Underdetermination in Classic and Modern Tests of General Relativity
arXiv:2307.10074 · doi:10.1007/s13194-024-00617-1
Abstract
Canonically, `classic' tests of general relativity (GR) include perihelion precession, the bending of light around stars, and gravitational redshift; `modern' tests have to do with, inter alia, relativistic time delay, equivalence principle tests, gravitational lensing, strong field gravity, and gravitational waves. The orthodoxy is that both classic and modern tests of GR afford experimental confirmation of that theory in particular. In this article, we question this orthodoxy, by showing there are classes of both relativistic theories (with spatiotemporal geometrical properties different from those of GR) and non-relativistic theories (in which the lightcones of a relativistic spacetime are `widened') which would also pass such tests. Thus, (a) issues of underdetermination in the context of GR loom much larger than one might have thought, and (b) given this, one has to think more carefully about what exactly such tests in fact are testing.
arXiv commentThis is a revised version of the previous draft
References in corpus (70)
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- Modified Gravity and Cosmology
- The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
- Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
- Metric-Affine Gauge Theory of Gravity: Field Equations, Noether Identities, World Spinors, and Breaking of Dilation Invariance
- Testing General Relativity with Present and Future Astrophysical Observations
- Coincident General Relativity
- Detection of the gravitational redshift in the orbit of the star S2 near the Galactic centre massive black hole
- Strong constraints on cosmological gravity from GW170817 and GRB 170817A
- Cosmology in geometry
- Detection of the Schwarzschild precession in the orbit of the star S2 near the Galactic centre massive black hole
- Teleparallel Gravity: From Theory to Cosmology
- Testing General Relativity in Cosmology
- Dark Energy vs. Modified Gravity
- Bouncing Cosmologies: Progress and Problems
- General coordinate invariance and conformal invariance in nonrelativistic physics: Unitary Fermi gas
- Horava-Lifshitz Cosmology: A Review
- Testing modified gravity at cosmological distances with LISA standard sirens
- MICROSCOPE mission: final results of the test of the Equivalence Principle
- Boundary Stress-Energy Tensor and Newton-Cartan Geometry in Lifshitz Holography
- Inflationary paradigm after Planck 2013
- Symmetric teleparallel general relativity
- Non-Relativistic Strings and Limits of the AdS/CFT Correspondence
- Action Principle for Newtonian Gravity
- Horava-Lifshitz Gravity From Dynamical Newton-Cartan Geometry
- Comparing Equivalent Gravities: common features and differences
- `Stringy' Newton-Cartan Gravity
- No further gravitational wave modes in gravity
- Symmetric Teleparallel Gravity: Some exact solutions and spinor couplings
- Polarization of gravitational waves in symmetric teleparallel theories of gravity and their modifications
- Non-Relativistic Gravity and its Coupling to Matter
- The Link between General Relativity and Shape Dynamics
- Torsional Newton-Cartan gravity from the large expansion of General Relativity
- Underdetermination of dark energy
- General Relativity and Weyl Geometry
- Implications of Planck2015 for inflationary, ekpyrotic and anamorphic bouncing cosmologies
- Pulsars and Gravity
- Gravity between Newton and Einstein
- Gauge-Invariant Localization of Infinitely Many Gravitational Energies from All Possible Auxiliary Structures
- Gravitational waves in modified teleparallel theories of gravity
- Bigravity and Lorentz-violating Massive Gravity
- Absolute Objects and Counterexamples: Jones-Geroch Dust, Torretti Constant Curvature, Tetrad-Spinor, and Scalar Density
- Frequently asked questions about Shape Dynamics
- The Teleparallel Equivalent of Newton-Cartan Gravity
- Standard Sirens as a novel probe of dark energy
- Clarifying possible misconceptions in the foundations of general relativity
- Noether charge and black hole entropy in teleparallel gravity
- Robert Dicke and the naissance of experimental gravity physics, 1957-1967
- Permanent Underdetermination from Approximate Empirical Equivalence in Field Theory: Massless and Massive Scalar Gravity, Neutrino, Electromagnetic, Yang-Mills and Gravitational Theories
- The Nontriviality of Trivial General Covariance: How Electrons Restrict 'Time' Coordinates, Spinors (Almost) Fit into Tensor Calculus, and 7/16 of a Tetrad Is Surplus Structure
- Role of spacetime boundaries in Einstein's other gravity
- Lifshitz Hydrodynamics from Lifshitz Black Branes with Linear Momentum
- Conformal and projective symmetries in Newtonian cosmology
- Respecting Boundaries: Theoretical Equivalence and Structure Beyond Dynamics
- On Gravitational Energy in Newtonian Theories
- Methodological Reflections on the MOND/Dark Matter Debate
- The Non-Relativistic Geometric Trinity of Gravity
- Polarization of gravitational waves in general teleparallel theories of gravity
- Light cone and Weyl compatibility of conformal and projective structures
- Conformal Invariance of the Newtonian Weyl Tensor
- Symmetries and currents of the ideal and unitary Fermi gases
- On the geometric trinity of gravity, non-relativistic limits, and Maxwell gravitation
- Explanatory Depth in Primordial Cosmology: A Comparative Study of Inflationary and Bouncing Paradigms
- Fields as Bodies: a unified presentation of spacetime and internal gauge symmetry
- Covariant effective action for a Galilean invariant quantum Hall system
- Cosmological Inflation and Meta-Empirical Theory Assessment
- Wald's entropy in Coincident General Relativity
- Newtonian gravitational deflection of light revisited
- On the physical interpretation of non-metricity in Brans-Dicke gravity
- Is spacetime curved? Assessing the underdetermination of general relativity and teleparallel gravity