Causal modeling the delayed choice experiment
arXiv:1710.07323 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.190401
Abstract
Wave-particle duality has become one of the flagships of quantum mechanics. This counter-intuitive concept is highlighted in a delayed choice experiment, where the experimental setup that reveals either the particle or wave nature of a quantum system is decided after the system has entered the apparatus. Here we consider delayed choice experiments from the perspective of device-independent causal models and show their equivalence to a prepare-and-measure scenario. Within this framework, we consider Wheeler's original proposal and its variant using a quantum control and show that a simple classical causal model is capable of reproducing the quantum mechanical predictions. Nonetheless, among other results, we show that in a slight variant of Wheeler's Gedankenexperiment, a photon in an interferometer can indeed generate statistics incompatible with any non-retrocausal hidden variable model whose dimensionality is the same as that of the quantum system it is supposed to mimic. Our proposal tolerates arbitrary losses and inefficiencies making it specially suited to loophole-free experimental implementations.
arXiv comment5 pages (main text) + 2 pages (appendix), 4 figures. This version includes some simple corrections, and one new figure
References in corpus (19)
- Device-independent tests of classical and quantum dimensions
- Semi-device-independent security of one-way quantum key distribution
- A quantum delayed choice experiment
- Local deterministic model of singlet state correlations based on relaxing measurement independence
- Delayed-choice gedanken experiments and their realizations
- A self-testing quantum random number generator
- Entanglement-enabled delayed choice experiment
- Proposal for a quantum delayed-choice experiment
- A unifying framework for relaxations of the causal assumptions in Bell's theorem
- MHz-rate semi-device-independent quantum random number generators based on unambiguous state discrimination
- Experimental Device-independent Tests of Classical and Quantum Dimensions
- Certifying the dimension of classical and quantum systems in a prepare-and-measure scenario with independent devices
- Entanglement of photons in their dual wave-particle nature
- Experimental analysis of the quantum complementarity principle
- Quantifying Bell non-locality with the trace distance
- Device-Independent Tests of Entropy
- Is wave-particle objectivity compatible with determinism and locality?
- Restrictions for the Causal Inferences in an Interferometric System
- Determinism, independence and objectivity are incompatible
Cited by in corpus (29)
- Why interference phenomena do not capture the essence of quantum theory
- Experimental assessment of physical realism in a quantum-controlled device
- Proposal to Test Quantum Wave-Particle Superposition on Massive Mechanical Resonators
- Quantum wave-particle superposition in a delayed-choice experiment
- Device independent certification of a quantum delayed choice experiment
- Semi-device-independent certification of entanglement in superdense coding
- Realization of a causal-modeled delayed-choice experiment using single photons
- A loophole-free Wheeler-delayed-choice experiment
- Classical model of delayed-choice quantum eraser
- General Method for Classicality Certification in the Prepare and Measure Scenario
- Macroscopic delayed-choice and retrocausality: quantum eraser, Leggett-Garg and dimension witness tests with cat states
- Mesoscopic and macroscopic quantum correlations in photonic, atomic and optomechanical systems
- Quantum chicken-egg dilemmas: Delayed-choice causal order and the reality of causal non-separability
- Device-independent Verification of Quantum Coherence without Quantum Control
- Prepare-and-Magic: Semi-Device Independent Magic Certification in the Prepare-and-Measure Scenario
- Controlling wave-particle duality with quantum entanglement
- Weak versus deterministic macroscopic realism, and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen's elements of reality
- Causal reappraisal of the quantum three box paradox
- Modified quantum delayed-choice experiment without quantum control
- Experimental realization of Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment with dual selections
- General framework of quantum complementarity from a measurement-based perspective
- Encrypted quantum correlations: Delayed choice of quantum statistics and other applications
- Quantum key distribution based on the quantum eraser
- Nonclassicality of induced coherence witnessed by contextuality
- Unveiling quantum complementarity tradeoffs in relativistic scenarios
- Semi-device-independent randomness certification on discretized continuous-variable platforms
- On safe post-selection for Bell tests with ideal detectors: Causal diagram approach
- Forward-backward stochastic simulations: Q-based model for measurement and Bell-nonlocality consistent with weak local realistic premises
- Causal Emergence in Quantum Mechanics