Testing a proposed "planarity" tool for studying satellite systems: On the alleged consistency of Milky Way satellite galaxy planes with $\Lambda$CDM

Abstract

The existence of planes of satellite galaxies has been identified as a long-standing challenge to $\Lambda$CDM cosmology, due to the rarity of satellite systems in cosmological simulations that are as extremely flattened and as strongly kinematically correlated as observed structures. Here we investigate a recently proposed new metric to measure the overall degree of ''planarity'' of a satellite system, which was used to claim consistency between the Milky Way satellite plane and $\Lambda$CDM. We study the behavior of the ''planarity'' metric under several features of anisotropy present in $\Lambda$CDM satellite systems but unrelated to satellite planes. Specifically, we consider the impact of oblate or prolate distributions, the number of satellites, clustering of satellites, and radial and asymmetric distributions ('lopsidedness'). We also investigate whether the metric is independent of the orientation of the studied satellite system. We find that all of these features of anisotropy result in the metric inferring an increased degree of ''planarity'', despite none of them having any direct relation to satellite planes. The metric is also highly sensitive to the orientation of the studied system (or chosen coordinate system): there is almost no correlation between the metric's reported degrees of ''planarity'' for identical random systems rotated by 90°. Our results demonstrate that the new proposed metric is unsuitable to measure overall ''planarity'' in satellite systems. Consequently, no consistency of the observed Milky Way satellite plane with $\Lambda$CDM can be inferred using this metric.

10 pages, 11 figures, submitted to A&A, in response to arXiv:2411.17813

References in corpus (54)

• The Shape of Dark Matter Halos: Dependence on Mass, Redshift, Radius, and Formation
• A Vast Thin Plane of Co-rotating Dwarf Galaxies Orbiting the Andromeda Galaxy
• The great disk of Milky-Way satellites and cosmological sub-structures
• Internal and External Alignment of the Shapes and Angular Momenta of LCDM Halos
• The VPOS: a vast polar structure of satellite galaxies, globular clusters and streams around the Milky Way
• Introducing the NewHorizon simulation: Galaxy properties with resolved internal dynamics across cosmic time
• Luminosity function and radial distribution of Milky Way Satellites in a LCDM Universe
• A whirling plane of satellite galaxies around Centaurus A challenges cold dark matter cosmology
• Confirmation of Faint Dwarf Galaxies in the M81 Group
• Dwarf Galaxy Planes: the discovery of symmetric structures in the Local Group
• The Orbital Histories of Magellanic Satellites Using Gaia DR2 Proper Motions
• Sweating the small stuff: simulating dwarf galaxies, ultra-faint dwarf galaxies, and their own tiny satellites
• Co-orbiting satellite galaxy structures are still in conflict with the distribution of primordial dwarf galaxies
• The Three-Dimensional Structure of the M31 Satellite System; Strong Evidence for an Inhomogeneous Distribution of Satellites
• Gaia early DR3 systemic motions of Local Group dwarf galaxies and orbital properties with a massive Large Magellanic Cloud
• Two Planes of Satellites in the Centaurus A Group
• The Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem, Suggested Solutions, and Open Questions
• Phat ELVIS: The inevitable effect of the Milky Way's disk on its dark matter subhaloes
• A profile in FIRE: resolving the radial distributions of satellite galaxies in the Local Group with simulations
• The Milky Way's Disk of Classical Satellite Galaxies in Light of Gaia DR2
• Limit on the LMC mass from a census of its satellites
• A thousand shadows of Andromeda: rotating planes of satellites in the Millennium-II cosmological simulation
• Probing the Intrinsic Shape and Alignment of Dark Matter Haloes using SDSS Galaxy Groups
• Discovery of a close pair of faint dwarf galaxies in the halo of Centaurus A
• On the persistence of two small-scale problems in ΛCDM
• Planes of satellites around Milky Way/M31-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations and comparisons with the Local Group
• The Spatial Distribution of Galactic Satellites in the LCDM Cosmology
• The Hubble Space Telescope Survey of M31 Satellite Galaxies I. RR Lyrae-based Distances and Refined 3D Geometric Structure
• The coherent motion of Cen A dwarf satellite galaxies remains a challenge for $\Lambda$CDM cosmology
• On the shape of dark matter halos from MultiDark Planck simulations
• The Frequency of Dwarf Galaxy Multiples at Low Redshift in SDSS vs. Cosmological Expectations
• HST Proper Motions of NGC 147 and NGC 185: Orbital Histories and Test of Dynamically Coherent Andromeda Satellite Plane
• Tracing satellite planes in the Sculptor group: I. Discovery of three faint dwarf galaxies around NGC 253
• Evolution of galactic planes of satellites in the EAGLE simulation
• The lopsided distribution of satellite galaxies
• The Lopsidedness of Satellite Galaxy Systems in $\Lambda$CDM simulations
• Co-orbiting planes of sub-halos are similarly unlikely around paired and isolated hosts
• Galaxy Pairs in the Local Group
• On the Co-Orbitation of Satellite Galaxies Along the Great Plane of Andromeda: NGC 147, NGC 185, and Expectations from Cosmological Simulations
• Do halos that form early, have high concentration, are part of a pair, or contain a central galaxy potential host more pronounced planes of satellite galaxies?
• Considerations on how to investigate planes of satellite galaxies
• Lopsided Satellite Distributions around Isolated Host Galaxies
• A co-rotating gas and satellite structure around the interacting galaxy pair NGC 4490/85
• On the Effect of the Large Magellanic Cloud on the Orbital Poles of Milky Way Satellite Galaxies
• A portrait of the Vast Polar Structure as a young phenomenon: hints from its member satellites
• The lopsided distribution of satellites of isolated central galaxies
• We are not the 99 percent: quantifying asphericity in the distribution of Local Group satellites
• The satellite galaxy plane of NGC 4490 in light of ΛCDM - Sparsity of similarly extreme analogs and a possible role of satellite pairs
• Binary Satellite Galaxies
• Classifying the satellite plane membership of Centaurus A's dwarf galaxies using orbital alignment constraints
• Satellite group infall into the Milky Way: exploring the Crater-Leo case with new HST proper motions
• Lopsided Satellite Distributions around Isolated Host Galaxies in a LCDM Universe
• Lopsided distribution of MATLAS and ELVES dwarf satellite systems around isolated host galaxies
• Is there a dwarf galaxy satellite-of-satellite problem in $\Lambda$CDM?