Evidence for lensing of gravitational waves from LIGO-Virgo

Abstract

Recently, the LIGO-Virgo Collaboration (LVC) concluded that there is no evidence for lensed gravitational waves (GW) in the first half of the O3 run, claiming "We find the observation of lensed events to be unlikely, with the fractional rate at $\mu >2$ being $3.3\times 10^{-4}$". While we agree that the chance of an individual GW event being lensed at $\mu >2$ is smaller than $10^{-3}$, the number of observed events depends on the product of this small probability times the rate of mergers at high redshift. Observational constraints from the stochastic GW background indicate that the rate of conventional mass BBH mergers (8 < M (M${}_{\odot }$) < 15) in the redshift range 1<z< 2 could be as high as O($10^7$) events per year, more than sufficient to compensate for the intrinsically low probability of lensing. To reach the LVC trigger threshold these events require high magnification, but would still produce up to 10 to 30 LVC observable events per year. Thus, all the LVC observed ordinary stellar mass BBH mergers from this epoch must be strongly lensed. By adopting low-rates at high redshift, LVC assumes that lensed events can not be taking place, thus incorrectly assigning them a closer distance and higher masses by a factor of a few (typically 2 to 5). The LVC adopted priors on time delay are in tension with the distribution of observed time delays in lensed quasars. Pairs of events like GW190421-GW190910 and GW190424-GW190910, which are directly assigned a probability of zero by LVC, should be instead considered as prime candidates to be strongly lensed GW pairs, since their separation in time is consistent with observations of time delays in lensed quasars. Correcting for the LVC wrong Bayesian priors, maximum merger rate of conventional mass BBH in 1<z<2, and gravitational lensing time-delay model, reverses the LVC conclusions and supports the strong gravitational lensing hypothesis.

8 pages with 3 figures. Added new figure 3. Matches version accepted by Phys. Rev. D

References in corpus (3)

• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The Detection of a Population of Submillimeter-Bright, Strongly-Lensed Galaxies
• Strong lensing optical depths in a \LambdaCDM universe

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Gravitational wave lensing as a probe of halo properties and dark matter
• Strongly Lensed Transient Sources: A Review
• Discovering gravitationally lensed gravitational waves: predicted rates, candidate selection, and localization with the Vera Rubin Observatory
• Gravitational Lensing by Black Holes with Multiple Photon Spheres
• Exploring the Impact of Microlensing on Gravitational Wave Signals: Biases, Population Characteristics, and Prospects for Detection
• Microlensing of gravitational waves by dark matter structures
• Amplitude and phase fluctuations of gravitational waves magnified by strong gravitational lensing
• Detecting Strong Gravitational Lensing of Gravitational Waves with TianQin
• Measuring the Hubble Constant Using Strongly Lensed Gravitational Wave Signals
• Multi-messenger Gravitational Lensing
• Deep Learning-based Search for Microlensing Signature from Binary Black Hole Events in GWTC-1 and -2
• Constraining changes in the merger history of (P)BH binaries with the stochastic gravitational wave background
• GLANCE -- Gravitational Lensing Authenticator using Non-Modelled Cross-Correlation Exploration of Gravitational Wave Signals
• Observable Signatures of RN Black Holes with Dark Matter Halos via Strong Gravitational Lensing and Constraints from EHT Observations
• Parameter estimation of microlensed gravitational waves with Conditional Variational Autoencoders
• What is the nature of GW230529? An exploration of the gravitational lensing hypothesis
• $\mu$-GLANCE: A Novel Technique to Detect Chromatically and Achromatically Lensed Gravitational Wave Signals
• Identifying Strongly Lensed Gravitational Waves with the Third-generation Detectors
• Fundamental Physics and Cosmology with TianQin
• Gravitational Lensing in More Realistic Dark Matter Halo Models
• Mitigating the effect of the population model uncertainty on the strong lensing Bayes factor using nonparametric methods
• Toward Gravitational Lensing in Modified Theories of Gravity
• Possible discrimination of black hole origins from the lensing rate of DECIGO and B-DECIGO sources
• Probing cosmic strings via gravitational-wave lensing
• Across the Universe: GW231123 as a magnified and diffracted black hole merger
• Could the high-mass black holes from gravitational-wave observations be explained by lensing?