(Not as) Big as a Barn: Upper Bounds on Dark Matter-Nucleus Cross Sections

Abstract

Critical probes of dark matter come from tests of its elastic scattering with nuclei. The results are typically assumed to be model-independent, meaning that the form of the potential need not be specified and that the cross sections on different nuclear targets can be simply related to the cross section on nucleons. For point-like spin-independent scattering, the assumed scaling relation is ${\sigma }_{\chi A}\propto A^2{\mu }_A^2{\sigma }_{\chi N}\propto A^4{\sigma }_{\chi N}$, where the $A^2$ comes from coherence and the ${\mu }_A^2\simeq A^2{m}_N^2$ from kinematics for $m_{\chi }\gg m_A$. Here we calculate where model independence ends, i.e., where the cross section becomes so large that it violates its defining assumptions. We show that the assumed scaling relations generically fail for dark matter-nucleus cross sections ${\sigma }_{\chi A}\sim 10^{-32}-10^{-27}{\text{cm}}^2$, significantly below the geometric sizes of nuclei, and well within the regime probed by underground detectors. Last, we show on theoretical grounds, and in light of existing limits on light mediators, that point-like dark matter cannot have ${\sigma }_{\chi N}\gtrsim 10^{-25}{\text{cm}}^2$, above which many claimed constraints originate from cosmology and astrophysics. The most viable way to have such large cross sections is composite dark matter, which introduces significant additional model dependence through the choice of form factor. All prior limits on dark matter with cross sections ${\sigma }_{\chi N}>10^{-32}{\text{cm}}^2$ with $m_{\chi }\gtrsim 1\text{GeV}$ must therefore be re-evaluated and reinterpreted.

18 pages, 7 figures, revised to match journal version including erratum, comments are welcome

References in corpus (43)

• Results from a search for dark matter in the complete LUX exposure
• Dark Matter Results From 54-Ton-Day Exposure of PandaX-II Experiment
• Precise Relic WIMP Abundance and its Impact on Searches for Dark Matter Annihilation
• Constraints on Dark Matter from Colliders
• First results from the CRESST-III low-mass dark matter program
• Light Dark Matter: Models and Constraints
• Novel direct detection constraints on light dark matter
• Dark Matter Search Results from the PICO-2L C${}_3$F${}_8$ Bubble Chamber
• Limits on spin-dependent WIMP-nucleon cross section obtained from the complete LUX exposure
• Towards Closing the Window on Strongly Interacting Dark Matter: Far-Reaching Constraints from Earth's Heat Flow
• Light Dark Matter at Neutrino Experiments
• Dark Matter Searches at Colliders
• Characterising dark matter searches at colliders and direct detection experiments: Vector mediators
• Review of short-range gravity experiments in the LHC era
• Search for low-mass WIMPs in a 0.6 kg day exposure of the DAMIC experiment at SNOLAB
• Constraints on Dark Matter Microphysics from the Milky Way Satellite Population
• Viscoelastic hydrodynamics and holography
• Discovery of a 3.5 keV line in the Galactic Center and a Critical Look at the Origin of the Line Across Astronomical Targets
• A Robust Excess in the Cosmic-Ray Antiproton Spectrum: Implications for Annihilating Dark Matter
• Composite dark matter from a model with composite Higgs boson
• Dark Nuclei I: Cosmology and Indirect Detection
• Macro Dark Matter
• Direct dark matter detection: the next decade
• Strong New Limits on Light Dark Matter from Neutrino Experiments
• Reverse Direct Detection: Cosmic Ray Scattering With Light Dark Matter
• Final Results of the PICASSO Dark Matter Search Experiment
• TeV-Scale Thermal WIMPs: Unitarity and its Consequences
• Nuclear structure factors for general spin-independent WIMP-nucleus scattering
• Resonant Dark Matter
• Galactic Center Gas Clouds and Novel Bounds on Ultra-Light Dark Photon, Vector Portal, Strongly Interacting, Composite, and Super-Heavy Dark Matter
• Daily Modulation as a Smoking Gun of Dark Matter with Significant Stopping
• Type Ia supernovae from dark matter core collapse
• Searches for gamma-ray lines and `pure WIMP' spectra from Dark Matter annihilations in dwarf galaxies with H.E.S.S
• Direct Detection of Bound States of Asymmetric Dark Matter
• Probing Dark Matter with AGN Jets
• Foraging for dark matter in large volume liquid scintillator neutrino detectors with multiscatter events
• The Search for Dark Matter
• Closing the window on $\sim$GeV Dark Matter with moderate ($\sim$$\mu$b) interaction with nucleons
• Search for Semi-Annihilating Dark Matter with Fermi-LAT, H.E.S.S., Planck, and the Cherenkov Telescope Array
• Energy loss during Dark Matter propagation in an overburden
• Gamma Rays from Cosmic-Ray Proton Scattering in AGN Jets: the Intra-Cluster Gas vastly outshines Dark Matter
• 6-quark Dark Matter
• Determination of Dark Matter Properties at High-Energy Colliders

Cited by in corpus (53)

• Light Dark Matter Search with a High-Resolution Athermal Phonon Detector Operated Above Ground
• Strong New Limits on Light Dark Matter from Neutrino Experiments
• Cosmological Constraints on Dark Matter Interactions with Ordinary Matter
• Maximizing Direct Detection with Highly Interactive Particle Relic Dark Matter
• Direct detection and complementary constraints for sub-GeV dark matter
• Dark Matter-Electron Scattering from Aromatic Organic Targets
• Evaporation of dark matter from celestial bodies
• Observational constraints on dark matter scattering with electrons
• Implications of BBN Bounds for Cosmic Ray Upscattered Dark Matter
• First direct detection constraints on Planck-scale mass dark matter with multiple-scatter signatures using the DEAP-3600 detector
• Snowmass2021 Cosmic Frontier White Paper: Ultraheavy particle dark matter
• Terrestrial and Martian Heat Flow Limits on Dark Matter
• Present and future status of light dark matter models from cosmic-ray electron upscattering
• Direct Detection Limits on Heavy Dark Matter
• Detecting Composite Dark Matter with Long Range and Contact Interactions in Gas Clouds
• New Experimental Constraints in a New Landscape for Composite Dark Matter
• No room to hide: implications of cosmic-ray upscattering for GeV-scale dark matter
• Celestial Objects as Strongly-Interacting Non-Annihilating Dark Matter Detectors
• Dark matter astrometry at underground detectors with multiscatter events
• Cosmic-ray dark matter confronted by constraints on new light mediators
• Etching Plastic Searches for Dark Matter
• Dark Matter Induced Power in Quantum Devices
• Accelerating Earth-Bound Dark Matter
• New constraints on ultraheavy dark matter from the LZ experiment
• Dark Matter Candidates and Searches
• Searching for Heavy Dark Matter near the Planck Mass with XENON1T
• Prospects for Light Dark Matter Searches at Large-Volume Neutrino Detectors
• Regurgitated Dark Matter
• Continuous Gravitational Waves: A New Window to Look for Heavy Non-annihilating Dark Matter
• Optimal Celestial Bodies for Dark Matter Detection
• New Constraints on Macroscopic Dark Matter Using Radar Meteor Detectors
• Investigation of CMB constraints for dark matter-helium scattering
• Cosmology and prospects for sub-MeV dark matter in electron recoil experiments
• Fractionally Charged Particles at the Energy Frontier: The SM Gauge Group and One-Form Global Symmetry
• Premature Black Hole Death of Population III Stars by Dark Matter
• Dark Matter (H)eats Young Planets
• Constraints on GeV Dark Matter interaction with baryons, from a novel Dewar experiment
• Neutrinos from Earth-Bound Dark Matter Annihilation
• Enhancing Direct Detection of Higgsino Dark Matter
• New constraints on cosmic ray-boosted dark matter from the LUX-ZEPLIN experiment
• XQC and CSR constraints on strongly interacting dark matter with spin and velocity dependent cross sections
• Dark Matter Search with the Nuclear Isomer Ta-180m
• Resonant Scattering between Dark Matter and Baryons: Revised Direct Detection and CMB Limits
• Mechanical Sensors for Ultraheavy Dark Matter Searches via Long-range Forces
• Revisiting Puffy Dark Matter with Novel Insights: Partial Wave Analysis
• Using Secondary Tau Neutrinos to Probe Heavy Dark Matter Decays in Earth
• Solar wind bremsstrahlung off DM in our solar system
• Radiation Exposure from the Dark
• Listening for ultra-heavy dark matter with underwater acoustic detectors
• Models of ultra-heavy dark matter visible to macroscopic mechanical sensing arrays
• Secluded Dark Composites and Remnant Binding Fields
• Constraints on ultraheavy dark matter from the CDEX-10 experiment at the China Jinping Underground Laboratory
• Heavy dark matter in rapidly evolving massive stars