Quantum chicken-egg dilemmas: Delayed-choice causal order and the reality of causal non-separability

Abstract

Recent frameworks describing quantum mechanics in the absence of a global causal order admit the existence of causally indefinite processes, where it is impossible to ascribe causal order for events A and B. These frameworks even allow for processes that violate the so-called causal inequalities, which are analogous to Bell's inequalities. However, the physicality of these exotic processes is, in the general case, still under debate, bringing into question their foundational relevance. While it is known that causally indefinite processes can be probabilistically realised by means of a quantum circuit, along with an additional conditioning event C, concrete insights into the ontological meaning of such implementation schemes have heretofore been limited. Here, we show that causally indefinite processes can be realised with schemes where C serves only as a classical flag heralding which causally indefinite process was realised. We then show that there are processes where any pure conditioning measurement of C leads to a causally indefinite process for A and B, thus establishing causal indefiniteness as a basis-independent quantity. Finally, we demonstrate that quantum mechanics allows for phenomena where C can deterministically decide whether A comes before B or vice versa, without signalling to either. This is akin to Wheeler's famous delayed-choice experiment establishing definite causal order in quantum mechanics as instrument-\textit{dependent} property.

arXiv comment14+6 pages, 4 figures. Close to published version

References in corpus (55)

• Quantum Computing in the NISQ era and beyond
• Quantum correlations with no causal order
• Quantum computations without definite causal structure
• Theoretical framework for quantum networks
• Quantum Circuits Architecture
• Non-Markovian quantum processes: complete framework and efficient characterisation
• Experimental Superposition of Orders of Quantum Gates
• Operational Markov condition for quantum processes
• Experimental Verification of an Indefinite Causal Order
• A quantum delayed choice experiment
• Quantum causal modelling
• Enhanced communication with the assistance of indefinite causal order
• Indefinite Causal Order in a Quantum Switch
• Exponential Communication Complexity Advantage from Quantum Superposition of the Direction of Communication
• Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
• Witnessing causal nonseparability
• Memory effects in quantum channel discrimination
• Inferring causal structure: a quantum advantage
• Causal and causally separable processes
• Experimental transmission of quantum information using a superposition of causal orders
• Experimental Quantum Switching for Exponentially Superior Quantum Communication Complexity
• Quantum superposition of the order of parties as a communication resource
• Bell's Theorem for Temporal Order
• Indefinite causal order enables perfect quantum communication with zero capacity channels
• Quantum Shannon theory with superpositions of trajectories
• The simplest causal inequalities and their violation
• Experimental Quantum Communication Enhancement by Superposing Trajectories
• Communication through coherent control of quantum channels
• Communicating via ignorance: Increasing communication capacity via superposition of order
• Computational advantage from quantum superposition of multiple temporal orders of photonic gates
• Communication through quantum-controlled noise
• Maximal incompatibility of locally classical behavior and global causal order in multi-party scenarios
• Resource theories of communication
• Communication Enhancement Through Quantum Coherent Control of $N$ Channels in an Indefinite Causal-order Scenario
• A purification postulate for quantum mechanics with indefinite causal order
• Quantum violation of an instrumental test
• Updating the Born rule
• Quantum computation with indefinite causal structures
• Operational quantum theory without predefined time
• Quantum-coherent mixtures of causal relations
• Causal modeling the delayed choice experiment
• Quantum communication in a superposition of causal orders
• Quantum speedup in the identification of cause-effect relations
• Entanglement, non-Markovianity, and causal non-separability
• Dynamics of quantum causal structures
• Connecting processes with indefinite causal order and multi-time quantum states
• Structure of temporal correlations of a qubit
• Superposition of causal order enables perfect quantum teleportation with very noisy singlets
• Causally nonseparable processes admitting a causal model
• Quantum superpositions of "common-cause" and "direct-cause" causal structures
• Quantum superpositions of causal orders as an operational resource
• Simulating extremal temporal correlations
• Structure of dimension-bounded temporal correlations
• A no-go theorem for superpositions of causal orders
• A time-reversible quantum causal model

Cited by in corpus (5)

• Genuine Multipartite Entanglement in Time
• Evading noise in multiparameter quantum metrology with indefinite causal order
• Reassessing thermodynamic advantage from indefinite causal order
• Breaking the limits of purification: Postselection enhances heat-bath algorithmic cooling
• Quantum theory cannot violate a causal inequality