Assessing the Performance of Molecular Gas Clump Identification Algorithms

Abstract

The detection of clumps(cores) in molecular clouds is an important issue in sub-millimetre astronomy. However, the completeness of the identification and the accuracy of the returned parameters of the automated clump identification algorithms are still not clear by now. In this work, we test the performance and bias of the GaussClumps, ClumpFind, Fellwalker, Reinhold, and Dendrograms algorithms in identifying simulated clumps. By designing the simulated clumps with various sizes, peak brightness, and crowdedness, we investigate the characteristics of the algorithms and their performance. In the aspect of detection completeness, Fellwalker, Dendrograms, and Gaussclumps are the first, second, and third best algorithms, respectively. The numbers of correct identifications of the six algorithms gradually increase as the size and SNR of the simulated clumps increase and they decrease as the crowdedness increases. In the aspect of the accuracy of retrieved parameters, Fellwalker and Dendrograms exhibit better performance than the other algorithms. The average deviations in clump parameters for all algorithms gradually increase as the size and SNR of clumps increase. Most of the algorithms except Fellwalker exhibit significant deviation in extracting the total flux of clumps. Taken altogether, Fellwalker, Gaussclumps, and Dendrograms exhibit the best performance in detection completeness and extracting parameters. The deviation in virial parameter for the six algorithms is relatively low. When applying the six algorithms to the clump identification for the Rosette molecular cloud, ClumpFind1994, ClumpFind2006, Gaussclumps, Fellwalker, and Reinhold exhibit performance that is consistent with the results from the simulated test.

23 pages, 13 figures. Accepted for publication in RAA

References in corpus (24)

• Theory of Star Formation
• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• Systematic Molecular Differentiation in Starless Cores
• High-Mass Proto-Stellar Candidates - II : Density structure from dust continuum and CS emission
• ATLASGAL --- properties of a complete sample of Galactic clumps
• Bolocam Survey for 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Emission in the c2d Legacy Clouds. I. Perseus
• The Physical Conditions for Massive Star Formation: Dust Continuum Maps and Modeling
• The Equilibrium State of Molecular Regions in the Outer Galaxy
• ATLASGAL --- towards a complete sample of massive star forming clumps
• The Mass-Size Relation from Clouds to Cores. II. Solar Neighborhood Clouds
• FellWalker - a Clump Identification Algorithm
• The Perils of Clumpfind: The Mass Spectrum of Sub-structures in Molecular Clouds
• Molecular clouds and clumps in the Boston University-Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory Galactic Ring Survey
• The Mass-Size Relation from Clouds to Cores. I. A new Probe of Structure in Molecular Clouds
• Correlation Between Gas and Dust in Molecular Clouds: L977
• Testing Larson's relationships in massive clumps
• Molecular line mapping of the giant molecular cloud associated with RCW 106 - III. Multi-molecular line mapping
• The structure of molecular clumps around high-mass young stellar objects
• On the fidelity of the core mass functions derived from dust column density data
• A large-scale CO survey of the Rosette Molecular Cloud: assessing the effects of O stars on surrounding molecular gas
• The properties of SCUBA cores in the Perseus molecular cloud: the bias of clump-finding algorithms
• A large-scale survey of CO and its isotopologues toward the Rosette molecular cloud
• Galactic cold cores IX. Column density structures and radiative transfer modelling
• A High-Resolution, Dust-Selected Molecular Cloud Catalogue of M33, the Triangulum Galaxy

Cited by in corpus (19)

• The effects of subgrid models on the properties of giant molecular clouds in galaxy formation simulations
• Molecular Clouds in the Second Quadrant of the Milky Way Mid-plane from l$=$104$.{}^{\circ }$75 to l=119$.{}^{\circ }$75 and b=$-$5$.{}^{\circ }$25 to b=5$.{}^{\circ }$25
• NOEMA High Fidelity Imaging of the Molecular Gas in and around M82
• The turbulent gas structure in the centers of NGC253 and the Milky Way
• The KOSMA-$\tau$ PDR Model -- I. Recent updates to the numerical model of photo-dissociated regions
• The molecular gas resolved by ALMA in the low-metallicity dwarf merging galaxy Haro 11
• Merger-induced star formation in low-metallicity dwarf galaxy NGC 4809/4810
• An Unbiased CO Survey Toward the Northern Region of the Small Magellanic Cloud with the Atacama Compact Array. II. CO Cloud Catalog
• FacetClumps: A Facet-based Molecular Clump Detection Algorithm
• Identification of molecular clouds in emission maps: a comparison between methods in the \ce{^{13}CO}/\ce{C^{18}O} ($J=3-2$) Heterodyne Inner Milky Way Plane Survey
• Molecular Clump Extraction Algorithm Based on Local Density Clustering
• Characterization of dense Planck clumps observed with Herschel and SCUBA-2
• Revisiting The Mass-Size Relation Of Structures In Molecular Clouds
• Star burst in W49N presumably induced by cloud-cloud collision
• Hot Molecular Core Candidates in the Galactic Center 50 km/s Molecular Cloud
• ALMA observations of massive clouds in the central molecular zone: slim filaments tracing parsec-scale shocks
• Low-redshift analogues of cosmic noon galaxies as laboratories for clumpy star formation
• Molecular cloud matching in CO and dust in M33 II. Physical properties of giant molecular clouds
• Stellar Feedback Effects on the Mass Distribution of Clouds and Cloud Complexes