Using 3D and 2D analysis for analyzing large-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions

Abstract

The nature of galaxy spin is still not fully known. Iye et al (2021) applied a 3D analysis to a dataset of bright SDSS galaxies that was used in the past for photometric analysis. They showed that the distribution of spin directions of spiral galaxies is random, providing a dipole axis with low statistical significance of 0.29$\sigma$. However, to show random distribution, two decisions were made, each can lead to random distribution regardless of the real distribution of the spin direction of galaxies. The first decision was to limit the dataset arbitrarily to z$<$0.1, which is a redshift range in which previous literature already showed that random distribution is expected. More importantly, while the 3D analysis requires the redshift of each galaxy, the analysis was done with the photometric redshift. If the asymmetry existed, its signal is expected to be an order of magnitude weaker than the error of the photometric redshift, and therefore the low statistical signal under these conditions is expected. When using the exact same data without limiting to $z_{phot}<0.1$ and without using the photometric redshift, the distribution of the spin directions in that dataset shows a statistical signal of $>2\sigma$. Code and data for reproducing the analysis are publicly available. These results are in agreement with other experiments with SDSS, Pan-STARRS, HST, and the DESI Legacy Survey. The paper also examines other previous studies that showed random distribution in galaxy spin directions. While further research will be required, the current evidence suggest that large-scale asymmetry between the number of clockwise and counterclockwise galaxies cannot be ruled out.

arXiv commentPASJ, accepted Data for the reproduction of simple binomial distribution in two opposite hemispheres is available at: https://people.cs.ksu.edu/~lshamir/data/assym_72k/index.html Code and data for analysis of a dipole axis, as well as Monte Carlo simulation of separation into opposite hemispheres is available at: https://people.cs.ksu.edu/~lshamir/data/iye_et_al/index.html

References in corpus (76)

• The World as a Hologram
• The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: Power-spectrum analysis of the final dataset and cosmological implications
• The holographic principle
• Galaxy Zoo 1 : Data Release of Morphological Classifications for nearly 900,000 galaxies
• Asymmetries in the CMB anisotropy field
• The Spin of the Near-Extreme Kerr Black Hole GRS 1915+105
• Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and statistics of the CMB
• The axis of evil
• Observation of a Large-scale Anisotropy in the Arrival Directions of Cosmic Rays above $8\times 10^{18}$ eV
• A Critical Assessment of Photometric Redshift Methods: A CANDELS Investigation
• The distribution and cosmic evolution of massive black hole spins
• Black Hole Spin Evolution
• Photometric Redshifts for Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program Data Release 1
• Shapes and Positions of Black Hole Shadows in Accretion Disks and Spin Parameters of Black Holes
• A Test of the Cosmological Principle with Quasars
• Interacting dark energy, holographic principle and coincidence problem
• Cosmology with torsion: An alternative to cosmic inflation
• Evidence for anisotropy of cosmic acceleration
• On the Importance of NNLO QCD and Isospin-breaking Corrections in ${\epsilon }^{\prime }/\epsilon$
• Galaxy Zoo: Reproducing Galaxy Morphologies Via Machine Learning
• Cosmic Microwave Background Quadrupole and Ellipsoidal Universe
• Probing cosmic isotropy with a new X-ray galaxy cluster sample through the $L_{\text{X}}-T$ scaling relation
• Ellipsoidal Universe Can Solve The CMB Quadrupole Problem
• Mapping extreme-scale alignments of quasar polarization vectors
• Does the small CMB quadrupole moment suggest new physics?
• A Low CMB Quadrupole from Dark Energy Isocurvature Perturbations
• Galaxy Zoo: The large-scale spin statistics of spiral galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Detection of a Dipole in the Handedness of Spiral Galaxies with Redshifts z ~ 0.04
• Catastrophic photometric redshift errors: weak lensing survey requirements
• Probing the isotropy of cosmic acceleration traced by Type Ia supernovae
• Radial motion into an Einstein-Rosen bridge
• Universe Generation from Black Hole Interiors
• On Larger $H_0$ Values in the CMB Dipole Direction
• Holographic principle and dark energy
• Holographic Principle and String Cosmology
• A Cosmic Void Catalog of SDSS DR12 BOSS Galaxies
• Ganalyzer: A tool for automatic galaxy image analysis
• Geometric Inflation
• Towards geometric inflation: the cubic case
• Scalable Automated Detection of Spiral Galaxy Arm Segments
• CMB Maximum Temperature Asymmetry Axis: Alignment with Other Cosmic Asymmetries
• Dipole Anisotropy in Integrated Linearly Polarized Flux Density in NVSS Data
• Matrix Model simulations using Quantum Computing, Deep Learning, and Lattice Monte Carlo
• A Complete Statistical Analysis for the Quadrupole Amplitude in an Ellipsoidal Universe
• Directional Variations of Cosmological Parameters from the Planck CMB Data
• Anomalies in the low CMB multipoles and extended foregrounds
• The significance of anisotropic signals hiding in the type Ia supernovae
• What Lies Beneath: Using p(z) to Reduce Systematic Photometric Redshift Errors
• Handedness asymmetry of spiral galaxies with z<0.3 shows cosmic parity violation and a dipole axis
• Computer-generated visual morphology catalog of ~3,000,000 SDSS galaxies
• Anisotropy in the all-sky distribution of galaxy morphological types
• On the nature and correction of the spurious S-wise spiral galaxy winding bias in Galaxy Zoo 1
• Observational detection of correlation between galaxy spins and initial conditions
• Mysterious Coherence in Several-Megaparsec Scales Between Galaxy Rotation and Neighbor Motion
• Cosmic Parallax in Ellipsoidal Universe
• Patterns of galaxy spin directions in SDSS and Pan-STARRS show parity violation and multipoles
• Quadrupole--octopole alignment of CMB related to primordial power spectrum with dipolar modulation in anisotropic spacetime
• The Ellipsoidal Universe in the Planck Satellite Era
• Aspects of Geometric Inflation
• Estimation of the black hole spin in LMC X-1 using AstroSat
• Asymmetry between galaxies with clockwise handedness and counterclockwise handedness
• Probing statistical isotropy of cosmological radio sources using SKA
• Galaxy Rotation Coherent with the Motions of Neighbors: Discovery of Observational Evidence
• Photometric asymmetry between clockwise and counterclockwise spiral galaxies in SDSS
• An Oppositeness in the Cosmology: Distribution of the Gamma-Ray Bursts and the Cosmological Principle
• Holography, Dark Energy and Entropy of Large Cosmic Structures
• Galaxy spin direction distribution in HST and SDSS show similar large-scale asymmetry
• On the viability of the evolution of the universe with Geometric Inflation
• Large-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions: evidence from the Southern hemisphere
• Spin Parity of Spiral Galaxies III -- Dipole Analysis of the Distribution of SDSS Spirals with 3D Random Walk Simulations
• New evidence and analysis of cosmological-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions
• Large-scale asymmetry between clockwise and counterclockwise galaxies revisited
• Influence of Planck foreground masks in the large angular scale quadrant CMB asymmetry
• Analysis of $\sim 10^6$ spiral galaxies from four telescopes shows large-scale patterns of asymmetry in galaxy spin directions
• Inflation in de Sitter spacetime and CMB large scales anomaly
• Large-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions -- analysis of galaxies with spectra in DES, SDSS, and DESI Legacy Survey

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
• The distribution of galaxy rotation in JWST Advanced Deep Extragalactic Survey
• Reanalysis of the spin direction distribution of Galaxy Zoo SDSS spiral galaxies
• Large-scale asymmetry in the distribution of galaxy spin directions -- analysis and reproduction
• No evidence for anisotropy in galaxy spin directions
• Galaxy spin direction asymmetry in JWST deep fields
• A simple direct empirical observation of systematic bias of the redshift as a distance indicator
• Asymmetry in galaxy spin directions: a fully reproducible experiment using HSC data