On Joint Distributions, Counterfactual Values, and Hidden Variables in Relation to Contextuality

Abstract

This paper deals with three traditional ways of defining contextuality: (C1) in terms of (non)existence of certain joint distributions involving measurements made in several mutually exclusive contexts; (C2) in terms of relationship between factual measurements in a given context and counterfactual measurements that could be made if one used other contexts; and (C3) in terms of (non)existence of ``hidden variables'' that determine the outcomes of all factually performed measurements. It is generally believed that the three meanings are equivalent, but the issues involved are not entirely transparent. Thus, arguments have been offered that C2 may have nothing to do with C1, and the traditional formulation of C1 itself encounters difficulties when measurement outcomes in a contextual system are treated as random variables. I show that if C1 is formulated within the framework of the Contextuality-by-Default (CbD) theory, the notion of a probabilistic coupling, the core mathematical tool of CbD, subsumes both counterfactual values and ``hidden variables''. In the latter case, a coupling itself can be viewed as a maximally parsimonious choice of a hidden variable.

arXiv commentTo be published in Dzhafarov, E.N. (2019). Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A

References in corpus (23)

• A simple test for hidden variables in spin-1 system
• An experimental test of non-local realism
• The Sheaf-Theoretic Structure Of Non-Locality and Contextuality
• Specker's Parable of the Over-protective Seer: A Road to Contextuality, Nonlocality and Complementarity (PLUS AN ERRATUM)
• Simple explanation of the quantum violation of a fundamental inequality
• All noncontextuality inequalities for the n-cycle scenario
• The contextual fraction as a measure of contextuality
• Necessary and Sufficient Conditions for Extended Noncontextuality in a Broad Class of Quantum Mechanical Systems
• Entropic Test of Quantum Contextuality
• Fundamental monogamy relation between contextuality and nonlocality
• Sequential modular position and momentum measurements of a trapped ion mechanical oscillator
• Contextuality in Canonical Systems of Random Variables
• Contextuality is About Identity of Random Variables
• Contextuality in Three Types of Quantum-Mechanical Systems
• Proof of a Conjecture on Contextuality in Cyclic Systems with Binary Variables
• What Quantum Measurements Measure
• Measures of Contextuality and Noncontextuality
• Probing the limits of correlations in an indivisible quantum system
• Contextuality Analysis of the Double Slit Experiment (With a Glimpse Into Three Slits)
• Quantum Measurements and Contextuality
• Single-photon quantum contextuality on a chip
• Testing noncontextuality inequalities that are building blocks of quantum correlations
• Replacing Nothing with Something Special: Contextuality-by-Default and Dummy Measurements

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Machine Learning meets Quantum Foundations: A Brief Survey
• Contextuality and Noncontextuality Measures and Generalized Bell Inequalities for Cyclic Systems
• Contextuality-by-Default description of Bell tests: Contextuality as the rule not as an exception
• Contextuality or nonlocality; what would John Bell choose today?
• Quantum Nonlocality: how does Nature do it?
• Assumption-free derivation of the Bell-type criteria of contextuality/nonlocality
• My discussions of quantum foundations with John Stewart Bell
• Epistemic Odds of Contextuality in Cyclic Systems
• Contextuality with disturbance and without: Neither can violate substantive requirements the other satisfies
• Contextuality Can be Verified with Noncontextual Experiments
• Contextuality and dichotomizations of random variables
• Quantum mechanics is compatible with counterfactual definiteness