Can different black holes cast the same shadow?

Abstract

We consider the following question: may two different black holes (BHs) cast exactly the same shadow? In spherical symmetry, we show the necessary and sufficient condition for a static BH to be shadow-degenerate with Schwarzschild is that the dominant photonsphere of both has the same impact parameter, when corrected for the (potentially) different redshift of comparable observers in the different spacetimes. Such shadow-degenerate geometries are classified into two classes. The first shadow-equivalent class contains metrics whose constant (areal) radius hypersurfaces are isometric to those of the Schwarzschild geometry, which is illustrated by the Simpson and Visser (SV) metric. The second shadow-degenerate class contains spacetimes with different redshift profiles and an explicit family of metrics within this class is presented. In the stationary, axi-symmetric case, we determine a sufficient condition for the metric to be shadow degenerate with Kerr for far-away observers. Again we provide two classes of examples. The first class contains metrics whose constant (Boyer-Lindquist-like) radius hypersurfaces are isometric to those of the Kerr geometry, which is illustrated by a rotating generalization of the SV metric, obtained by a modified Newman-Janis algorithm. The second class of examples pertains BHs that fail to have the standard north-south ${\mathbb{Z}}_2$ symmetry, but nonetheless remain shadow degenerate with Kerr. The latter provides a sharp illustration that the shadow is not a probe of the horizon geometry. These examples illustrate that nonisometric BH spacetimes can cast the same shadow, albeit the lensing is generically different.

arXiv commentMatches the version published in Physical Review D, title changed, typos corrected, 16 pages, 8 figures

References in corpus (33)

• Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
• First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole
• First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI. The Shadow and Mass of the Central Black Hole
• First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. V. Physical Origin of the Asymmetric Ring
• Viewing the Shadow of the Black Hole at the Galactic Center
• Shadows and strong gravitational lensing: a brief review
• Shadows of Kerr black holes with scalar hair
• Rotating Charged Black Hole Solution in Heterotic String Theory
• Light ring stability in ultra-compact objects
• Generating rotating regular black hole solutions without complexification
• Black-bounce to traversable wormhole
• Stationary black holes and light rings
• The Rotating Dyonic Black Holes Of Kaluza-Klein Theory
• Chaotic lensing around boson stars and Kerr black holes with scalar hair
• Shadows of Kerr black holes with and without scalar hair
• Fundamental photon orbits: black hole shadows and spacetime instabilities
• Black hole shadow in a general rotating spacetime obtained through Newman-Janis algorithm
• A novel family of rotating black hole mimickers
• Asymptotic safety casts its shadow
• Does the black hole shadow probe the event horizon geometry?
• What does a binary black hole merger look like?
• Constraining alternatives to the Kerr black hole
• Preserving Kerr symmetries in deformed spacetimes
• General parametrization of black holes: the only parameters that matter
• Rotating black holes without ${\mathbb{Z}}_2$ symmetry and their shadow images
• Black Hole Shadows and Invariant Phase Space Structures
• Scalar absorption: Black holes versus wormholes
• The Fingerprints of Black Holes - Shadows and their Degeneracies
• Spinning black holes with a separable Hamilton-Jacobi equation from a modified Newman-Janis algorithm
• Isolated black holes without ${\mathbb{Z}}_2$ isometry
• Global embedding of the Kerr black hole event horizon into hyperbolic 3-space
• Scalar Fields and Parametrized Spherically Symmetric Black Holes: Can one hear the shape of space-time?
• Black holes with surrounding matter and rainbow scattering

Cited by in corpus (77)

• Horizon-scale tests of gravity theories and fundamental physics from the Event Horizon Telescope image of Sagittarius A${}^{\ast }$
• Nonlinear electrodynamics effects on the black hole shadow, deflection angle, quasinormal modes and greybody factors
• Charged black-bounce spacetimes
• Constraining a modified gravity theory in strong gravitational lensing and black hole shadow observations
• Photon Spheres and Spherical Accretion Image of a Hairy Black Hole
• Imaging compact boson stars with hot-spots and thin accretion disks
• Strong gravitational lensing by rotating Simpson--Visser black holes
• Shadows and rings of the Kehagias-Sfetsos black hole surrounded by thin disk accretion
• Shadows and lensing of black holes immersed in strong magnetic fields
• Shadows of black holes with dark matter halo
• Scalar perturbations around rotating regular black holes and wormholes: quasi-normal modes, ergoregion instability and superradiance
• Analytical study of higher-order ring images of accretion disk around black hole
• On black bounces, wormholes and partly phantom scalar fields
• Can supermassive black hole shadows test the Kerr metric?
• Gravitational Footprints of Black Holes and Their Microstate Geometries
• Image features of spinning regular black holes based on a locality principle
• Kerr black holes with synchronised Proca hair: lensing, shadows and EHT constraints
• Black hole surrounded by the pseudo-isothermal dark matter halo
• Shape of higher-order images of equatorial emission rings around a Schwarzschild black hole: Analytical description with polar curves
• Retrolensing by two photon spheres of a black-bounce spacetime
• Testing black hole mimickers with the Event Horizon Telescope image of Sagittarius A${}^{\ast }$
• Photon rings as tests for alternative spherically symmetric geometries with thin accretion disks
• Separating Astrophysics and Geometry in Black Hole Images
• Light rings and long-lived modes in quasi-black hole spacetimes
• Universal signatures of singularity-resolving physics in photon rings of black holes and horizonless objects
• Charged black-bounce spacetimes: Photon rings, shadows and observational appearances
• Conservation of distortion of gravitationally lensed images
• AdS-Taub-NUT spacetimes and exact black bounces with scalar hair
• Parameterizations of black-hole spacetimes beyond circularity
• On Detecting Equatorial Symmetry Breaking with LISA
• Cylindrical black bounces and their field sources
• Eikonal quasinormal modes and photon orbits of deformed Schwarzschild black holes
• Black Bounces with multiple throats and anti-throats
• Constraining spherically symmetric metrics by the gap between photon rings
• Lifetime of scalar cloud formation around a rotating regular black hole
• Asymmetric wormholes in Palatini $f(\mathcal{R})$ gravity: Energy conditions, absorption and quasibound states
• Optical appearance of a thin-shell wormhole with a Hayward profile
• Regularising the JNW and JMN naked singularities
• Parameterized non-relativistic limit of stellar structure equations in Ricci-based gravity theories
• Gravitational lensing of massive particles by a black-bounce-Schwarzschild black hole
• Testing black hole equatorial reflection symmetry using Sgr A* shadow images
• Thermodynamic properties of Quantum-Corrected AdS Black Hole with Phantom Global Monopoles
• Evaporation of a Kerr-black-bounce by emission of scalar particles
• Newman-Janis algorithm's application to regular black hole models
• Rotating Black Hole in Kalb-Ramond Gravity: Constraining Parameters by Comparison with EHT Observations of Sgr A* and M87*
• Supergravity Black Holes, Love Numbers and Harmonic Coordinates
• Is a black hole shadow a reliable test of the no-hair theorem?
• Scalar scattering by black holes and wormholes
• Dynamics of null particles and shadow for general rotating black hole
• Chaotic photon orbits and shadows of a non-Kerr object described by the Hartle-Thorne spacetime
• Superentropic Black Hole Shadows in Arbitrary Dimensions
• Spherically symmetric and static black bounces with multiple horizons, throats, and anti-throats in four dimensions
• The Existence and Distribution of Photon Spheres Near Spherically Symmetric Black Holes -- A Geometric Analysis
• Resonant orbits of rotating black holes beyond circularity: Discontinuity along parameter shift
• Neutrino pair annihilation above black-hole accretion disks in modified gravity
• Parametrized black holes: Scattering investigation
• Topological dyonic black holes of massive gravity with generalized quasitopological electromagnetism
• Arbitrary static, spherically symmetric space-times as solutions of scalar-tensor gravity
• Spectral lines of dirty wormholes
• Image of Quantum Improved Regular Kerr Black Hole and Parameter Constraints from EHT Observations
• Tidal Stretching and Compression in Black Bounce Backgrounds
• Fractal signatures of non-Kerr spacetimes in the shadow of light-ring bifurcations
• Observational features of reflection asymmetric black holes
• Scalar Quasinormal Modes of Rotating Regular Black Holes
• Shadows and optical appearance of black bounces illuminated by a thin accretion disk
• Is it possible to distinguish between different black hole solutions using the Shapiro time delay?
• Gravitational Black Hole Shadow Spectroscopy
• Shadow of higher dimensional collapsing dark star and blackhole
• Fluctuation theorems in general relativistic stochastic thermodynamics
• Exact plane symmetric black bounce with a perfect-fluid exterior obeying a linear equation of state
• Determining parameters of Kerr-Newman black holes by shadow observation from finite distance and spatial infinity
• General parametrization of wormhole spacetimes and its application to shadows and quasinormal modes
• Roche limit and stellar disruption in the Simpson--Visser spacetime
• Generalized black-bounces solutions in f(R) gravity and their field sources
• Optical and orbital characterization of spherically symmetric static black holes of self-gravitating new nonlinear electrodynamics model
• Remarks on the black hole shadows in Kerr-de Sitter space times
• Multi-ring images of thin accretion disk of a regular naked compact object