The Photospheric Temperatures of Betelgeuse during the Great Dimming of 2019/2020: No New Dust Required

Abstract

The processes that shape the extended atmospheres of red supergiants (RSGs), heat their chromospheres, create molecular reservoirs, drive mass loss, and create dust remain poorly understood. Betelgeuse's V-band "Great Dimming" event of 2019 September /2020 February and its subsequent rapid brightening provides a rare opportunity to study these phenomena. Two different explanations have emerged to explain the dimming; new dust appeared in our line of sight attenuating the photospheric light, or a large portion of the photosphere had cooled. Here we present five years of Wing three-filter (A, B, and C band) TiO and near-IR photometry obtained at the Wasatonic Observatory. These reveal that parts of the photosphere had a mean effective temperature $(T_{\mathrm{eff}}$) significantly lower than that found by (Levesque & Massey 2020). Synthetic photometry from MARCS -model photospheres and spectra reveal that the V band, TiO index, and C-band photometry, and previously reported 4000-6800 Angstrom spectra can be quantitatively reproduced if there are multiple photospheric components, as hinted at by VLT-SPHERE images (Montarges et al. 2020). If the cooler component has $\Delta T_{\mathrm{eff}}\ge 250$ K cooler than 3650 K, then no new dust is required to explain the available empirical constraints. A coincidence of the dominant short- ($\sim 430$ day) and long-period ($\sim 5.8$ yr) V-band variations occurred near the time of deep minimum (Guinan et al. 2019). This is in tandem with the strong correlation of V mag and photospheric radial velocities, recently reported by Dupree et al. (2020b). These suggest that the cooling of a large fraction of the visible star has a dynamic origin related to the photospheric motions, perhaps arising from pulsation or large-scale convective motions.

Accepted ApJ - 19 pages, 5 figures

References in corpus (14)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• Variability in red supergiant stars: pulsations, long secondary periods and convection noise
• Standing on the shoulders of giants: New mass and distance estimates for Betelgeuse through combined evolutionary, asteroseismic, and hydrodynamical simulations with MESA
• The close circumstellar environment of Betelgeuse - V. Rotation velocity and molecular envelope properties from ALMA
• What causes the large extensions of red-supergiant atmospheres? Comparisons of interferometric observations with 1-D hydrostatic, 3-D convection, and 1-D pulsating model atmospheres
• Betelgeuse Just Isn't That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse
• Spatially Resolved Ultraviolet Spectroscopy of the Great Dimming of Betelgeuse
• The period-luminosity relation of red supergiants with Gaia DR2
• Tomography of cool giant and supergiant star atmospheres II. Signature of convection in the atmosphere of the red supergiant star $\mu$ Cep
• The Secret Lives of Cepheids: $\delta$ Cep -- the Prototype of a New Class of Pulsating X-ray Variable Stars
• The inhomogeneous sub-millimeter atmosphere of Betelgeuse
• Betelgeuse fainter in the sub-millimetre too: an analysis of JCMT and APEX monitoring during the recent optical minimum
• ALMA and VLA reveal the lukewarm chromospheres of the nearby red supergiants Antares and Betelgeuse
• SOFIA-EXES Observations of Betelgeuse during the Great Dimming of 2019/2020

Cited by in corpus (42)

• Has NANOGrav found first evidence for cosmic strings?
• The Threshold for Primordial Black Hole Formation: a Simple Analytic Prescription
• Orbital Evolution of Equal-mass Eccentric Binaries due to a Gas Disk: Eccentric Inspirals and Circular Outspirals
• Astrophysics Milestones For Pulsar Timing Array Gravitational Wave Detection
• A dusty veil shading Betelgeuse during its Great Dimming
• NANOGrav results and LIGO-Virgo primordial black holes in axion-like curvaton model
• NANOGrav signal from MHD turbulence at QCD phase transition in the early universe
• On the gravitational wave sources from the NANOGrav 12.5-yr data
• Primordial black hole dark matter in dilaton-extended two-field Starobinsky inflation
• Sound speed resonance of the stochastic gravitational wave background
• Atmosphere of Betelgeuse before and during the Great Dimming event revealed by tomography
• The Great Dimming of Betelgeuse: a Surface Mass Ejection (SME) and its Consequences
• Implications of the NANOGrav result on primordial gravitational waves in nonstandard cosmologies
• The QCD Axion and Gravitational Waves in light of NANOGrav results
• The Mass-Loss History of the Red Hypergiant VY CMa
• Post-Merger Jets from Supermassive Black Hole Coalescences as Electromagnetic Counterparts of Gravitational Wave Emission
• The Great Dimming of Betelgeuse seen by the Himawari-8 meteorological satellite
• Higher-Curvature Corrections and Tensor Modes
• The impact of winds on the spectral appearance of Red Supergiants
• Shining Primordial Black Holes
• Searching for Gravitational Waves with Strongly Lensed Repeating Fast Radio Bursts
• Frequentist versus Bayesian analyses: Cross-correlation as an (approximate) sufficient statistic for LIGO-Virgo stochastic background searches
• An Exceptional Dimming Event for a Massive, Cool Supergiant in M51
• Analysis of photometric and spectroscopic variability of red supergiant Betelgeuse
• The Search for Binary Supermassive Black Holes Amongst Quasars with Offset Broad Lines Using the Very Long Baseline Array
• Rescaled Einstein-Hilbert Gravity: Inflation and the Swampland Criteria
• Stellar models of Betelgeuse constrained using observed surface conditions
• Gravitational wave cosmology I: high frequency approximation
• The Great Dimming of Betelgeuse: the photosphere as revealed by tomography over the past 15 years
• Images of Betelgeuse with VLTI/MATISSE across the Great Dimming
• The dusty circumstellar environment of Betelgeuse during the Great Dimming as seen by VLTI/MATISSE
• UBVRI photometry of Betelgeuse over 23 years since 1999
• Spectroscopic evidence for a large spot on the dimming Betelgeuse
• The effect of winds on atmospheric layers of red supergiants II. Modelling VLTI/GRAVITY and MATISSE observations of AH Sco, KW Sgr, V602 Car, CK Car and V460 Car
• Spatially Resolved Observations of Betelgeuse at 7mm and 1.3cm Just Prior to the Great Dimming
• Earth-mass primordial black hole mergers as sources for non-repeating FRBs
• Chromospheric activity and photospheric variation of $\alpha$ Ori during the great dimming event in 2020
• Impact of hypermagnetic fields on relic gravitational waves, neutrino oscillations and baryon asymmetry
• Betelgeuse's Buddy: X-Ray Constraints on the Nature of $\alpha$ Ori B
• Evaluating Low-Frequency Pulsar Observations to Monitor Dispersion with the Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope
• An estimate of the gravitational-wave background from the observed cosmological distribution of quasars
• The variability of Betelgeuse explained by surface convection