in corpus (10)

• Robust dynamic classes revealed by measuring the response function of a social system
• Mainshocks are aftershocks of conditional foreshocks: How do foreshock statistical properties emerge from aftershock laws
• "Universal" Distribution of Inter-Earthquake Times Explained
• Theory of Earthquake Recurrence Times
• Apparent Clustering and Apparent Background Earthquakes Biased by Undetected Seismicity
• Magnitude-Dependent Omori Law: Empirical Study and Theory
• Generic Multifractality in Exponentials of Long Memory Processes
• Nonlinear theory and tests of earthquake recurrence times
• Renormalization of the ETAS branching model of triggered seismicity from total to observable seismicity
• Endogenous versus Exogenous Origins of Crises

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Quantifying reflexivity in financial markets: towards a prediction of flash crashes
• Modeling and estimation of multi-source clustering in crime and security data
• Self-similar aftershock rates
• Nonlinear Hawkes Processes
• Super-linear scaling of offsprings at criticality in branching processes
• Generating Functions and Stability Study of Multivariate Self-Excited Epidemic Processes
• Hierarchy of Temporal Responses of Multivariate Self-Excited Epidemic Processes
• Quasistatic kinetic avalanches and self-organized criticality in deviatorically loaded granular media
• Are Triggering Rates of Labquakes Universal? Inferring Triggering Rates From Incomplete Information
• Revisiting Seismicity Criticality: A New Framework for Bias Correction of Statistical Seismology Model Calibrations
• Multivariate Spatiotemporal Hawkes Processes and Network Reconstruction
• The ARMA Point Process and its Estimation
• Semiparametric Bayesian Forecasting of Spatial Earthquake Occurrences
• Effective Measure of Endogeneity for the Autoregressive Conditional Duration Point Processes via Mapping to the Self-Excited Hawkes Process
• Estimation of the Hawkes Process With Renewal Immigration Using the EM Algorithm