On safe post-selection for Bell tests with ideal detectors: Causal diagram approach

Abstract

Reasoning about Bell nonlocality from the correlations observed in post-selected data is always a matter of concern. This is because conditioning on the outcomes is a source of non-causal correlations, known as a selection bias, rising doubts whether the conclusion concerns the actual causal process or maybe it is just an effect of processing the data. Yet, even in the idealised case without detection inefficiencies, post-selection is an integral part of experimental designs, not least because it is a part of the entanglement generation process itself. In this paper we discuss a broad class of scenarios with post-selection on multiple spatially distributed outcomes. A simple criterion is worked out, called the all-but-one principle, showing when the conclusions about nonlocality from breaking Bell inequalities with post-selected data remain in force. Generality of this result, attained by adopting the high-level diagrammatic tools of causal inference, provides safe grounds for systematic reasoning based on the standard form of multipartite Bell inequalities in a wide array of entanglement generation schemes, without worrying about the dangers of selection bias. In particular, it can be applied to post-selection defined by single-particle events in each detection chanel when the number of particles in the system is conserved.

arXiv comment16 pages, 9 figures

References in corpus (40)

• Bell nonlocality
• Integrated Photonic Quantum Technologies
• Multi-photon entanglement and interferometry
• Advances in High Dimensional Quantum Entanglement
• Boson sampling with 20 input photons in 60-mode interferometers at $10^{14}$ state spaces
• 12-photon entanglement and scalable scattershot boson sampling with optimal entangled-photon pairs from parametric down-conversion
• The lesson of causal discovery algorithms for quantum correlations: Causal explanations of Bell-inequality violations require fine-tuning
• Loopholes in Bell Inequality Tests of Local Realism
• Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
• Indistinguishability of elementary systems as resource for quantum information processing
• Entanglement by Path Identity
• Inferring causal structure: a quantum advantage
• The Two Bell's Theorems of John Bell
• A unifying framework for relaxations of the causal assumptions in Bell's theorem
• Two-photon Franson-type experiments and local realism
• Bell's Theorem and Locally-Mediated Reformulations of Quantum Mechanics
• Statistics, Causality and Bell's Theorem
• Postselection-loophole-free Bell violation with genuine time-bin entanglement
• Robust entanglement preparation against noise by controlling spatial indistinguishability
• Quantum violation of an instrumental test
• Experimental Test of Nonlocal Causality
• Demonstration of efficient scheme for generation of "Event Ready" entangled photon pairs from single photon source
• Experimental High-Dimensional Entanglement by Path Identity
• Experimental Bell inequality violation without the postselection loophole
• Causal modeling the delayed choice experiment
• Experimental control of remote spatial indistinguishability of photons to realize entanglement and teleportation
• Revisiting Bell's theorem for a class of down-conversion experiments
• $N$ identical particles and one particle to entangle them all
• Postselection-Loophole-Free Bell Test Over an Installed Optical Fiber Network
• Informationally symmetrical Bell state preparation and measurement
• Violations of locality and free choice are equivalent resources in Bell experiments
• Classical causal models for Bell and Kochen-Specker inequality violations require fine-tuning
• Entangling three qubits without ever touching
• Efficient generation of multipartite W state via quantum eraser
• Entangling Bosons through Particle Indistinguishability and Spatial Overlap
• Activating remote entanglement in a quantum network by local counting of identical particles
• Generating entanglement with linear optics
• Bell Experiments with Random Destination Sources
• Efficient linear optical generation of a multipartite W state
• Causal reappraisal of the quantum three box paradox