Classical causal models for Bell and Kochen-Specker inequality violations require fine-tuning

Abstract

Nonlocality and contextuality are at the root of conceptual puzzles in quantum mechanics, and are key resources for quantum advantage in information-processing tasks. Bell nonlocality is best understood as the incompatibility between quantum correlations and the classical theory of causality, applied to relativistic causal structure. Contextuality, on the other hand, is on a more controversial foundation. In this work, I provide a common conceptual ground between nonlocality and contextuality as violations of classical causality. First, I show that Bell inequalities can be derived solely from the assumptions of no-signalling and no-fine-tuning of the causal model. This removes two extra assumptions from a recent result from Wood and Spekkens, and remarkably, does not require any assumption related to independence of measurement settings -- unlike all other derivations of Bell inequalities. I then introduce a formalism to represent contextuality scenarios within causal models and show that all classical causal models for violations of a Kochen-Specker inequality require fine-tuning. Thus the quantum violation of classical causality goes beyond the case of space-like separated systems, and manifests already in scenarios involving single systems.

9 pages, 14 figures. Modified title, discussion and presentation

References in corpus (7)

• A simple test for hidden variables in spin-1 system
• Experimentally testable state-independent quantum contextuality
• Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
• Information-Theoretic Implications of Quantum Causal Structures
• Theory-independent limits on correlations from generalised Bayesian networks
• A unifying framework for relaxations of the causal assumptions in Bell's theorem
• Logical Bell Inequalities

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Kolmogorov extension theorem for (quantum) causal modelling and general probabilistic theories
• Why initial system-environment correlations do not imply the failure of complete positivity: a causal perspective
• No-go theorem based on incomplete information of Wigner about his friend
• A Unifying Framework for Spatial and Temporal Quantum Correlations
• Causation does not explain contextuality
• Classical causal models cannot faithfully explain Bell nonlocality or Kochen-Specker contextuality in arbitrary scenarios
• A mathematical framework for operational fine tunings
• Contextuality, Fine-Tuning, and Teleological Explanation
• Experimentally adjudicating between different causal accounts of Bell inequality violations via statistical model selection
• Relating Wigner's Friend Scenarios to Nonclassical Causal Compatibility, Monogamy Relations, and Fine Tuning
• Wigner and friends, a map is not the territory! Contextuality in multi-agent paradoxes
• Extending the fair sampling assumption using causal diagrams
• Measuring the Mermin-Peres magic square using an online quantum computer
• Connecting extended Wigner's friend arguments and noncontextuality
• On safe post-selection for Bell tests with ideal detectors: Causal diagram approach
• Twenty years of quantum contextuality at USTC
• Quantum interpretations, causality and quantum computation
• Quantum causal models via QBism
• The standard no-signalling constraints in Bell scenarios are neither sufficient nor necessary for preventing superluminal signalling with general interventions
• Forward-backward stochastic simulations: Q-based model for measurement and Bell-nonlocality consistent with weak local realistic premises