Dancing in the Dark: Uncertainty in ultra-faint dwarf galaxy predictions from cosmological simulations

Abstract

The existence of ultra-faint dwarf (UFD) galaxies highlights the need to push our theoretical understanding of galaxies to extremely low mass. We examine the formation of UFDs by twice running a fully cosmological simulations of dwarf galaxies, but varying star formation. One run uses a temperature-density threshold for star formation, while the other uses an H${}_2$-based sub-grid star formation model. The total number of dwarf galaxies that forms is different by a factor of 2 between the two runs, but most of these are satellites, leading to a factor of 5 difference in the number of luminous UFD companions around more massive, isolated dwarfs. The first run yields a 47\% chance of finding a satellite around a M${}_{halo}$ $\sim 10^{10}$ M${}_{\odot }$ host, while the H${}_2$ run predicts only a 16\% chance. Metallicity is the primary physical parameter that creates this difference. As metallicity decreases, the formation of H${}_2$ is slowed and relegated to higher-density material. Thus, our H${}_2$ run is unable to form many (and often, any) stars before reionization removes gas. These results emphasize that predictions for UFD properties made using hydrodynamic simulations, in particular regarding the frequency of satellites around dwarf galaxies, the slope of the stellar mass function at low masses, as well as the properties of ultra-faint galaxies occupying the smallest halos, are extremely sensitive to the subgrid physics of star formation contained within the simulation. However, upcoming discoveries of ultra-faint dwarfs will provide invaluable constraining power on the physics of the first star formation.

arXiv comment18 pages, 7 Figures. Accepted version, ApJ

References in corpus (130)

• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• The observed properties of dwarf galaxies in and around the Local Group
• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: the galaxy color bimodality
• Galaxies on FIRE (Feedback In Realistic Environments): Stellar Feedback Explains Cosmologically Inefficient Star Formation
• Radiative transfer in a clumpy universe: IV. New synthesis models of the cosmic UV/X-ray background
• FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
• At the heart of the matter: the origin of bulgeless dwarf galaxies and Dark Matter cores
• A model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation physics
• Ahf: Amiga's Halo Finder
• Radiation Pressure Supported Starburst Disks and AGN Fueling
• Star Formation and Feedback in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamic Simulations--I. Isolated Galaxies
• A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
• Cuspy No More: How Outflows Affect the Central Dark Matter and Baryon Distribution in Lambda CDM Galaxies
• The APOSTLE simulations: solutions to the Local Group's cosmic puzzles
• Eight New Milky Way Companions Discovered in First-Year Dark Energy Survey Data
• Stellar Feedback in Galaxies and the Origin of Galaxy-scale Winds
• Beasts of the Southern Wild: Discovery of nine Ultra Faint satellites in the vicinity of the Magellanic Clouds
• Eight Ultra-faint Galaxy Candidates Discovered in Year Two of the Dark Energy Survey
• The Star Formation Histories of Local Group Dwarf Galaxies I. Hubble Space Telescope / Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 Observations
• Towards a complete accounting of energy and momentum from stellar feedback in galaxy formation simulations
• Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition in Galaxies. II: HI and H_2 Column Densities
• The evolution substructure I: a new identification method
• The Enrichment of the Intergalactic Medium with Adiabatic Feedback I: Metal Cooling and Metal Diffusion
• Hundreds of Milky Way Satellites? Luminosity Bias in the Satellite Luminosity Function
• NIHAO project I: Reproducing the inefficiency of galaxy formation across cosmic time with a large sample of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
• Forged in FIRE: cusps, cores, and baryons in low-mass dwarf galaxies
• The total mass of the Large Magellanic Cloud from its perturbation on the Orphan stream
• Not so lumpy after all: modeling the depletion of dark matter subhalos by Milky Way-like galaxies
• Baryons Matter: Why Luminous Satellite Galaxies Have Reduced Central Masses
• The Quenching of the Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxies in the Reionization Era
• The Romulus Cosmological Simulations: A Physical Approach to the Formation, Dynamics and Accretion Models of SMBHs
• ELVIS: Exploring the Local Volume in Simulations
• Why Baryons Matter: The Kinematics of Dwarf Spheroidal Satellites
• Dark matter cores all the way down
• A Comparison of Methods for Determining the Molecular Content of Model Galaxies
• Molecular Hydrogen and Global Star Formation Relations in Galaxies
• The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project
• Towards a more realistic population of bright spiral galaxies in cosmological simulations
• Gasoline2: A Modern SPH Code
• The Origin and Evolution of the Mass-Metallicity Relationship for Galaxies: Results from Cosmological N-Body Simulations
• The impact of dark matter cusps and cores on the satellite galaxy population around spiral galaxies
• Radiation pressure from massive star clusters as a launching mechanism for super-galactic winds
• Modeling Molecular Hydrogen and Star Formation in Cosmological Simulations
• Hierarchical formation of bulgeless galaxies: Why outflows have low angular momentum
• FIRE in the Field: Simulating the Threshold of Galaxy Formation
• Damped Lyman Alpha Systems in Galaxy Formation Simulations
• Environmental Dependence of the Kennicutt-Schmidt Relation in Galaxies
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition in Galaxies. I: An Analytic Approximation for Photodissociation Fronts in Finite Clouds
• HI-to-H2 Transitions and H I Column Densities in Galaxy Star-Forming Regions
• A timing constraint on the (total) mass of the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The stellar mass-halo mass relation of isolated field dwarfs: a critical test of $\Lambda$CDM at the edge of galaxy formation
• The APOSTLE project: Local Group kinematic mass constraints and simulation candidate selection
• Bent by baryons: the low mass galaxy-halo relation
• Simulations of disk galaxies with cosmic ray driven galactic winds
• In-N-Out: the gas cycle from dwarfs to spiral galaxies
• The Meaning and Consequences of Star Formation Criteria in Galaxy Models with Resolved Stellar Feedback
• The distribution and kinematics of early high-sigma peaks in present-day haloes: implications for rare objects and old stellar populations
• Small Dwarf Galaxies Within Larger Dwarfs: Why Some Are Luminous While Most Go Dark
• Reproducing the Stellar Mass/Halo Mass Relation in Simulated LCDM Galaxies: Theory vs Observational Estimates
• The Star Formation Histories of Local Group Dwarf Galaxies II. Searching For Signatures of Reionization
• The Invisibles: A Detection Algorithm to Trace the Faintest Milky Way Satellites
• What Phase of the Interstellar Medium Correlates with the Star Formation Rate?
• Implementing Molecular Hydrogen in Hydrodynamic Simulations of Galaxy Formation
• The Birth of a Galaxy. II. The Role of Radiation Pressure
• The upper bound on the lowest mass halo
• Sweating the small stuff: simulating dwarf galaxies, ultra-faint dwarf galaxies, and their own tiny satellites
• MaGICC Disks: Matching Observed Galaxy Relationships Over a Wide Stellar Mass Range
• Toward first-principle simulations of galaxy formation: I. How should we choose star formation criteria in high-resolution simulations of disk galaxies?
• Cosmological Galaxy Formation Simulations Using SPH
• The abundance of (not just) dark matter haloes
• Infall of substructures onto a Milky Way-like dark halo
• A Magellanic Origin of the DES Dwarfs
• The Baryon Cycle of Dwarf Galaxies: Dark, Bursty, Gas-Rich Polluters
• Star Formation in Atomic Gas
• Horologium II: a Second Ultra-faint Milky Way Satellite in the Horologium Constellation
• The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. II: Isolated Disk Test
• Response of the Milky Way's disc to the Large Magellanic Cloud in a first infall scenario
• The role of cosmic ray pressure in accelerating galactic outflows
• The Missing Satellites of the Magellanic Clouds? Gaia Proper Motions of the Recently Discovered Ultra-Faint Galaxies
• Connecting the first galaxies with ultra faint dwarfs in the Local Group: chemical signatures of Population~III stars
• Impact of Cosmic Ray Transport on Galactic Winds
• Organized Chaos: Scatter in the relation between stellar mass and halo mass in small galaxies
• The total satellite population of the Milky Way
• The impact of chemistry on the structure of high-z galaxies
• The impact of stellar feedback on the structure, size and morphology of galaxies in Milky Way size dark matter haloes
• The Primeval Populations of the Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxies
• Dwarf galaxy formation with H2-regulated star formation
• All about baryons: revisiting SIDM predictions at small halo masses
• A Hero's Dark Horse: Discovery of an Ultra-Faint Milky Way Satellite in Pegasus
• Non-universal star formation efficiency in turbulent ISM
• Satellites of LMC-Mass Dwarfs: Close Friendships Ruined by Milky Way Mass Halos
• Self-Consistent Modeling of Reionization in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations
• The stellar-to-halo mass relation for Local Group galaxies
• First results from the MADCASH Survey: A Faint Dwarf Galaxy Companion to the Low Mass Spiral Galaxy NGC 2403 at 3.2 Mpc
• On the Kennicutt-Schmidt relation of low-metallicity high-redshift galaxies
• Identifying true satellites of the Magellanic Clouds
• How galaxies form stars: the connection between local and global star formation in galaxy simulations
• Role of Cosmic Rays in the Circumgalactic Medium
• Interpreting the Evolution of the Size - Luminosity Relation for Disk Galaxies from Redshift 1 to the Present
• Effects of baryon removal on the structure of dwarf spheroidal galaxies
• NIHAO XIV: Reproducing the observed diversity of dwarf galaxy rotation curve shapes in LCDM
• Approximations for modelling CO chemistry in GMCs: a comparison of approaches
• Satellites and Haloes of Dwarf Galaxies
• The predicted luminous satellite populations around SMC and LMC-mass galaxies - A missing satellite problem around the LMC?
• Searches for New Milky Way Satellites from the First Two Years of Data of the Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam Survey: Discovery of Cetus~III
• Clues to the "Magellanic Galaxy" from Cosmological Simulations
• On column density thresholds and the star formation rate
• How to Reconcile the Observed Velocity Function of Galaxies with Theory
• Reignition of Star Formation in Dwarf Galaxies
• Ships Passing in the Night: Spectroscopic Analysis of Two Ultra-Faint Satellites in the Constellation Carina
• The imprint of cosmic reionisation on the luminosity function of galaxies
• On the assembly of the Milky Way dwarf satellites and their common mass scale
• The effect of models of the interstellar media on the central mass distribution of galaxies
• An observer's guide to the (Local Group) dwarf galaxies: predictions for their own dwarf satellite populations
• Hunting Faint Dwarf Galaxies in the Field Using Integrated Light Surveys
• Dwarf Galaxy Formation with H2-Regulated Star Formation: II. Gas-Rich Dark Galaxies at Redshift 2.5
• The anatomy of a star-forming galaxy: Pressure-driven regulation of star formation in simulated galaxies
• Accretion of the Magellanic system onto the Galaxy
• The Abundance of Molecular Hydrogen and its Correlation with Midplane Pressure in Galaxies: Non-Equilibrium, Turbulent, Chemical Models
• The roles of radiation and ram pressure in driving galactic winds
• The Little Galaxies that Could (Reionize the Universe): Predicting Faint End Slopes & Escape Fractions at z > 4
• Simulating disc galaxy bulges that are consistent with observed scaling relations
• Where are All the Gas-Bearing Local Dwarf Galaxies? Quantifying Possible Impacts of Reionization
• $\Lambda$CDM Predictions for the Satellite Population of M33
• Local ultra faint dwarves as a product of Galactic processing during a Magellanic group infall
• Comparing galactic satellite properties in hydrodynamical and Nbody simulations
• Exploring Simulated Early Star Formation in the Context of the Ultrafaint Dwarf Galaxies
• Ultra faint dwarf galaxies: an arena for testing dark matter versus modified gravity
• Implementing Dust Shielding as a Criteria for Star Formation

Cited by in corpus (48)

• Milky Way Satellite Census. II. Galaxy--Halo Connection Constraints Including the Impact of the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Be it therefore resolved: Cosmological Simulations of Dwarf Galaxies with Extreme Resolution
• The SAGA Survey. II. Building a Statistical Sample of Satellite Systems around Milky Way-like Galaxies
• Milky Way Satellite Census. I. The Observational Selection Function for Milky Way Satellites in DES Y3 and Pan-STARRS DR1
• EDGE: the mass-metallicity relation as a critical test of galaxy formation physics
• Ultra-faint dwarfs in a Milky Way context: Introducing the Mint Condition DC Justice League Simulations
• The DECam Local Volume Exploration Survey: Overview and First Data Release
• The detailed structure and the onset of galaxy formation in low-mass gaseous dark matter haloes
• FIREbox: Simulating galaxies at high dynamic range in a cosmological volume
• Quantifying scatter in galaxy formation at the lowest masses
• Going, going, gone dark: Quantifying the scatter in the faintest dwarf galaxies
• NIHAO-UHD: The properties of MW-like stellar disks in high resolution cosmological simulations
• An extended halo around an ancient dwarf galaxy
• EDGE: From quiescent to gas-rich to star-forming low-mass dwarf galaxies
• EDGE: The origin of scatter in ultra-faint dwarf stellar masses and surface brightnesses
• Resolved Dwarf Galaxy Searches within ~5 Mpc with the Vera Rubin Observatory and Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam
• How low does it go? Too few Galactic satellites with standard reionization quenching
• Roll of the Dice: A Stochastically Sampled IMF Alters the Stellar Content of Simulated Dwarf Galaxies
• The role of faint population III supernovae in forming CEMP stars in ultra-faint dwarf galaxies
• The little things matter: relating the abundance of ultrafaint satellites to the hosts' assembly history
• GRUMPY: a simple framework for realistic forward-modelling of dwarf galaxies
• The LBT Satellites of Nearby Galaxies Survey (LBT-SONG): The Satellite Population of NGC 628
• Spatial Decorrelation of Young Stars and Dense Gas as a Probe of the Star Formation-Feedback Cycle in Galaxies
• Hubble Space Telescope Observations of Two Faint Dwarf Satellites of Nearby LMC Analogs from MADCASH
• EDGE: What shapes the relationship between HI and stellar observables in faint dwarf galaxies?
• An observational test for star formation prescriptions in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
• The cosmic UV background and the beginning and end of star formation in simulated field dwarf galaxies
• EDGE: The sensitivity of ultra-faint dwarfs to a metallicity-dependent initial mass function
• Simulating Metal Mixing of Both Common and Rare Enrichment Sources in a Low Mass Dwarf Galaxy
• Endothermic self-interacting dark matter in Milky Way-like dark matter haloes
• Satellite mass functions and the faint end of the galaxy mass-halo mass relation in LCDM
• EDGE: The emergence of dwarf galaxy scaling relations from cosmological radiation-hydrodynamics simulations
• Local Group star formation in warm and self-interacting dark matter cosmologies
• The baryon cycle of Seven Dwarfs with superbubble feedback
• Ultrafaint Dwarf Galaxy Candidates in the M81 Group: Signatures of Group Accretion
• The Milky Way, Coming into Focus: Precision Astrometry Probes its Evolution, and its Dark Matter
• Metallicity Distribution Function of the Eridanus~II Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxy from Hubble Space Telescope Narrow-band Imaging
• The Luminosity Functions and Redshift Evolution of Satellites of Low-Mass Galaxies in the COSMOS Survey
• Ghostly Stellar Haloes and their Relationship to Ultra-faint Dwarfs
• Predictions for Complex Distributions of Stellar Elemental Abundances in Low-Mass Galaxies
• Escaping the maze: a statistical sub-grid model for cloud-scale density structures in the interstellar medium
• A MARVEL-ous study of how well galaxy shapes reflect Dark Matter halo shapes in Cold Dark Matter Simulations
• Why do semi-analytic models predict higher scatter in the stellar mass-halo mass relation than cosmological hydrodynamic simulations?
• Machine Learning the Fates of Dark Matter Subhalos: A Fuzzy Crystal Ball
• Exploring the Diversity of Faint Satellites in the M81 Group
• Evolution of dwarf galaxy observable parameters
• CROCODILE-DWARF: Assembly and Kinematics of Field Dwarf Galaxies with GADGET4-OSAKA
• Turning Points in the Age-Metallicity Relations -- Created by Late Satellite Infall and Enhanced by Radial Migration