The temperatures of Red Supergiants

Abstract

We present a re-appraisal of the temperatures of Red Supergiants (RSGs) using their optical and near-infrared spectral energy distributions (SEDs). We have obtained data of a sample of RSGs in the Magellanic Clouds using VLT+XSHOOTER, and we fit MARCS model atmospheres to different regions of the spectra, deriving effective temperatures for each star from (a) the TiO bands, (b) line-free continuum regions of the spectral energy distributions (SEDs), and (c) the integrated fluxes. We show that the temperatures derived from fits to the TiO bands are systematically {\it lower} than the other two methods by several hundred Kelvin. The TiO fits also dramatically over-predict the flux in the near-IR, and imply extinctions which are anomalously low compared to neighbouring stars. In contrast, the SED temperatures provide good fits to the fluxes at all wavelengths other than the TiO bands, are in agreement with the temperatures from the flux integration method, and imply extinctions consistent with nearby stars. After considering a number of ways to reconcile this discrepancy, we conclude that 3-D effects (i.e.\ granulation) are the most likely cause, as they affect the temperature structure in the upper layers where the TiO lines form. The continuum, however, which forms at much deeper layers, is apparently more robust to such effects. We therefore conclude that RSG temperatures are much warmer than previously thought. We discuss the implications of this result for stellar evolution and supernova progenitors, and provide relations to determine the bolometric luminosities of RSGs from single-band photometry.

21 pages, 26 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (16)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• The death of massive stars - I. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type II-P supernovae
• The effect of massive binaries on stellar populations and supernova progenitors
• The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars: Evolution of surface N abundances and effective temperature scales in the Galaxy and Magellanic Clouds
• The Effective Temperatures and Physical Properties of Magellanic Cloud Red Supergiants: The Effects of Metallicity
• Variability in red supergiant stars: pulsations, long secondary periods and convection noise
• A massive cluster of Red Supergiants at the base of the Scutum-Crux arm
• Spitzer SAGE-SMC Infrared Photometry of Massive Stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Discovery of an Extraordinarily Massive Cluster of Red Supergiants
• Chemical Abundances of Luminous Cool Stars in the Galactic Center from High-Resolution Infrared Spectroscopy
• Late-Type Red Supergiants: Too Cool for the Magellanic Clouds?
• VLT detection of a red supergiant progenitor of the type IIP supernova 2008bk
• Near-IR Spectra of Red Supergiants and Giants. I- Models with Solar and with Mixing-Induced Surface Abundance Ratios
• Diffuse interstellar bands in RAVE Survey spectra
• The Period-Luminosity Relation of Red Supergiant Stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• A red supergiant nebula at 25 micron: arcsecond scale mass-loss asymmetries of mu Cep

Cited by in corpus (111)

• Observational constraints on the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae : the case for missing high mass stars
• The ExoMol database: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other hot atmospheres
• Grids of stellar models with rotation - III. Models from 0.8 to 120 Msun at a metallicity Z = 0.002
• ExoMol Molecular linelists -- XXXIII. The spectrum of Titanium Oxide
• An excess of massive stars in the local 30 Doradus starburst
• High Resolution Study of Presupernova Compactness
• Type II-Plateau supernova radiation: dependencies on progenitor and explosion properties
• A new mass-loss rate prescription for red supergiants
• Measuring the Progenitor Masses and Dense Circumstellar Material of Type II Supernovae
• Fundamental properties of core-collapse Supernova and GRB progenitors: predicting the look of massive stars before death
• The Initial Masses of the Red Supergiant Progenitors to Type-II Supernovae
• The spectroscopic Hertzsprung-Russell diagram of Galactic massive stars
• The impact of mass-loss on the evolution and pre-supernova properties of red supergiants
• A comparison of evolutionary tracks for single Galactic massive stars
• Constraining mixing in massive stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• The luminosities of cool supergiants in the Magellanic Clouds, and the Humphreys-Davidson limit revisited
• The `Red Supergiant Problem': the upper luminosity boundary of type-II supernova progenitors
• SN2023ixf in Messier 101: A Variable Red Supergiant as the Progenitor Candidate to a Type II Supernova
• Evolution of blue supergiants and αCygni variables; Puzzling CNO surface abundances
• The Type II-Plateau Supernova 2017eaw in NGC 6946 and Its Red Supergiant Progenitor
• Standing on the shoulders of giants: New mass and distance estimates for Betelgeuse through combined evolutionary, asteroseismic, and hydrodynamical simulations with MESA
• The evolution of Red Supergiants to supernova in the LMC cluster NGC 2100
• On the photometric and spectroscopic diversity of Type II supernovae
• The X-Shooter Spectral Library (XSL): Data Release 2
• Red Supergiant Stars as Cosmic Abundance Probes: KMOS Observations in NGC 6822
• Betelgeuse Just Isn't That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse
• Stellar atmospheric parameters for 754 spectra from the X-shooter Spectral Library
• Red Supergiant Stars as Cosmic Abundance Probes. III. NLTE effects in J-band Magnesium lines
• The Photospheric Temperatures of Betelgeuse during the Great Dimming of 2019/2020: No New Dust Required
• The surface abundances of Red Supergiants at core-collapse
• An LTE effective temperature scale for red supergiants in the Magellanic clouds
• Red Supergiants as Cosmic Abundance Probes: The Magellanic Clouds
• Evolved Massive Stars at Low-metallicity V. Mass-Loss Rate of Red Supergiant Stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Red Supergiants as Cosmic Abundance Probes: The Sculptor Galaxy NGC 300
• Discovery of a red supergiant donor star in SN2010da/NGC 300 ULX-1
• Evolved Massive Stars at Low-metallicity I. A Source Catalog for the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Variability of Red Supergiants in M31 from the Palomar Transient Factory
• IRC-10414: a bow-shock-producing red supergiant star
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey. XXX. Red stragglers in the clusters Hodge 301 and SL 639
• Atmosphere of Betelgeuse before and during the Great Dimming event revealed by tomography
• Discovery of a red supergiant counterpart to RX~J004722.4-252051, a ULX in NGC 253
• Carbon stars in the X-shooter Spectral Library
• Evolutionary models of red supergiants: Evidence for a metallicity-dependent mixing length and implications for Type IIP supernova progenitors
• Catching a star before explosion: the luminous blue variable progenitor of SN 2015bh
• The Age of Westerlund 1 Revisited
• A sequence of Type Ib, IIb, II-L, and II-P supernovae from binary-star progenitors of varying initial separation
• Exploring the Mass Loss Histories of the Red Supergiants
• Progenitor candidate for the type II-P supernova SN 2018aoq in NGC 4151
• Red supergiant stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud. II. Infrared properties and mid-infrared variability
• Spectral type, temperature and evolutionary stage in cool supergiants
• Establishing a mass-loss rate relation for red supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Searching for GC-like abundance patterns in young massive clusters
• GIANO-TNG spectroscopy of red supergiants in the young star cluster RSGC2
• Quantitative Spectroscopic J-band Study of Red Supergiants in Perseus OB-1
• Evolved Massive Stars at Low-metallicity III. A Source Catalog for the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Identification of red supergiants in nearby galaxies with mid-IR photometry
• Evolved Massive Stars at Low-metallicity II. Red Supergiant Stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Chemistry and Kinematics of Red Supergiant Stars in the Young Massive Cluster NGC 2100
• Multiplicity of the red supergiant population in the young massive cluster NGC 330
• The Great Dimming of Betelgeuse seen by the Himawari-8 meteorological satellite
• Red Supergiants in M31: The Humphreys-Davidson limit at high metallicity
• Physical properties of the first spectroscopically confirmed red supergiant stars in the Sculptor Group galaxy NGC 55
• The impact of winds on the spectral appearance of Red Supergiants
• Effective temperatures of red supergiants estimated from line-depth ratios of iron lines in the YJ bands, 0.97--1.32 micron
• VdBH 222: a starburst cluster in the inner Milky Way
• Stellar population astrophysics (SPA) with the TNG. GIANO-B spectroscopy of red supergiants in Alicante 7 and Alicante 10
• Cool, Luminous, and Highly Variable Stars in the Magellanic Clouds from ASAS-SN: Implications for Thorne-Żytkow Objects and Super-Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars
• A critical re-evaluation of the Thorne-Żytkow object candidate HV 2112
• Chemical abundances of two extragalactic young massive clusters
• Type II-P Supernova Progenitor Star Initial Masses and SN 2020jfo: Direct Detection, Light Curve Properties, Nebular Spectroscopy, and Local Environment
• The Optical to Infrared Extinction Law of Magellanic Clouds Based on Red Supergiant and Classical Cepheid
• A comparison between X-shooter spectra and PHOENIX models across the HR-diagram
• Distance and age of the massive stellar cluster Westerlund 1. I. Parallax method using Gaia-EDR3
• Red Supergiant Candidates for Multimessenger Monitoring of the Next Galactic Supernova
• A systematic study of super-Eddington layers in the envelopes of massive stars
• The mass-loss rates of red supergiants at low metallicity: Detection of rotational CO emission from two red supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Identification of dusty massive stars in star-forming dwarf irregular galaxies in the Local Group with mid-IR photometry
• Searching for GC-like abundance patterns in young massive clusters II. - Results from the Antennae galaxies
• GIANO-TNG spectroscopy of red supergiants in the young star cluster RSGC3
• Evolved Massive Stars at Low-metallicity IV. Using 1.6 $\mu$m "H-bump" to identify red supergiant stars: a case study of NGC 6822
• Physical parameters of red supergiants in dwarf irregular galaxies in the Local Group
• On Granulation and Irregular Variation of Red Supergiants
• Long Term Evolution of Surface Features on the Red Supergiant AZ Cyg
• Revisiting the progenitor of the low-luminosity type II-plateau supernova, SN 2008bk
• The Evolution of Massive Stars: Bridging the Gap in the Local Group
• Red supergiant stars in binary systems. I. Identification and characterisation in the Small Magellanic Cloud from the UVIT ultraviolet imaging survey
• The red supergiant population in the Perseus arm
• Near Infrared spectroscopic indices for unresolved stellar populations. I. Template galaxy spectra
• Properties of luminous red supergiant stars in the Magellanic Clouds
• Red Supergiants in the JWST Era. I: Near-IR Photometric Diagnostics
• Investigating the metallicity dependence of the mass-loss rate relation of red supergiants
• The temperatures of red supergiants in low metallicity environments
• Investigating episodic mass loss in evolved massive stars: II. Physical properties of red supergiants at subsolar metallicity
• Episodic mass loss in the very luminous red supergiant [W60] B90 in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Dust Buried Compact Sources in the Dwarf Galaxy NGC 4449
• The effect of winds on atmospheric layers of red supergiants I. Modelling for interferometric observations
• Red supergiant stars in IC 1613 and metallicity-dependent mixing length in the evolutionary model
• The Main Sequence of three Red Supergiant Clusters
• Detection of new O-type stars in the obscured stellar cluster Tr 16-SE in the Carina Nebula with KMOS
• NLTE 1.5D Modeling of Red Giant Stars
• Unveiling the evolutionary state of three B supergiant stars: PU Gem, $\epsilon$ CMa and $\eta$ CMa
• V838 Mon: A slow waking up of Sleeping Beauty?
• Investigating episodic mass loss in evolved massive stars: III. Spectroscopy of dusty massive stars in three northern galaxies
• Chemical composition of the young massive cluster NGC 1569-B
• Spectroscopic analysis of cool giants and supergiants
• Red Supergiants in the Milky Way and Nearby Galaxies
• Red Supergiants -- The Other Side of the H-R Diagram
• Modeling the near-UV band of GK stars, Paper III: Dependence on abundance pattern
• Testing Evolutionary Models with Red Supergiant and Wolf-Rayet Populations
• Carbon stars in the X-Shooter Spectral Library: II. Comparison with models
• The extreme scarcity of dust-enshrouded red supergiants: consequences for producing stripped stars via winds