Depth of shower maximum and mass composition of cosmic rays from 50 PeV to 2 EeV measured with the LOFAR radio telescope

Abstract

We present an updated cosmic-ray mass composition analysis in the energy range $10^{16.8}$ to $10^{18.3}$ eV from 334 air showers measured with the LOFAR radio telescope, and selected for minimal bias. In this energy range, the origin of cosmic rays is expected to shift from galactic to extragalactic sources. The analysis is based on an improved method to infer the depth of maximum $X_{\max }$ of extensive air showers from radio measurements and air shower simulations. We show results of the average and standard deviation of $X_{\max }$ versus primary energy, and analyze the $X_{\max }$-dataset at distribution level to estimate the cosmic ray mass composition. Our approach uses an unbinned maximum likelihood analysis, making use of existing parametrizations of $X_{\max }$-distributions per element. The analysis has been repeated for three main models of hadronic interactions. Results are consistent with a significant light-mass fraction, at best fit $23$ to $39$ $\%$ protons plus helium, depending on the choice of hadronic interaction model. The fraction of intermediate-mass nuclei dominates. This confirms earlier results from LOFAR, with systematic uncertainties on $X_{\max }$ now lowered to 7 to $9$ $g/c{\mathrm{m}}^2$. We find agreement in mass composition compared to results from Pierre Auger Observatory, within statistical and systematic uncertainties. However, in line with earlier LOFAR results, we find a slightly lower average $X_{\max }$. The values are in tension with those found at Pierre Auger Observatory, but agree with results from other cosmic ray observatories based in the Northern hemisphere.

arXiv comment24 pages, 14 figures. Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D

References in corpus (33)

• LOFAR: The LOw-Frequency ARray
• EPOS LHC : test of collective hadronization with LHC data
• Cosmic ray event generator Sibyll 2.1
• Measurements of the Cosmic Ray Composition with Air Shower Experiments
• Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurements at Energies above 10^17.8 eV
• One-dimensional Hybrid Approach to Extensive Air Shower Simulation
• Hadronic interaction model Sibyll 2.3d and extensive air showers
• Trigger and Aperture of the Surface Detector Array of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Monte Carlo simulations of radio pulses in atmospheric showers using ZHAireS
• Simulating radio emission from air showers with CoREAS
• Radio detection of cosmic ray air showers in the digital era
• A large light-mass component of cosmic rays at 10^{17} - 10^{17.5} eV from radio observations
• A Macroscopic Description of Coherent Geo-Magnetic Radiation from Cosmic Ray Air Showers
• A method for high precision reconstruction of air shower Xmax using two-dimensional radio intensity profiles
• Measurement of the Radiation Energy in the Radio Signal of Extensive Air Showers as a Universal Estimator of Cosmic-Ray Energy
• Detecting cosmic rays with the LOFAR radio telescope
• Cosmic-ray energy spectrum and composition up to the ankle - the case for a second Galactic component
• General description of electromagnetic radiation processes based on instantaneous charge acceleration in `endpoints'
• A parameterization for the radio emission of air showers as predicted by CoREAS simulations and applied to LOFAR measurements
• Simulation of Radiation Energy Release in Air Showers
• LORA: A scintillator array for LOFAR to measure extensive air showers
• The Cosmic-Ray Composition between 2 PeV and 2 EeV Observed with the TALE Detector in Monocular Mode
• The radio emission pattern of air showers as measured with LOFAR - a tool for the reconstruction of the energy and the shower maximum
• Final Results from the High Resolution Fly's Eye (HiRes) Experiment
• Measurement of the circular polarization in radio emission from extensive air showers confirms emission mechanisms
• Reinterpreting the development of extensive air showers initiated by nuclei and photons
• Determination of the absolute energy scale of extensive air showers via radio emission: systematic uncertainty of underlying first-principle calculations
• Calibration of the LOFAR low-band antennas using the Galaxy and a model of the signal chain
• The effect of the atmospheric refractive index on the radio signal of extensive air showers
• Reconstructing air shower parameters with LOFAR using event specific GDAS atmospheres
• Measurement of the cosmic-ray energy spectrum above $10^{16}$ eV with the LOFAR Radboud Air Shower Array
• On the cosmic-ray energy scale of the LOFAR radio telescope
• Recent results from the Pierre Auger Observatory

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays: The Intersection of the Cosmic and Energy Frontiers
• Radio Measurements of the Depth of Air-Shower Maximum at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Demonstrating Agreement between Radio and Fluorescence Measurements of the Depth of Maximum of Extensive Air Showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• TAROGE-M: Radio Antenna Array on Antarctic High Mountain for Detecting Near-Horizontal Ultra-High Energy Air Showers
• A high-precision interpolation method for pulsed radio signals from cosmic-ray air showers
• Framework and Tools for the Simulation and Analysis of the Radio Emission from Air Showers at IceCube
• Determination of the Cosmic-Ray Chemical Composition: Open Issues and Prospects
• Science with the Global Cosmic-ray Observatory (GCOS)
• Status of the Yakutsk air shower array and future plans
• Double and multiple bangs at tau neutrino telescopes: A novel probe of sphalerons with cosmogenic neutrinos
• Exploring the role of composition and mass-loading on the properties of hadronic jets
• Reconstructing Air Shower Parameters with MGMR3D
• Study of longitudinal development of air showers in the knee energy range
• A LOFAR-style reconstruction of cosmic-ray air showers with SKA-Low
• Measuring temporal characteristics of the Cherenkov radiation signal from extensive air showers of cosmic rays with a wide field-of-view telescope addendum to the Yakutsk array
• A Probabilistic Model for the Efficiency of Cosmic-Ray Radio Arrays
• Is Dark Energy an Effective Manifestation of Non-equilibrium Thermodynamics? -- Insights from DESI
• A Bayesian Method for Air-Shower Reconstruction using Information Field Theory
• Uncertainties in the Estimation of Air Shower Observables from Monte Carlo Simulation of Radio Emission