Can the Distance-Redshift Relation Be Determined from Correlations Between Luminosities?

Abstract

We explore whether an independent determination of the distance-redshift relation, and hence cosmological model parameters, can be obtained from the apparent correlations between two different waveband luminosities or fluxes, as has been claimed in recent works using the X-ray and ultraviolet luminosities and fluxes of quasars. We show that such an independent determination is possible only if the correlation between luminosities is obtained independent of the cosmological model, and measured fluxes and redshifts; for example, being based on sound theoretical models or unrelated observations. In particular, we show that if the correlation is determined empirically from two luminosities obtained from fluxes and redshifts, then the method suffers from circularity. In case, as claimed in recent works, the observed correlation between fluxes in very narrow redshift bins are used as proxy for the luminosity correlation, then we show that one is dealing with a pure tautology with no information on distances and cosmological model. We argue that the problem arises because of the incomplete treatment of the correlation and we use numerical methods with a joint X-ray and ultraviolet quasar data set to demonstrate this shortcoming.

6 pages, 2 figures, updated to version accepted to ApJL, typos and misformattings removed

References in corpus (11)

• Determining the range of validity of quasar X-ray and UV flux measurements for constraining cosmological model parameters
• Quasar standardization: Overcoming Selection Biases and Redshift Evolution
• Quasars as standard candles II: The non linear relation between UV and X-ray emission at high redshifts
• Do quasar X-ray and UV flux measurements provide a useful test of cosmological models?
• The Chandra view of the relation between X-ray and UV emission in quasars
• Observational signatures of end-dominated collapse in the S242 filamentary structure
• Quasars as high-redshift standard candles
• On Problems with Cosmography in Cosmic Dark Ages
• Cosmological Evolution of Fermi-LAT Gamma-ray Blazars Using Novel Nonparametric Methods
• The X-ray Luminosity Function Evolution of Quasars and the Correlation Between the X-ray and Ultraviolet Luminosities
• The Mid-Infrared Luminosity Evolution and Luminosity Function of Quasars with SDSS and WISE

Cited by in corpus (17)

• Gamma-Ray Bursts, Quasars, Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations, and Supernovae Ia: new statistical insights and cosmological constraints
• $H_0=69.8\pm 1.3$ $\mathrm{km}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}\mathrm{Mp}{\mathrm{c}}^{-1}$, ${\Omega }_{m0}=0.288\pm 0.017$, and other constraints from lower-redshift, non-CMB, expansion-rate data
• $\Lambda$CDM Tensions: Localising Missing Physics through Consistency Checks
• Testing AGN outflow and accretion models with CIV and HeII emission line demographics in z=2 quasars
• Reducing the uncertainty on the Hubble constant up to 35\% with an improved statistical analysis: different best-fit likelihoods for Supernovae Ia, Baryon Acoustic Oscillations, Quasars, and Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Quasar UV/X-ray relation luminosity distances are shorter than reverberation-measured radius-luminosity relation luminosity distances
• Current data are consistent with flat spatial hypersurfaces in the $\Lambda$CDM cosmological model but favor more lensing than the model predicts
• Does DESI DR2 challenge $\Lambda$CDM paradigm ?
• Effect of extinction on quasar luminosity distances determined from UV and X-ray flux measurements
• Quasars as Standard Candles IV. Analysis of the X-ray and UV indicators of the disc-corona relation
• Redshift-evolutionary X-ray and UV luminosity relation of quasars from Gaussian copula
• Effects of heterogeneous data sets and time-lag measurement techniques on cosmological parameter constraints from MgII and CIV reverberation-mapped quasar data
• Testing the standardizability of, and deriving cosmological constraints from, a new Amati-correlated gamma-ray burst data compilation
• Low- and high-redshift H II starburst galaxies obey different luminosity-velocity dispersion relations
• Are quasars reliable standard candles?
• Tilted non-spatially-flat inflation
• Testing the consistency of new Amati-correlated gamma-ray burst dataset cosmological constraints with those from better-established cosmological data