On the robustness of analysis techniques for molecular detections using high resolution exoplanet spectroscopy

Abstract

High-resolution doppler spectroscopy provides a powerful means for chemical detections in exoplanetary atmospheres. This approach involves monitoring hundreds of molecular lines in the planetary spectrum doppler shifted by the orbital motion of the planet. The molecules are detected by cross-correlating the observed spectrum of the system with a model planetary spectrum. The method has led to molecular detections of H2O, CO, and TiO in hot Jupiters using large ground-based telescopes. Critical to this method, however, is the accurate removal of the stellar and telluric features from the observed spectrum, also known as detrending. Previous molecular detections have relied on specific choices of detrending methods and parameters. However, the robustness of molecular detections across the different choices has not been investigated in detail. We conduct a systematic investigation of the effect of detrending algorithms, parameters, and optimizations on chemical detections using high-resolution spectroscopy. As a case study, we consider the hot Jupiter HD 189733 b. Using multiple methods, we confirm high-significance detections of H2O (4.8$\sigma$) and CO (4.7$\sigma$). Additionally, we report evidence for HCN at high significance (5.0$\sigma$). On the other hand, our results highlight the need for improved metrics and extended observations for robust confirmations of such detections. In particular, we show that detection significances of $\gtrsim$ 4$\sigma$ can be obtained by optimizing detrending at incorrect locations in the planetary velocity space; such false positives can occur in nearly 30\% of cases. We discuss approaches to help distinguish molecular detections from spurious noise.

15 pages, 16 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (30)

• The orbital motion, absolute mass, and high-altitude winds of exoplanet HD209458b
• Molecfit: A general tool for telluric absorption correction. I. Method and application to ESO instruments
• The ExoMol database: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other hot atmospheres
• Correcting systematic effects in a large set of photometric lightcurves
• ELODIE metallicity-biased search for transiting Hot Jupiters II. A very hot Jupiter transiting the bright K star HD189733
• C/O ratio as a Dimension for Characterizing Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• The signature of orbital motion from the dayside of the planet tau Bootis b
• Detection of water absorption in the day side atmosphere of HD 189733 b using ground-based high-resolution spectroscopy at 3.2 microns
• ExoMol line lists III: An improved hot rotation-vibration line list for HCN and HNC
• Chemical consequences of the C/O ratio on hot Jupiters: Examples from WASP-12b,CoRoT-2b, XO-1b, and HD 189733b
• Rotation and winds of exoplanet HD 189733 b measured with high-dispersion transmission spectroscopy
• Improved HCN/HNC linelist, model atmospheres and synthetic spectra for WZ Cas
• Detection of carbon monoxide in the high-resolution day-side spectrum of the exoplanet HD 189733b
• Exoplanetary Atmospheres - Chemistry, Formation Conditions, and Habitability
• The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect of CoRoT-3b & HD189733b
• Carbon monoxide and water vapor in the atmosphere of the non-transiting exoplanet HD 179949 b
• High-Resolution Spectroscopic Detection of TiO and Stratosphere in the Day-side of WASP-33b
• Weighing The Non-Transiting Hot Jupiter Tau BOO b
• Detection of molecular absorption in the dayside of exoplanet 51 Pegasi b?
• Discovery of water at high spectral resolution in the atmosphere of 51 Peg b
• GENESIS: New Self-Consistent Models of Exoplanetary Spectra
• Near-IR Direct Detection of Water Vapor in Tau Boo b
• A framework to combine low- and high-resolution spectroscopy for the atmospheres of transiting exoplanets
• Exoplanet atmospheres with GIANO. I. Water in the transmission spectrum of HD 189733b
• Evidence for multiple molecular species in the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• Evidence against a strong thermal inversion in HD 209458 b from high-dispersion spectroscopy
• Evidence for the Direct Detection of the Thermal Spectrum of the Non-Transiting Hot Gas Giant HD 88133 b
• Exoplanet Atmospheres at High Spectral Resolution
• Model atmospheres of sub-stellar mass objects
• Exoplanet-atmospheres at high spectral resolution: A CRIRES survey of hot-Jupiters

Cited by in corpus (58)

• Exoplanetary Atmospheres: Key Insights, Challenges and Prospects
• Retrieving Temperatures and Abundances of Exoplanet Atmospheres with High-Resolution Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy
• The 2020 release of the ExoMol database: molecular line lists for exoplanet and other hot atmospheres
• Detection of Fe I in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b, and a new likelihood-based approach for Doppler-resolved spectroscopy
• Where is the Water? Jupiter-like C/H ratio but strong H${}_2$O depletion found on $\tau$ Boötis b using SPIRou
• PLATON II: New Capabilities And A Comprehensive Retrieval on HD 189733b Transit and Eclipse Data
• Detection of neutral atomic species in the ultra-hot jupiter WASP-121b
• Vanadium oxide and a sharp onset of cold-trapping on a giant exoplanet
• Searching for Thermal Inversion Agents in the Transmission Spectrum of MASCARA-2b/KELT-20b: Detection of Neutral Iron and Ionised Calcium H$\&$K Lines
• Non-detection of TiO and VO in the atmosphere of WASP-121b using high-resolution spectroscopy
• Detection of Na, K, and H$\alpha$ absorption in the atmosphere of WASP-52b using ESPRESSO
• First Detection of Hydroxyl Radical Emission from an Exoplanet Atmosphere: High-dispersion Characterization of WASP-33b using Subaru/IRD
• Water vapor detection in the transmission spectra of HD 209458 b with the CARMENES NIR channel
• Molecular Cross Sections for High Resolution Spectroscopy of Super Earths, Warm Neptunes and Hot Jupiters
• An inventory of atomic species in the atmosphere of WASP-121b using UVES high-resolution spectroscopy
• High-resolution Transmission Spectroscopy of MASCARA-2 b with EXPRES
• HyDRA-H: Simultaneous Hybrid Retrieval of Exoplanetary Emission Spectra
• Neutral Cr and V in the atmosphere of ultra hot jupiter WASP-121 b
• Seeing above the Clouds with High Resolution Spectroscopy
• Sulfur Chemistry in the Atmospheres of Warm and Hot Jupiters
• Prospects for Characterizing the Haziest Sub-Neptune Exoplanets with High Resolution Spectroscopy
• Robustness Measures for Molecular Detections using High-Resolution Transmission Spectroscopy of Exoplanets
• The composition of hot Jupiter atmospheres assembled within chemically evolved protoplanetary discs
• CO or no CO? Narrowing the CO abundance constraint and recovering the H2O detection in the atmosphere of WASP-127 b using SPIRou
• A Search for FeH in Hot-Jupiter Atmospheres with High-Dispersion Spectroscopy
• Homogeneous search for helium in the atmosphere of 11 gas giant exoplanets with SPIRou
• Black Mirror: The impact of rotational broadening on the search for reflected light from 51 Pegasi b with high resolution spectroscopy
• Grid of pseudo-2D chemistry models for tidally locked exoplanets -- II. The role of photochemistry
• Characterizing exoplanetary atmospheres at high resolution with SPIRou: Detection of water on HD 189733 b
• Is TiO emission present in the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-33b? A reassessment using the improved ExoMol Toto line list
• Exoplanet atmospheres at high resolution through a modest-size telescope. Fe II in MASCARA-2b and KELT-9b with FIES on the Nordic Optical Telescope
• Retrieval of the dayside atmosphere of WASP-43b with CRIRES+
• The GAPS Programme at TNG XXXIII. HARPS-N detects multiple atomic species in emission from the dayside of KELT-20b
• A weak spectral signature of water vapour in the atmosphere of HD 179949 b at high spectral resolution in the L-band
• A quantitative assessment of the VO line list: Inaccuracies hamper high-resolution VO detections in exoplanet atmospheres
• Assessing telluric correction methods for Na detections with high-resolution exoplanet transmission spectroscopy
• Investigating the detectability of hydrocarbons in exoplanet atmospheres with JWST
• A sub-solar metallicity on the ultra-short period planet HIP 65Ab
• Behind the Mask: can HARMONI@ELT detect biosignatures in the reflected light of Proxima b?
• On spectroscopic phase-curve retrievals: H2 dissociation and thermal inversion in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-103 b
• Transmission spectroscopy of the lowest-density gas giant: metals and a potential extended outflow in HAT-P-67b
• Neutral metals in the atmosphere of HD149026b
• The hot Neptune WASP-166 b with ESPRESSO III: A blue-shifted tentative water signal constrains the presence of clouds
• High Resolution Spectroscopy and High Contrast Imaging with the ELT : looking for O${}_2$ in Proxima b
• Applications of a Gaussian Process Framework for Modelling of High-Resolution Exoplanet Spectra
• Discriminating between hazy and clear hot-Jupiter atmospheres with CARMENES
• A formally motivated retrieval framework applied to the high resolution transmission spectrum of HD 189733 b
• Water observed in the atmosphere of τ Bootis Ab with CARMENES/CAHA
• Multi-epoch detections of the extended atmosphere and transmission spectra of KELT-9b with a 1.5 m telescope
• Instrumentation prospects for rocky exoplanet atmospheres studies with high resolution spectroscopy
• Tighter constraints on the atmosphere of GJ 436 b from combined high-resolution CARMENES and CRIRES${}^{+}$ observations
• DARWEN: Data-driven Algorithm for Reduction of Wide Exoplanetary Networks
• Global Chemistry and Thermal Structure Models for the Hot Jupiter WASP-43b and Predictions for JWST
• Ground-based Atmospheric Characterization of Super-Earth L 98-59 d at High Spectral Resolution
• Open Source High-Resolution Exoplanet Atmosphere Retrievals with POSEIDON
• A First Look at CRIRES+: Performance Assessment and Exoplanet Spectroscopy
• TOI-1518b: A Misaligned Ultra-hot Jupiter with Iron in its Atmosphere
• Confirmation of Fe I on MASCARA-5 b's Dayside Observed With EXPRES