Identifying the Theory of Dark Matter with Direct Detection

Abstract

Identifying the true theory of dark matter depends crucially on accurately characterizing interactions of dark matter (DM) with other species. In the context of DM direct detection, we present a study of the prospects for correctly identifying the low-energy effective DM-nucleus scattering operators connected to UV-complete models of DM-quark interactions. We take a census of plausible UV-complete interaction models with different low-energy leading-order DM-nuclear responses. For each model (corresponding to different spin-, momentum-, and velocity-dependent responses), we create a large number of realizations of recoil-energy spectra, and use Bayesian methods to investigate the probability that experiments will be able to select the correct scattering model within a broad set of competing scattering hypotheses. We conclude that agnostic analysis of a strong signal (such as Generation-2 would see if cross sections are just below the current limits) seen on xenon and germanium experiments is likely to correctly identify momentum dependence of the dominant response, ruling out models with either "heavy" or "light" mediators, and enabling downselection of allowed models. However, a unique determination of the correct UV completion will critically depend on the availability of measurements from a wider variety of nuclear targets, including iodine or fluorine. We investigate how model-selection prospects depend on the energy window available for the analysis. In addition, we discuss accuracy of the DM particle mass determination under a wide variety of scattering models, and investigate impact of the specific types of particle-physics uncertainties on prospects for model selection.

v2: minor corrections, 2 appendicies added; key results in Figures 8, 9, and 10; submitted to JCAP; dmdd code available at https://github.com/veragluscevic/dmdd

References in corpus (13)

• A Theory of Dark Matter
• Standard Model anatomy of WIMP dark matter direct detection II: QCD analysis and hadronic matrix elements
• Electromagnetic properties of dark matter: dipole moments and charge form factor
• Magnetic Inelastic Dark Matter
• Not so Coy Dark Matter explains DAMA (and the Galactic Center excess)
• Dipolar Dark Matter
• Nuclear structure aspects of spin-independent WIMP scattering off xenon
• Nuclear spin structure in dark matter search: The finite momentum transfer limit
• Light stops, blind spots, and isospin violation in the MSSM
• Prospects for direct detection of dark matter in an effective theory approach
• Halo Independent Direct Detection of Momentum-Dependent Dark Matter
• Search for Low-Mass Dark Matter with CsI(Tl) Crystal Detectors
• Understanding WIMP-baryon interactions with direct detection: A Roadmap

Cited by in corpus (46)

• Dark Matter Search Results from the Complete Exposure of the PICO-60 C${}_3$F${}_8$ Bubble Chamber
• Dark Matter Search Results from the PICO-60 C${}_3$F${}_8$ Bubble Chamber
• A Next-Generation Liquid Xenon Observatory for Dark Matter and Neutrino Physics
• Toward (Finally!) Ruling Out Z and Higgs Mediated Dark Matter Models
• Dark Matter Search Results from the PICO-60 CF${}_3$I Bubble Chamber
• The SABRE project and the SABRE PoP
• Dark matter in the Sun: scattering off electrons vs nucleons
• The Migdal Effect and Photon Bremsstrahlung in effective field theories of dark matter direct detection and coherent elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering
• Reopening the Higgs portal for Singlet Scalar Dark Matter
• Towards accurate cosmological predictions for rapidly oscillating scalar fields as dark matter
• (Not as) Big as a Barn: Upper Bounds on Dark Matter-Nucleus Cross Sections
• Strong constraints from COSINE-100 on the DAMA dark matter results using the same sodium iodide target
• No $\nu$ floors: Effective field theory treatment of the neutrino background in direct dark matter detection experiments
• Loop-induced direct detection signatures from CP-violating scalar mediators
• Constraints on dark matter-nucleon effective couplings in the presence of kinematically distinct halo substructures using the DEAP-3600 detector
• DAMA confronts null searches in the effective theory of dark matter-nucleon interactions
• A complete Lorentz-to-Galileo dictionary for direct Dark Matter detection
• Exploring light mediators with low-threshold direct detection experiments
• Casting a Wide Signal Net with Future Direct Dark Matter Detection Experiments
• Studying generalised dark matter interactions with extended halo-independent methods
• Dark Matter Direct Detection from new interactions in models with spin-two mediators
• Dark matter, light mediators, and the neutrino floor
• Mapping The Neutrino Floor For Dark Matter-Electron Direct Detection Experiments
• Light dark matter scattering in outer neutron star crusts
• Comparison between DAMA/LIBRA and COSINE-100 in the light of Quenching Factors
• Implications of the Gaia Sausage for Dark Matter Nuclear Interactions
• Data-Driven Modeling of Electron Recoil Nucleation in PICO C${}_3$F${}_8$ Bubble Chambers
• Multi-Dimensional Effective Field Theory Analysis for Direct Detection of Dark Matter
• SABRE: WIMP modulation detection in the northern and southern hemisphere
• Opening the energy window on direct dark matter detection
• A combined analysis of PandaX, LUX, and XENON1T experiments within the framework of dark matter effective theory
• Surrogate Models for Direct Dark Matter Detection
• The Milky Way, Coming into Focus: Precision Astrometry Probes its Evolution, and its Dark Matter
• Dark Matter Model or Mass, but Not Both: Assessing Near-Future Direct Searches with Benchmark-free Forecasting
• On the sensitivity of present direct detection experiments to WIMP-quark and WIMP-gluon effective interactions: a systematic assessment and new model-independent approaches
• Internal heating mechanisms in neutron stars
• Velocity independent constraints on spin-dependent DM-nucleon interactions from IceCube and PICO
• Characterizing dark matter at the LHC in Drell-Yan events
• Prospects for Distinguishing Dark Matter Models Using Annual Modulation
• Upgrading the COSINE-100 Experiment for Enhanced Sensitivity to Low-Mass Dark Matter Detection
• Results on photon-mediated dark matter-nucleus interactions from the PICO-60 C${}_3$F${}_8$ bubble chamber
• Equilibrium axisymmetric halo model for the Milky Way and its implications for direct and indirect DM searches
• Scintillation characteristics of an undoped CsI crystal at low-temperature for dark matter search
• Model for bubble nucleation efficiency of low-energy nuclear recoils in bubble chambers for dark matter detection
• Searching for low-mass dark matter via Migdal effect in COSINE-100
• HydroX, a light dark matter search with hydrogen-doped liquid xenon time projection chambers