Absence of a fundamental acceleration scale in galaxies

Abstract

The Radial Acceleration Relation confirms that a nontrivial acceleration scale can be found in the average internal dynamics of galaxies. The existence of such a scale is not obvious as far as the standard cosmological model is concerned, and it has been interpreted as a possible sign of modified gravity. The implications could be profound: it could in principle explain galactic dynamics without large amounts of yet-undetected dark matter and address issues that the standard cosmological model faces at galactic scales. Here, we consider 193 disk galaxies from the SPARC and THINGS databases and, using Bayesian inference, we show that the probability of existence of a fundamental acceleration that is common to all the galaxies is essentially zero: the $p$-value is smaller than $10^{-20}$ or, equivalently, the null hypothesis is rejected at more than 10$\sigma$. We conclude that the acceleration scale unveiled by the Radial Acceleration Relation is of emergent nature, possibly caused by a complex interplay between baryons and dark matter. In particular, the MOND theory, or any other theory that behaves like it at galactic scales, is ruled out as a fundamental theory for galaxies at more than 10$\sigma$.

arXiv comment16 pages, 2 figues, 1 table. This version does not match the published version at Nature Astronomy. See https://rdcu.be/ZXNT for the published version. Initially submitted on December 20, 2017

References in corpus (27)

• Results from a search for dark matter in the complete LUX exposure
• Small-Scale Challenges to the $\Lambda$CDM Paradigm
• THINGS: The HI Nearby Galaxy Survey
• High-Resolution Rotation Curves and Galaxy Mass Models from THINGS
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND): Observational Phenomenology and Relativistic Extensions
• First Dark Matter Search Results from the XENON1T Experiment
• The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics as an Alternative to Dark Matter
• SPARC: Mass Models for 175 Disk Galaxies with Spitzer Photometry and Accurate Rotation Curves
• The Radial Acceleration Relation in Rotationally Supported Galaxies
• Emergent Gravity and the Dark Universe
• One Law To Rule Them All: The Radial Acceleration Relation of Galaxies
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics in the Milky Way
• Small scale problems of the $\Lambda$CDM model: a short review
• Current status of direct dark matter detection experiments
• Clusters of galaxies with modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND)
• Testing Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Low Surface Brightness Galaxies --Rotation curve fits-
• Fitting the radial acceleration relation to individual SPARC galaxies
• THINGS about MOND
• The Mass-Discrepancy Acceleration Relation: a Natural Outcome of Galaxy Formation in Cold Dark Matter halos
• Are sterile neutrinos consistent with clusters, the CMB and MOND?
• The Real Problem with MOND
• Combined Solar System and rotation curve constraints on MOND
• The origin of the mass discrepancy-acceleration relation in $\Lambda$CDM
• Evidences against cuspy dark matter halos in large galaxies
• Galaxy Mass Models: MOND versus Dark Matter Halos
• Emergence of the mass discrepancy-acceleration relation from dark matter-baryon interactions

Cited by in corpus (53)

• From galactic bars to the Hubble tension: weighing up the astrophysical evidence for Milgromian gravity
• Reconciling the Diversity and Uniformity of Galactic Rotation Curves with Self-Interacting Dark Matter
• Dark Matter Cores and Cusps in Spiral Galaxies and their Explanations
• Predictions and Outcomes for the Dynamics of Rotating Galaxies
• NIHAO XVIII: Origin of the MOND phenomenology of galactic rotation curves in a LCDM universe
• The radial acceleration relation in galaxy clusters
• A common Milgromian acceleration scale in nature
• Modified Gravity (MOG) fits to observed radial acceleration of SPARC galaxies
• The radial acceleration relation in a $\Lambda$CDM universe
• Is there a fundamental acceleration scale in galaxies?
• Towards a full general relativistic approach to galaxies
• Dark matter profiles of SPARC galaxies: a challenge to fuzzy dark matter
• Radial Acceleration Relation between Baryons and Dark or Phantom Matter in the Super-critical Acceleration Regime of Nearly Spherical Galaxies
• Yet another test of Radial Acceleration Relation for galaxy clusters
• The Intrinsic Scatter of the Radial Acceleration Relation
• On the Presence of a Universal Acceleration Scale in Elliptical Galaxies
• A fundamental test for MOND
• Long Range Effects in Gravity Theories with Vainshtein Screening
• On the gravitational field of a point-like body immersed in quantum vacuum
• Reply to "Presence of a fundamental acceleration scale in galaxies" and "A common Milgromian acceleration scale in nature"
• A new line on the wide binary test of gravity
• Normalized additional velocity distribution: testing the radial profile of dark matter halos and MOND
• Directly testing gravity with Proxima Centauri
• Heat capacity of Holographic screen inspires MOND theory
• Stiff Matter Solution in Brans-Dicke Theory and The General Relativity Limit
• Baryon-Interacting Dark Matter: heating dark matter and the emergence of galaxy scaling relations
• Two new approaches to the anomalous limit of Brans-Dicke to Einstein gravity
• The solar system test for the general modified gravity theories
• A cautionary tale in fitting galaxy rotation curves with Bayesian techniques: does Newton's constant vary from galaxy to galaxy?
• There is no universal acceleration scale in galaxies
• Hamiltonian analysis of General Relativity and extended gravity from the iterative Faddeev-Jackiw symplectic approach
• Dynamical Regularities in Galaxies
• A test of Radial Acceleration Relation for the {\it Giles et al Chandra} cluster sample
• Evidence for Modified Newtonian Dynamics from Cavendish-type gravitational constant experiments
• Reply to: Overconfidence in Bayesian analyses of galaxy rotation curves
• Reconstructing a Model for Gravity at Large Distances from Dark Matter Density Profiles
• Theoretically motivated dark electromagnetism as the origin of relativistic MOND
• Solution of the dark matter riddle within standard model physics: From black holes, galaxies and clusters to cosmology
• ΛCDM with baryons vs. MOND: the time evolution of the universal acceleration scale in the Magneticum simulations
• Scale-invariant dynamics in the Solar System
• Exact semianalytical calculation of rotation curves with Bekenstein-Milgrom nonrelativistic MOND
• Slowly rotating Bose-Einstein Condensate confronted with the rotation curves of 12 dwarf galaxies
• Distortions of Robertson-Walker metric in perturbative cosmology and interpretation as dark matter and cosmological constant
• Prospects for a local detection of dark matter with future missions to Uranus and Neptune
• Dark Coincidences: Small-Scale Solutions with Refracted Gravity and MOND
• Quantum Modified Gravity at Low Energy in the Ricci Flow of Quantum Spacetime
• MUSE-DARK III: The evolution of the radial acceleration relation at intermediate redshifts
• Barions and $\Lambda$CDM Model Problems
• Fake dark matter from retarded distortions
• On the radial acceleration of disk galaxies
• A Toy Model for the Dynamical Discrepancies on Galactic Scales
• The radial acceleration relation and its emergent nature
• Geodesics in Quantum Gravity