Uncertainties in the Estimation of Air Shower Observables from Monte Carlo Simulation of Radio Emission

Abstract

The detection of extensive air showers (EAS) induced by cosmic rays via radio signals has undergone significant advancements in the last two decades. Numerous ultra-high energy cosmic ray experiments routinely capture radio pulses in the MHz to GHz frequency range emitted by EAS. The Monte Carlo simulation of these radio pulses is crucial to enable an accurate reconstruction of the primary cosmic ray energy and to infer the composition of the primary particles. In this work, a comprehensive comparison of the predicted electric field in EAS simulated with CoREAS and ZHAireS was conducted to estimate the systematic uncertainties arising from the use of different simulation packages in the determination of two key shower observables namely, the electromagnetic energy of the EAS and the depth of maximum development ($X_{\max }$). For this comparison, input parameters and settings as similar as possible were used in both simulations, along with the same realistic atmospheric refractive index depending on altitude, which is crucial for the prediction of radio emission properties of EAS. In addition, simulated EAS with very similar values of depth of maximum development were selected. Good agreement was found between CoREAS and ZHAireS, with discrepancies in the dominant electric field components generally remaining below 10\% across the frequency range of a few MHz to hundreds of MHz, relevant for most radio detection experiments, translating into uncertainties in the determination of energy below $5\%$ and $\simeq 10g/c{\mathrm{m}}^2$ in $X_{\max }$. Our work underscores the need for further studies to clarify their origin and impact on $X_{\max }$ inference in composition analyses.

arXiv comment24 pages, 11 figures, version accepted in Astroparticle Physics

References in corpus (34)

• EPOS LHC : test of collective hadronization with LHC data
• Monte Carlo treatment of hadronic interactions in enhanced Pomeron scheme: I. QGSJET-II model
• Hadronic interaction model Sibyll 2.3d and extensive air showers
• Monte Carlo simulations of radio pulses in atmospheric showers using ZHAireS
• Radio detection of Cosmic-Ray Air Showers and High-Energy Neutrinos
• Simulating radio emission from air showers with CoREAS
• A large light-mass component of cosmic rays at 10^{17} - 10^{17.5} eV from radio observations
• A method for high precision reconstruction of air shower Xmax using two-dimensional radio intensity profiles
• Energy Estimation of Cosmic Rays with the Engineering Radio Array of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Measurement of the Radiation Energy in the Radio Signal of Extensive Air Showers as a Universal Estimator of Cosmic-Ray Energy
• Probing the radio emission from air showers with polarization measurements
• General description of electromagnetic radiation processes based on instantaneous charge acceleration in `endpoints'
• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays: The Intersection of the Cosmic and Energy Frontiers
• Coherent Cherenkov Radiation from Cosmic-Ray-Induced Air Showers
• Polarized radio emission from extensive air showers measured with LOFAR
• Simulation of Radiation Energy Release in Air Showers
• Cherenkov radio pulses from electromagnetic showers in the time-domain
• Measuring a Cherenkov ring in the radio emission from air showers at 110-190 MHz with LOFAR
• Radio measurements of the energy and the depth of the shower maximum of cosmic-ray air showers by Tunka-Rex
• Observation of inclined EeV air showers with the radio detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Determination of the calorimetric energy in extensive air showers
• Depth of shower maximum and mass composition of cosmic rays from 50 PeV to 2 EeV measured with the LOFAR radio telescope
• Reconstruction of cosmic ray air showers with Tunka-Rex data using template fitting of radio pulses
• Determination of the absolute energy scale of extensive air showers via radio emission: systematic uncertainty of underlying first-principle calculations
• Theory and simulations of air shower radio emission
• Radio Measurements of the Depth of Air-Shower Maximum at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Calculations of electric fields for radio detection of Ultra-High Energy particles
• Demonstrating Agreement between Radio and Fluorescence Measurements of the Depth of Maximum of Extensive Air Showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• The SLAC T-510 experiment for radio emission from particle showers: detailed simulation study and interpretation
• Determination of cosmic-ray primary mass on an event-by-event basis using radio detection
• Density and magnetic intensity dependence of radio pulses induced by energetic air showers
• Simulating radio emission from particle cascades with CORSIKA 8
• A LOFAR-style reconstruction of cosmic-ray air showers with SKA-Low
• Characterization of Atmosphere-Skimming Cosmic-Ray Showers in High-Altitude Experiments