On the Co-Orbitation of Satellite Galaxies Along the Great Plane of Andromeda: NGC 147, NGC 185, and Expectations from Cosmological Simulations

Abstract

Half of the satellite galaxies of Andromeda form a narrow plane termed the Great Plane of Andromeda (GPoA), and their line-of-sight velocities display correlation reminiscent of a rotating structure. Recently reported first proper motion measurements for the on-plane satellites NGC 147 and NGC 185 indicate that they indeed co-orbit along the GPoA. This provides a novel opportunity to compare the M31 satellite system to $\Lambda$CDM expectations. We perform the first detailed comparison of the orbital alignment of two satellite galaxies beyond the Milky Way with several hydrodynamical and dark-matter-only cosmological simulations (Illustris TNG-50, TNG-100, ELVIS, PhatELVIS), in the context of the Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem. In line with previous works, we find that the spatial flattening and line-of-sight velocity correlation alone is already in substantial tension with $\Lambda$CDM, with none of the simulated analogs simultaneously reproducing both parameters. Almost none (3 to 4\%) of the simulated systems contain two satellites with orbital poles as well aligned with their satellite plane as indicated by the most-likely proper motions of NGC 147 and NGC 185. However, within current measurement uncertainties it is common (~70%) that the two best-aligned satellites of simulated systems are consistent with the orbital alignment. Yet, the chance that any two simulated on-plane satellites have as well aligned orbital poles as observed is low (~4%). We conclude that confirmation of the tight orbital alignment for these two objects via improved measurements, or the discovery of similar alignments for additional GPoA members, hold the potential to further raise the tension with $\Lambda$CDM expectations.

arXiv comment27 pages, 13 figures, 5 tables, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (82)

• SciPy 1.0--Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python
• Array Programming with NumPy
• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• Binary companions of evolved stars in APOGEE DR14: Search method and catalog of ~5,000 companions
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: matter and galaxy clustering
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: the stellar mass content of groups and clusters of galaxies
• Small-Scale Challenges to the $\Lambda$CDM Paradigm
• First Results from the TNG50 Simulation: Galactic outflows driven by supernovae and black hole feedback
• First Results from the TNG50 Simulation: The evolution of stellar and gaseous disks across cosmic time
• Cats and Dogs, Hair and A Hero: A Quintet of New Milky Way Companions
• Gaia Data Release 2: Kinematics of globular clusters and dwarf galaxies around the Milky Way
• Eight New Milky Way Companions Discovered in First-Year Dark Energy Survey Data
• The Faintest Dwarf Galaxies
• Beasts of the Southern Wild: Discovery of nine Ultra Faint satellites in the vicinity of the Magellanic Clouds
• Eight Ultra-faint Galaxy Candidates Discovered in Year Two of the Dark Energy Survey
• A Vast Thin Plane of Co-rotating Dwarf Galaxies Orbiting the Andromeda Galaxy
• Third-Epoch Magellanic Cloud Proper Motions I: HST/WFC3 data and Orbit Implications
• The great disk of Milky-Way satellites and cosmological sub-structures
• Not so lumpy after all: modeling the depletion of dark matter subhalos by Milky Way-like galaxies
• ELVIS: Exploring the Local Volume in Simulations
• The M31 Velocity Vector. II. Radial Orbit Towards the Milky Way and Implied Local Group Mass
• Gaia DR2 Proper Motions of Dwarf Galaxies within 420 kpc: Orbits, Milky Way Mass, Tidal Influences, Planar Alignments, and Group Infall
• The SAGA Survey: I. Satellite Galaxy Populations Around Eight Milky Way Analogs
• Sagittarius II, Draco II and Laevens 3: three new Milky Way satellites discovered in the Pan-STARRS 1 3pi Survey
• The SAGA Survey. II. Building a Statistical Sample of Satellite Systems around Milky Way-like Galaxies
• A whirling plane of satellite galaxies around Centaurus A challenges cold dark matter cosmology
• PAndAS' progeny: extending the M31 dwarf galaxy cabal
• Dwarf Galaxy Planes: the discovery of symmetric structures in the Local Group
• The Orbital Histories of Magellanic Satellites Using Gaia DR2 Proper Motions
• A Bayesian Approach to Locating the Red Giant Branch Tip Magnitude (Part II); Distances to the Satellites of M31
• The rotationally stabilized VPOS and predicted proper motions of the Milky Way satellite galaxies
• Co-orbiting satellite galaxy structures are still in conflict with the distribution of primordial dwarf galaxies
• The orbital poles of Milky Way satellite galaxies: a rotationally supported disc-of-satellites
• The Three-Dimensional Structure of the M31 Satellite System; Strong Evidence for an Inhomogeneous Distribution of Satellites
• Gaia Proper Motions and Orbits of the Ultra-Faint Milky Way Satellites
• PAndAS' cubs: discovery of two new dwarf galaxies in the surroundings of the Andromeda and Triangulum galaxies
• Two Planes of Satellites in the Centaurus A Group
• The Missing Satellites of the Magellanic Clouds? Gaia Proper Motions of the Recently Discovered Ultra-Faint Galaxies
• Discovery of two neighboring satellites in the Carina constellation with MagLiteS
• The Space Motion of Leo I: Hubble Space Telescope Proper Motion and Implied Orbit
• Phat ELVIS: The inevitable effect of the Milky Way's disk on its dark matter subhaloes
• The discovery of seven extremely low surface brightness galaxies in the field of the nearby spiral galaxy M101
• The Milky Way's Disk of Classical Satellite Galaxies in Light of Gaia DR2
• Limit on the LMC mass from a census of its satellites
• DGSAT: Dwarf Galaxy Survey with Amateur Telescopes I. Discovery of low surface brightness systems around nearby spiral galaxies
• A thousand shadows of Andromeda: rotating planes of satellites in the Millennium-II cosmological simulation
• First Gaia Dynamics of the Andromeda System: DR2 Proper Motions, Orbits, and Rotation of M31 and M33
• A Lonely Giant: The Sparse Satellite Population of M94 Challenges Galaxy Formation
• Planes of satellite galaxies: when exceptions are the rule
• Discs of Satellites: the new dwarf spheroidals
• Wide-Field Survey of Dwarf Satellite Systems Around 10 Hosts in the Local Volume
• Lacerta I and Cassiopeia III: Two luminous and distant Andromeda satellite dwarf galaxies found in the 3π Pan-STARRS1 survey
• Gaia EDR3 proper motions of Milky Way dwarfs I: 3D Motions and Orbits
• The new Milky Way satellites: alignment with the VPOS and predictions for proper motions and velocity dispersions
• Discovery of a close pair of faint dwarf galaxies in the halo of Centaurus A
• The M101 group complex: new dwarf galaxy candidates and spatial structure
• The dwarf galaxy satellite system of Centaurus A
• On the persistence of two small-scale problems in ΛCDM
• Planes of satellites around Milky Way/M31-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations and comparisons with the Local Group
• The Leo-I group: new dwarf galaxy and UDG candidates
• The coherent motion of Cen A dwarf satellite galaxies remains a challenge for $\Lambda$CDM cosmology
• HST Proper Motions of NGC 147 and NGC 185: Orbital Histories and Test of Dynamically Coherent Andromeda Satellite Plane
• Vast planes of satellites in a high resolution simulation of the Local Group: comparison to Andromeda
• New Low Surface Brightness Dwarf Galaxies Detected Around Nearby Spirals
• Perseus I: A distant satellite dwarf galaxy of Andromeda
• A comparison of the distribution of satellite galaxies around Andromeda and the results of $\Lambda$CDM simulations
• Space Motions of the Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies Draco and Sculptor based on HST Proper Motions with ~10-year Time Baseline
• Dwarf Galaxy Discoveries from the KMTNet Supernova Program I. The NGC 2784 Galaxy Group
• Evolution of galactic planes of satellites in the EAGLE simulation
• Simulated ΛCDM analogues of the thin Plane of Satellites around the Andromeda galaxy are not kinematically coherent structures
• The Role of Baryons in Creating Statistically Significant Planes of Satellites around Milky Way-Mass Galaxies
• The Transverse velocity of the Andromeda system, derived from the M31 satellite population
• The LBT Satellites of Nearby Galaxies Survey (LBT-SONG): The Satellite Population of NGC 628
• HST/ACS Direct Ages of the Dwarf Elliptical Galaxies NGC 147 and NGC 185
• The alignment of SDSS satellites with the VPOS: effects of the survey footprint shape
• The proper motion of Andromeda from Gaia eDR3: confirming a nearly radial orbit
• On the Stability of Satellite Planes I: Effects of Mass, Velocity, Halo Shape and Alignment
• Proper Motion of the Draco Dwarf Galaxy Based On Hubble Space Telescope Imaging
• A Collection of New Dwarf Galaxies in NGC5128's Western Halo
• Do halos that form early, have high concentration, are part of a pair, or contain a central galaxy potential host more pronounced planes of satellite galaxies?
• Considerations on how to investigate planes of satellite galaxies
• Proper Motions of the Satellites of M31

Cited by in corpus (13)

• From galactic bars to the Hubble tension: weighing up the astrophysical evidence for Milgromian gravity
• The distribution and morphologies of Fornax Cluster dwarf galaxies suggest they lack dark matter
• 3D hydrodynamic simulations for the formation of the Local Group satellite planes
• The satellite galaxy plane of NGC 4490 in light of ΛCDM - Sparsity of similarly extreme analogs and a possible role of satellite pairs
• Classifying the satellite plane membership of Centaurus A's dwarf galaxies using orbital alignment constraints
• New dwarf galaxy candidates in the sphere of influence of the Sombrero galaxy
• HubPUG: Proper Motions for Local Group Dwarfs observed with HST utilizing Gaia as a Reference Frame
• Mass Modeling the Andromeda Dwarf Galaxies: Andromeda VI and Andromeda XXIII
• A Study of the Properties and Dynamics of the Disk of Satellites in a Milky-Way-like Galaxy System
• Andromeda's asymmetric satellite system as a challenge to cold dark matter cosmology
• IFUM Integrated Field Spectroscopy of Ten M104 Satellite Galaxy Candidates
• Testing a proposed "planarity" tool for studying satellite systems: On the alleged consistency of Milky Way satellite galaxy planes with $\Lambda$CDM
• The Cen A galaxy group: dynamical mass and missing baryons