Is TiO emission present in the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-33b? A reassessment using the improved ExoMol Toto line list

Abstract

[abridged] Efficient absorption of stellar UV and visible radiation by TiO and VO is predicted to drive temperature inversions in the upper atmospheres of hot Jupiters. However, few inversions or detections of TiO or VO have been reported, and results are often contradictory. Using the improved ExoMol Toto line list, we searched for TiO emission in the dayside spectrum of WASP-33b using the same data in which the molecule was previously detected with an older line list at 4.8$\sigma$. We intended to confirm the molecular detection and quantify the signal improvement offered by the ExoMol Toto line list. Data from the High Dispersion Spectrograph on the Subaru Telescope was extracted and reduced in an identical manner to the previous study. Stellar and telluric contamination were then removed. High-resolution TiO emission models of WASP-33b were created using the radiative transfer code petitRADTRANS and cross-correlated with the data. We measure a 4.3$\sigma$ TiO emission signature using the ExoMol Toto models, corresponding to a WASP-33b orbital velocity semi-amplitude of $K_{\mathrm{p}}=252.9_{-5.3}^{+5.0}\mathrm{km}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ and a system velocity of $v_{\mathrm{sys}}=-23.0_{-4.6}^{+4.7}\mathrm{km}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$. Injection-recovery tests using models based on the new and earlier line lists indicate that if the new models provide a perfect match to the planet spectrum, the significance of the TiO detection should have increased by a factor of $\sim$2. Although the TiO signal we find is statistically significant, comparison with previous works makes our result too ambiguous to claim a clear-cut detection. Unexpectedly, the new ExoMol Toto models provide a weaker signal than that found previously, which is offset in $K_{\mathrm{p}}$-$v_{\mathrm{sys}}$ space. This sheds some doubt on both detections, especially in light of a recently published TiO non-detection using a different dataset.

17 pages, 15 figures, Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (13)

• petitRADTRANS: a Python radiative transfer package for exoplanet characterization and retrieval
• An ultrahot gas-giant exoplanet with a stratosphere
• Detection of Fe I in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b, and a new likelihood-based approach for Doppler-resolved spectroscopy
• Observing transiting planets with JWST -- Prime targets and their synthetic spectral observations
• Detection of titanium oxide in the atmosphere of a hot Jupiter
• High-Resolution Spectroscopic Detection of TiO and Stratosphere in the Day-side of WASP-33b
• Evidence for a Dayside Thermal Inversion and High Metallicity for the Hot Jupiter WASP-18b
• An emission spectrum for WASP-121b measured across the 0.8-1.1 micron wavelength range using the Hubble Space Telescope
• Molecular Cross Sections for High Resolution Spectroscopy of Super Earths, Warm Neptunes and Hot Jupiters
• Detection of Fe\,{\sc i} Emission in the Day-side Spectrum of WASP-33b
• Comprehensive time series analysis of the transiting extrasolar planet WASP-33b
• Search for TiO and Optical Night-side Emission from the Exoplanet WASP-33b
• Analysis of the TiO isotopologues in stellar optical spectra

Cited by in corpus (24)

• A Comparative Study of Atmospheric Chemistry with VULCAN
• Titanium oxide and chemical inhomogeneity in the atmosphere of the exoplanet WASP-189b
• Five key exoplanet questions answered via the analysis of 25 hot Jupiter atmospheres in eclipse
• Into the Storm: Diving into the winds of the ultra hot Jupiter WASP-76 b with HARPS and ESPRESSO
• Carbon monoxide emission lines reveal an inverted atmosphere in the ultra hot Jupiter WASP-33 b consistent with an eastward hot spot
• Detection of OH in the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76b
• High-resolution transmission spectroscopy study of ultra-hot Jupiters HAT-P-57b, KELT-17b, KELT-21b, KELT-7b, MASCARA-1b, and WASP-189b
• Confirmation of Iron Emission Lines and Non-detection of TiO on the Dayside of KELT-9b with MAROON-X
• High-resolution atmospheric retrievals of WASP-121b transmission spectroscopy with ESPRESSO: Consistent relative abundance constraints across multiple epochs and instruments
• Keck/KPIC Emission Spectroscopy of WASP-33b
• Silicon in the dayside atmospheres of two ultra-hot Jupiters
• The PEPSI Exoplanet Transit Survey (PETS). II. A Deep Search for Thermal Inversion Agents in KELT-20 b/MASCARA-2 b with Emission and Transmission Spectroscopy
• SimAb: A simple, fast and flexible model to assess the effects of planet formation on the atmospheric composition of gas giants
• Data availability and requirements relevant for the Ariel space mission and other exoplanet atmosphere applications
• Observability of silicates in volatile atmospheres of super-Earths and sub-Neptunes
• The Mantis Network I: A standard grid of templates and masks for cross-correlation analyses of ultra-hot Jupiter transmission spectra
• Applications of a Gaussian Process Framework for Modelling of High-Resolution Exoplanet Spectra
• High-resolution atmospheric retrievals of WASP-76b transmission spectroscopy with ESPRESSO: Monitoring limb asymmetries across multiple transits
• Dust in brown dwarfs and extra-solar planets. VIII. TiO${}_2$ seed formation: 3D Monte Carlo versus kinetic approach
• Measuring titanium isotope ratios in exoplanet atmospheres
• Disentangling disc and atmospheric signatures of young brown dwarfs with JWST/NIRSpec
• Thermal emission spectra of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-33 b
• Day-side Fe I Emission, Day-Night Brightness Contrast and Phase Offset of the Exoplanet WASP-33b
• The breaking of cold traps and onset of titanium in ultra-hot Jupiter atmospheres: WASP-189b in context