Understanding the systematic differences in extractions of the proton electric form factors at low-$Q^2$

Abstract

Systematic differences exist between values of the proton's electric form factors in the low-$Q^2$ region extracted by different experimental and theoretical groups, though they are all making use of basically the same electron-proton scattering data. To try understand the source of these differences, we make use of the analytically well-behaved rational (N=1, M=1) function, a predictive function that can be reasonably used for extrapolations at $Q^2\to 0$. First, we test how well this deceptively simple two-parameter function describes the extremely complex and state-of-the-art dispersively improved chiral effective field theory calculations. Second, we carry out a complete re-analysis of the 34 sets of eletron-proton elastic scattering cross-section data of the Mainz A1 Collaboration with its unconstrained 31 normalization parameters up to $Q^2=0.5(GeV/c{)}^2$. We find that subtle shifts in the normalization parameters can result in relatively large changes in the extracted physical qualities. In conclusion, we show that by simply using a well-behaved analytic function, the apparent discrepancy between recent form-factor extractions can be resolved.

arXiv comment8 pages, 4 figures and 1 table

References in corpus (41)

• The ratio of proton's electric to magnetic form factors measured by polarization transfer
• Measurement of GEp/GMp in ep -> ep to Q2 = 5.6 GeV2
• High-precision determination of the electric and magnetic form factors of the proton
• Nucleon Electromagnetic Form Factors
• Two-photon exchange and elastic electron-proton scattering
• The electric and magnetic form factors of the proton
• Global analysis of proton elastic form factor data with two-photon exchange corrections
• Precision Rosenbluth measurement of the proton elastic form factors
• Recoil Polarization Measurements of the Proton Electromagnetic Form Factor Ratio to Q^2 = 8.5 GeV^2
• Nucleon electromagnetic form factors
• Measurements of electron-proton elastic cross sections for $0.4<Q^2<5.5(GeV/c{)}^2$
• High Precision Measurement of the Proton Elastic Form Factor Ratio ${\mu }_p{G}_E/G_M$ at low $Q^2$
• Final Analysis of Proton Form Factor Ratio Data at ${\mathbf{Q}}^2=4.0$, 4.8 and 5.6 GeV${}^2$
• Extraction of the proton radius from electron-proton scattering data
• The proton charge radius
• Proton radii and two-photon exchange
• Are Electron Scattering Data Consistent with a Small Proton Radius?
• The Proton Radius from Electron Scattering Data
• Subtracted dispersion relation formalism for the two-photon exchange correction to elastic electron-proton scattering: comparison with data
• Reduction of the proton radius discrepancy by 3 sigma
• Proton charge radius extraction from electron scattering data using dispersively improved chiral effective field theory
• High-precision determination of the electric and magnetic radius of the proton
• Two-photon exchange correction in elastic unpolarized electron-proton scattering at small momentum transfer
• Precise determination of proton magnetic radius from electron scattering data
• Proton radius from electron-proton scattering and chiral perturbation theory
• Polynomial fits and the proton radius puzzle
• Fresh extraction of the proton charge radius from electron scattering
• Revisiting the proton-radius problem using constrained Gaussian processes
• Robust extraction of proton charge radius from electron-proton scattering data
• Form Factors and Two-Photon Exchange in High-Energy Elastic Electron-Proton Scattering
• Nucleon form factors in dispersively improved Chiral Effective Field Theory I: Scalar form factor
• Nucleon form factors in dispersively improved Chiral Effective Field Theory II: Electromagnetic form factors
• Accurate nucleon electromagnetic form factors from dispersively improved chiral effective field theory
• How Analytic Choices Can Affect the Extraction of Electromagnetic Form Factors from Elastic Electron Scattering Cross Section Data
• Nonidentical protons
• Proton Form Factor Ratio, ${\mu }_p{G}_E^p/G_M^p$ from Double Spin Asymmetry
• Advanced extraction of the deuteron charge radius from electron-deuteron scattering data
• Transverse charge density and the radius of the proton
• Two-photon exchange correction in elastic lepton-proton scattering
• Elastic Positron-Proton Scattering at Low Q${}^2$
• Differential Cross Section Predictions for PRad-II from Dispersion Theory

Cited by in corpus (1)

• Nucleon relativistic polarization and magnetization distributions