The Age of Westerlund 1 Revisited

Abstract

The cluster Westerlund~1 (Wd1) is host to a large variety of post main-sequence (MS) massive stars. The simultaneous presence of these stars can only be explained by stellar models if the cluster has a finely-tuned age of 4-5Myr, with several published studies independently claiming ages within this range. At this age, stellar models predict that the cool supergiants (CSGs) should have luminosities of $\log (L/L_{\odot })\approx 5.5$, close to the empirical luminosity limit. Here, we test that prediction using archival data and new photometry from SOFIA to estimate bolometric luminosities for the CSGs. We find that these stars are on average 0.4dex too faint to be 5Myr old, regardless of which stellar evolution model is used, and instead are indicative of a much older age of $10.4_{-1.2}^{+1.3}$Myr. We argue that neither systematic uncertainties in the extinction law nor stellar variability can explain this discrepancy. In reviewing various independent age estimates of Wd1 in the literature, we firstly show that those based on stellar diversity are unreliable. Secondly, we re-analyse Wd1's pre-MS stars employing the Damineli extinction law, finding an age of $7.2_{-2.3}^{+1.1}$Myr; older than that of previous studies, but which is vulnerable to systematic errors that could push the age close to 10Myr. However, there remains significant tension between the CSG age and that inferred from the eclipsing binary W13. We conclude that stellar evolution models cannot explain Wd1 under the single age paradigm. Instead, we propose that the stars in the Wd1 region formed over a period of several Myr.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ. 15 pages, 9 figures

References in corpus (47)

• The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I: Solar-Scaled Models
• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the construction of stellar isochrones
• Reevaluating Old Stellar Populations
• Stellar evolution with rotation X: Wolf-Rayet star populations at solar metallicity
• Interstellar Extinction Law toward the Galactic Center III: J, H, Ks bands in the 2MASS and the MKO systems, and 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, 8.0 micron in the Spitzer/IRAC system
• Early Science with SOFIA, the Stratospheric Observatory for Infrared Astronomy
• On the massive stellar population of the Super Star Cluster Westerlund 1
• A census of the Wolf-Rayet content in Westerlund 1 from near-infrared imaging and spectroscopy
• A new mass-loss rate prescription for red supergiants
• The temperatures of Red Supergiants
• The Initial Masses of the Red Supergiant Progenitors to Type-II Supernovae
• Intermediate to low-mass stellar content of Westerlund 1
• The cool supergiant population of the massive young star cluster RSGC1
• The luminosities of cool supergiants in the Magellanic Clouds, and the Humphreys-Davidson limit revisited
• First Science Observations with SOFIA/FORCAST: The FORCAST Mid-infrared Camera
• Age Determination in Upper Scorpius with Eclipsing Binaries
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey. XXIX. Massive star formation in the local 30 Doradus starburst
• Are pre-main-sequence stars older than we thought?
• Mass segregation and elongation of the starburst cluster Westerlund 1
• Instantaneous starburst of the massive clusters Westerlund 1 and NGC 3603 YC
• Late-Type Red Supergiants: Too Cool for the Magellanic Clouds?
• Exciting the Magnetosphere of the Magnetar CXOU J164710.2-455216 in Westerlund 1
• A serendipitous survey for variability amongst the massive stellar population of Westerlund 1
• Extinction law in the range 0.4-4.8 $\mu$m and the 8620 $\mathring{A}$ DIB towards the stellar cluster Westerlund 1
• Spectroscopic monitoring of the luminous blue variable Westerlund1-243 from 2002 to 2009
• Variability of Young Massive Stars in the Galactic Super Star Cluster Westerlund 1
• The very low-mass stellar content of the young supermassive Galactic star cluster Westerlund 1
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey. XXX. Red stragglers in the clusters Hodge 301 and SL 639
• Medium resolution 2.3 micron spectroscopy of the massive Galactic open cluster Westerlund 1
• Discrepancies in the ages of young star clusters; evidence for mergers?
• Red supergiant stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud. II. Infrared properties and mid-infrared variability
• The Optical/Near-Infrared Extinction Law In Highly Reddened Regions
• Unlocking Galactic Wolf-Rayet stars with $\text{Gaia}$ DR2 II: Cluster and Association membership
• The Period-Luminosity Relations of Red Supergiants in M33 and M31
• Stellar models and isochrones from low-mass to massive stars including pre-main sequence phase with accretion
• Fundamental Parameters of four Massive Eclipsing Binaries in Westerlund 1
• The Fundamental Parameters of Four Massive Eclipsing Binaries in Westerlund 1
• An ALMA 3mm continuum census of Westerlund 1
• The distances to star-clusters hosting Red Supergiants: $\chi$ Per, NGC 7419, and Westerlund 1
• A VLT/FLAMES survey for massive binaries in Westerlund 1: VII. Cluster census
• Inferring the parallax of Westerlund 1 from Gaia DR2
• Stellar Population Diagnostics of the Massive Star Binary Fraction
• Maser Observations of Westerlund 1 and Comprehensive Considerations on Maser Properties of Red Supergiants Associated with Massive Clusters
• A Comparison of Rotating and Binary Stellar Evolution Models: Effects on Massive Star Populations
• On aging star clusters using red supergiants independent of the fraction of interacting binary stars

Cited by in corpus (29)

• A deep spectromorphological study of the $\gamma$-ray emission surrounding the young massive stellar cluster Westerlund 1
• Grids of stellar models with rotation VII: Models from 0.8 to 300 M${}_{\odot }$ at super-solar metallicity (Z = 0.020)
• Gamma rays as probes of cosmic-ray propagation and interactions in galaxies
• Multiplicity of Galactic Luminous Blue Variable stars
• Establishing a mass-loss rate relation for red supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Inside the core of a young massive star cluster: 3D MHD simulations
• A UV census of the environments of stripped-envelope supernovae
• Understanding the TeV $\gamma$-ray emission surrounding the young massive star cluster Westerlund 1
• Westerlund 1 under the light of Gaia EDR3: Distance, isolation, extent, and a hidden population
• Extreme broad He\2 emission at high and low redshifts: the dominant role of VMS in NGC 3125-A1 and CDFS131717
• The effect of mass loss in models of red supergiants in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• The early evolution of young massive clusters: The kinematic history of NGC6611 / M16
• Distance and age of the massive stellar cluster Westerlund 1. I. Parallax method using Gaia-EDR3
• Survey of near-infrared diffuse interstellar bands in $Y$ and $J$ bands. I. Newly identified bands
• The impact of convective criteria on the properties of massive stars
• The landscape of binary core-collapse supernova progenitors and the late emergence of Wolf-Rayet winds
• Cosmic rays from massive star clusters : A close look at Westerlund 1
• The Demographics of Binary Companions to Stripped-Envelope Supernovae: Confronting Observations with Population Synthesis
• Comparing the Locations of Supernovae to CO (2-1) Emission in their Host Galaxies
• The temperatures of red supergiants in low metallicity environments
• X-ray emission from Westerlund 2 detected by SRG/ART-XC and Chandra: search for radiation of TeV leptons
• Distance and age of the massive stellar cluster Westerlund 1. II. The eclipsing binary W36
• Don't believe the hype(r): The Yellow Supergiants of Westerlund 1
• Investigating dusty Red Supergiant outflows in Westerlund 1 with 3D Hydrodynamic simulations
• A cosmic-ray loaded nascent outflow driven by a massive star cluster
• Structure and Dynamics of the Young Massive Star Cluster Westerlund 1
• The extreme scarcity of dust-enshrouded red supergiants: consequences for producing stripped stars via winds
• Morphology of Young Massive Stellar Clusters with Next-Generation IACTs
• EWOCS-V: Is Wd1-72 a recent post-interaction WR+O binary?