Formulating and critically examining the assumptions of global 21-cm signal analyses: How to avoid the false troughs that can appear in single spectrum fits

Abstract

The assumptions inherent to global 21-cm signal analyses are rarely delineated. In this paper, we formulate a general list of suppositions underlying a given claimed detection of the global 21-cm signal. Then, we specify the form of these assumptions for two different analyses: 1) the one performed by the EDGES team showing an absorption trough in brightness temperature that they modeled separately from the sky foreground and 2) a new, so-called Minimum Assumption Analysis (MAA), that makes the most conservative assumptions possible for the signal. We show fits using the EDGES analysis on various beam-weighted foreground simulations from the EDGES latitude with no signal added. Depending on the beam used, these simulations produce large false troughs due to the invalidity of the foreground model to describe the combination of beam chromaticity and the shape of the Galactic plane in the sky, the residuals of which are captured by the ad hoc flattened Gaussian signal model. On the other hand, the MAA provides robust fits by including many spectra at different time bins and allowing any possible 21-cm spectrum to be modeled exactly. We present uncertainty levels and example signal reconstructions found with the MAA for different numbers of time bins. With enough time bins, one can determine the true 21-cm signal with the MAA to $<10$ times the noise level.

arXiv comment19 pages, 4 figures, accepted to ApJ. Since previous version, added frequency correlation structure under MAA analysis and laid out extension of MAA to motion-induced dipole of 21-cm signal

References in corpus (35)

• An absorption profile centred at 78 megahertz in the sky-averaged spectrum
• 21-cm cosmology
• Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA)
• Possible interaction between baryons and dark-matter particles revealed by the first stars
• Enhanced global signal of neutral hydrogen due to excess radiation at cosmic dawn
• Severely Constraining Dark Matter Interpretations of the 21-cm Anomaly
• Concerns about Modelling of the EDGES Data
• Signs of Dark Matter at 21-cm?
• Modeling the Radio Background from the First Black Holes at Cosmic Dawn: Implications for the 21 cm Absorption Amplitude
• Signature of Excess Radio Background in the 21-cm Global Signal and Power Spectrum
• Constraining Baryon--Dark Matter Scattering with the Cosmic Dawn 21-cm Signal
• Testing for calibration systematics in the EDGES low-band data using Bayesian model selection
• A Ground Plane Artifact that Induces an Absorption Profile in Averaged Spectra from Global 21-cm Measurements - with Possible Application to EDGES
• The redshifted 21-cm signal in the EDGES low-band spectrum
• Results from EDGES High-Band: I. Constraints on Phenomenological Models for the Global $21$ cm Signal
• SARAS 2 constraints on global 21-cm signals from the Epoch of Reionization
• 21-cm Fluctuations from Charged Dark Matter
• Calibration of the EDGES High-Band Receiver to Observe the Global 21-cm Signature from the Epoch of Reionization
• Chromatic effects in the 21 cm global signal from the cosmic dawn
• Global 21cm signal experiments: A designer's guide
• The Effects of Population III X-ray and Radio Backgrounds on the Cosmological 21-cm Signal
• Spectral Index of the Diffuse Radio Background Between 50 and 100 MHz
• A Space-Based Observational Strategy for Characterizing the First Stars and Galaxies Using the Redshifted 21-cm Global Spectrum
• Direct millicharged dark matter cannot explain EDGES
• The Radio Scream from Black Holes at Cosmic Dawn: A Semi-Analytic Model for the Impact of Radio Loud Black-Holes on the 21 cm Global Signal
• Results from EDGES High-Band: II. Constraints on Parameters of Early Galaxies
• Global 21-cm signal extraction from foreground and instrumental effects I: Pattern recognition framework for separation using training sets
• On the contamination of the global 21~cm signal from polarized foregrounds
• Erasing the variable: Empirical foreground discovery for global 21 cm spectrum experiments
• Assessment of the Projection-induced Polarimetry Technique for Constraining the Foreground Spectrum in Global 21 cm Cosmology
• Absorption by Spinning Dust: a Contaminant for High-Redshift 21 cm Observations
• Dipole Anisotropy as an Essential Qualifier for the Monopole Component of the Cosmic-Dawn Spectral Signature, and the Potential of Diurnal Pattern for Foreground Estimation
• Dipole of the Epoch of Reionization 21-cm signal
• Measurements of the global 21-cm signal from the Cosmic Dawn
• The First Stars May Shed Light on Dark Matter

Cited by in corpus (35)

• HERA Phase I Limits on the Cosmic 21-cm Signal: Constraints on Astrophysics and Cosmology During the Epoch of Reionization
• A General Bayesian Framework for Foreground Modelling and Chromaticity Correction for Global 21cm Experiments
• Bursty star formation during the Cosmic Dawn driven by delayed stellar feedback
• Discovering the Sky at the Longest wavelengths with a lunar orbit array
• Transformative Science from the Lunar Farside: Observations of the Dark Ages and Exoplanetary Systems at Low Radio Frequencies
• A needle in a haystack? Catching Pop III stars in the Epoch of Reionization: I. Pop III star forming environments
• Global 21-cm Signal Extraction from Foreground and Instrumental Effects II: Efficient and Self-Consistent Technique for Constraining Nonlinear Signal Models
• Antenna beam characterisation for the global 21cm experiment LEDA and its impact on signal model parameter reconstruction
• Use of Time Dependent Data in Bayesian Global 21cm Foreground and Signal Modelling
• PRATUSH experiment concept and design overview
• Lost Horizon: Quantifying the Effect of Local Topography on Global 21-cm Cosmology Data Analysis
• Spectral index of the Galactic foreground emission in the 50-87 MHz range
• A Bayesian Calibration Framework for EDGES
• Global 21-cm signal extraction from foreground and instrumental effects IV: Accounting for realistic instrument uncertainties and their overlap with foreground and signal models
• Structure Formation and the Global 21-cm Signal in the Presence of Coulomb-like Dark Matter-Baryon Interactions
• Modelling the Galactic Foreground and Beam Chromaticity for Global 21-cm Cosmology
• Cosmic Reionization May Still Have Started Early and Ended Late: Confronting Early Onset with CMB Anisotropy and 21 cm Global Signals
• A Bayesian approach to modelling spectrometer data chromaticity corrected using beam factors -- I. Mathematical formalism
• The role of Pop III stars and early black holes in the 21cm signal from Cosmic Dawn
• Cosmic Variance of the 21-cm Global Signal
• A General Bayesian Framework to Account for Foreground Map Errors in Global 21-cm Experiments
• Exploring the cosmic dawn and epoch of reionization with 21cm line
• Sky-averaged 21-cm signal extraction using multiple antennas with an SVD framework: the REACH case
• A galaxy-free phenomenological model for the 21-cm power spectrum during reionization
• Joint constraints on reionization: a framework for combining the global 21cm signal and the kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect
• Simulation-Based Inference of the sky-averaged 21-cm signal from CD-EoR with REACH
• The EDGES measurement disfavors an excess radio background during the cosmic dawn
• Bounds on sterile neutrino lifetime and mixing angle with active neutrinos by global 21 cm signal
• Constraining PBH mass distributions from 21cm brightness temperature results and an analytical mapping between probability distribution of 21cm signal and PBH masses
• Ensuring Robustness in Training Set Based Global 21-cm Cosmology Analysis
• Constraining a Model of the Radio Sky Below 6 MHz Using the Parker Solar Probe/FIELDS Instrument in Preparation for Upcoming Lunar-based Experiments
• A Bayesian approach to modelling spectrometer data chromaticity corrected using beam factors -- II. Model priors and posterior odds
• Global 21cm Absorption Signal from Superconducting Cosmic Strings
• Sensitivities on non-spinning and spinning primordial black hole dark matter with global 21 cm troughs
• Optimizing Foreground Modelling for Global 21cm Cosmology with GPU-Accelerated Nested Sampling