Why initial system-environment correlations do not imply the failure of complete positivity: a causal perspective

Abstract

The common wisdom in the field of quantum information theory is that when a system is initially correlated with its environment, the map describing its evolution may fail to be completely positive. If true, this would have practical and foundational significance. We here demonstrate, however, that the common wisdom is mistaken. We trace the error to the standard argument for how the evolution map ought to be defined. We show that it sometimes fails to define a linear map or any map at all and that these pathologies persist even in completely classical examples. Drawing inspiration from the framework of classical causal models, we argue that the correct definition of the evolution map is obtained by considering a counterfactual scenario wherein the system is reprepared independently of any systems in its causal past while the rest of the circuit remains the same, yielding a map that is always completely positive. In a post-mortem on the standard argument, we highlight two distinct mistakes that retrospectively become evident (in its application to completely classical examples): (i) the types of constraints to which it appealed are constraints on what one can infer about the final state of a system based on its initial state, where such inferences are based not just on the cause-effect relation between them-which defines the correct evolution map-but also on the common cause of the two; (ii) in a (retrospectively unnecessary) attempt to introduce variability in the input state, it inadvertently introduced variability in the inference map itself, then tried to fit the input-output pairs associated to these different maps with a single map.

arXiv commentimproved discussion of relation with previous work. Comments encouraged!

References in corpus (53)

• Quantum correlations with no causal order
• Assessing non-Markovian dynamics
• Theoretical framework for quantum networks
• Non-Markovian quantum processes: complete framework and efficient characterisation
• The lesson of causal discovery algorithms for quantum correlations: Causal explanations of Bell-inequality violations require fine-tuning
• Vanishing quantum discord is necessary and sufficient for completely positive maps
• Dividing Quantum Channels
• Towards a Formulation of Quantum Theory as a Causally Neutral Theory of Bayesian Inference
• Operational Markov condition for quantum processes
• Quantum causal modelling
• Beyond Bell's Theorem: Correlation Scenarios
• Enhanced communication with the assistance of indefinite causal order
• Nonlinear quantum mechanics implies polynomial-time solution for NP-complete and #P problems
• Completely Positive Maps and Classical Correlations
• Quantum common causes and quantum causal models
• Dynamics of initially entangled open quantum systems
• Quantum Process Tomography of the Quantum Fourier Transform
• Dynamics of open quantum systems initially entangled with environment: Beyond the Kraus representation
• Information-Theoretic Implications of Quantum Causal Structures
• Theory-independent limits on correlations from generalised Bayesian networks
• Inferring causal structure: a quantum advantage
• Physical accessibility of non-completely positive maps
• Multiple-time states and multiple-time measurements in quantum mechanics
• Quantum Dynamics as an analog of Conditional Probability
• Operational approach to open dynamics and quantifying initial correlations
• A general framework for complete positivity
• An introduction to operational quantum dynamics
• Characterizing quantum dynamics with initial system-environment correlations
• Vanishing quantum discord is not necessary for completely-positive maps
• Causal structures from entropic information: Geometry and novel scenarios
• On modifications of Reichenbach's principle of common cause in light of Bell's theorem
• The Operator Tensor Formulation of Quantum Theory
• Quantum violation of an instrumental test
• Linear Assignment Maps for Correlated System-Environment States
• Can a quantum state over time resemble a quantum state at a single time?
• Is the dynamics of open quantum systems always linear?
• Experimentally bounding deviations from quantum theory in the landscape of generalized probabilistic theories
• Kraus representation in the presence of initial correlations
• Quantum-coherent mixtures of causal relations
• How state preparation can affect a quantum experiment: Quantum process tomography for open systems
• Pre- and post-selected quantum states: density matrices, tomography, and Kraus operators
• The role of preparation in quantum process tomography
• Entanglement, non-Markovianity, and causal non-separability
• Preparation of states in open quantum mechanics
• Maps for Lorentz transformations of spin
• Classical causal models for Bell and Kochen-Specker inequality violations require fine-tuning
• A Bayesian approach to compatibility, improvement, and pooling of quantum states
• Which causal structures might support a quantum-classical gap?
• Quantum superpositions of "common-cause" and "direct-cause" causal structures
• On the Debate Concerning the Proper Characterisation of Quantum Dynamical Evolution
• Inability of the entropy vector method to certify nonclassicality in linelike causal structures
• Quantum correlations which imply causation
• Quantum discord plays no distinguished role in characterization of complete positivity: Robustness of the traditional scheme

Cited by in corpus (29)

• The type-independent resource theory of local operations and shared randomness
• Why interference phenomena do not capture the essence of quantum theory
• Uniqueness of noncontextual models for stabilizer subtheories
• Witnessing quantum memory in non-Markovian processes
• Type-independent Characterization of Spacelike Separated Resources
• Quantum non-Markovianity: Overview and recent developments
• Operational applications of the diamond norm and related measures in quantifying the non-physicality of quantum maps
• Understanding the interplay of entanglement and nonlocality: motivating and developing a new branch of entanglement theory
• A structure theorem for generalized-noncontextual ontological models
• Postquantum common-cause channels: the resource theory of local operations and shared entanglement
• Initial Correlations in Open Quantum Systems: Constructing Linear Dynamical Maps and Master Equations
• Quantifying EPR: the resource theory of nonclassicality of common-cause assemblages
• A healthier semi-classical dynamics
• Memory Effects in Quantum Processes
• A review and reformulation of macroscopic realism: resolving its deficiencies using the framework of generalized probabilistic theories
• The resource theory of nonclassicality of channel assemblages
• Necessary and sufficient condition for the reduced dynamics of an open quantum system interacting with an environment to be linear
• Inverses, disintegrations, and Bayesian inversion in quantum Markov categories
• Unraveling-paired dynamical maps can recover the input of quantum channels
• Relating compatibility and divisibility of quantum channels
• Sufficient Conditions and Constraints for Reversing General Quantum Errors
• Guaranteeing Completely Positive Quantum Evolution
• Limitations of the Markovian approximation in the harmonic oscillator
• Activation of post-quantumness in bipartite generalised EPR scenarios
• Positivity of the assignment map implies complete positivity of the reduced dynamics
• Evolution of open quantum systems: time scales, stochastic and continuous processes
• On the use of total state decompositions for the study of reduced dynamics
• Theory-independent monitoring of the decoherence of a superconducting qubit with generalized contextuality
• Adapted projection operator technique for the treatment of initial correlations