Concepts of quantum non-Markovianity: a hierarchy
arXiv:1712.08879 · doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2018.07.001
Abstract
Markovian approximation is a widely-employed idea in descriptions of the dynamics of open quantum systems (OQSs). Although it is usually claimed to be a concept inspired by classical Markovianity, the term quantum Markovianity is used inconsistently and often unrigorously in the literature. In this report we compare the descriptions of classical stochastic processes and quantum stochastic processes (as arising in OQSs), and show that there are inherent differences that lead to the non-trivial problem of characterizing quantum non-Markovianity. Rather than proposing a single definition of quantum Markovianity, we study a host of Markov-related concepts in the quantum regime. Some of these concepts have long been used in quantum theory, such as quantum white noise, factorization approximation, divisibility, Lindblad master equation, etc.. Others are first proposed in this report, including those we call past-future independence, no (quantum) information backflow, and composability. All of these concepts are defined under a unified framework, which allows us to rigorously build hierarchy relations among them. With various examples, we argue that the current most often used definitions of quantum Markovianity in the literature do not fully capture the memoryless property of OQSs. In fact, quantum non-Markovianity is highly context-dependent. The results in this report, summarized as a hierarchy figure, bring clarity to the nature of quantum non-Markovianity.
arXiv commentClarifications and references added; discussion of the related classical hierarchy significantly improved. To appear in Physics Reports
References in corpus (68)
- Gaussian Quantum Information
- Quantum state engineering with Josephson-junction devices
- Decoherence Free Subspaces for Quantum Computation
- Dynamical Decoupling of Open Quantum Systems
- Dynamical suppression of decoherence in two-state quantum systems
- The Quantum Jump Approach to Dissipative Dynamics in Quantum Optics
- Measure for the Degree of Non-Markovian Behavior of Quantum Processes in Open Systems
- Non-Markovian dynamics in open quantum systems
- Entanglement and non-Markovianity of quantum evolutions
- Quantum Non-Markovianity: Characterization, Quantification and Detection
- A Theory of Quantum Error-Correcting Codes
- Dynamical decoupling and noise spectroscopy with a superconducting flux qubit
- Reference frames, superselection rules, and quantum information
- Universal dynamical decoupling of a single solid-state spin from a spin bath
- Optimized Dynamical Decoupling in a Model Quantum Memory
- Real-time quantum feedback prepares and stabilizes photon number states
- General Entanglement Breaking Channels
- Fault-Tolerant Quantum Dynamical Decoupling
- Experimental control of the transition from Markovian to non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems
- Quantum Fisher Information Flow in Non-Markovian Processes of Open Systems
- Quantum feedback control of a superconducting qubit: Persistent Rabi oscillations
- Non-Markovian Quantum State Diffusion
- Coherent and Collective Quantum Optical Effects in Mesoscopic Systems
- Structure of states which satisfy strong subadditivity of quantum entropy with equality
- Canonical form of master equations and characterization of non-Markovianity
- Non-Markovian quantum processes: complete framework and efficient characterisation
- Non-Markovian quantum jumps
- Thermalizing Quantum Machines: Dissipation and Entanglement
- Fundamentals of Quantum Information Theory
- Quantum Computers, Factoring, and Decoherence
- Dividing Quantum Channels
- Operational Markov condition for quantum processes
- On measures of non-Markovianity: divisibility vs. backflow of information
- Non-Markovian quantum dynamics: local versus non-local
- Quantum causal modelling
- Quantum Trajectories and Quantum Measurement Theory
- Non-Markovian quantum state diffusion: Perturbation approach
- Quantum-enhanced optical phase tracking
- Hierarchy of stochastic pure states for open quantum system dynamics
- Markovian and non-Markovian dynamics in quantum and classical systems
- Non-Markovianity through accessible information
- Collision-model-based approach to non-Markovian quantum dynamics
- Genuine quantum trajectories for non-Markovian processes
- Finding the Kraus decomposition from a master equation and vice versa
- Inferring causal structure: a quantum advantage
- Measuring non-Markovianity of processes with controllable system-environment interaction
- All (qubit) decoherences: Complete characterization and physical implementation
- Quantum regression theorem and non-Markovianity of quantum dynamics
- Non-Markovianity through flow of information between a system and an environment
- Simulation of indivisible qubit channels in collision models
- Pure-state quantum trajectories for general non-Markovian systems do not exist
- Equivalence between divisibility and monotonic decrease of information in classical and quantum stochastic processes
- Non-Markovian continuous quantum measurement of retarded observables
- The interpretation of non-Markovian stochastic Schrödinger equations as a hidden-variable theory
- Dynamical decoupling efficiency versus quantum non-Markovianity
- Markovianity criteria for quantum evolution
- Distinguishing decoherence from alternative quantum theories by dynamical decoupling
- The short-time and long-time behaviors of non-Markovianity measure using two-time correlation functions in open quantum systems
- An Efficient Quantum Jump Method for Coherent Energy Transfer Dynamics in Photosynthetic Systems under the Influence of Laser Fields
- Non-Markovian finite-temperature two-time correlation functions of system operators: beyond the quantum regression theorem
- Operational Characterization of Divisibility of Dynamical Maps
- Stochastic wave function approach to the calculation of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems
- A perturbative approach to non-Markovian stochastic Schrödinger equations
- Quantum state diffusion with a moving basis: computing quantum-optical spectra
- Dynamical Decoupling of Unbounded Hamiltonians
- Jump-like unravelings for non-Markovian open quantum systems
- Complete Parameterizations of Diffusive Quantum Monitorings
- Can Quantum Markov Evolutions Ever Be Dynamically Decoupled?
Cited by in corpus (263)
- IBM Q Experience as a versatile experimental testbed for simulating open quantum systems
- Quantum collision models: open system dynamics from repeated interactions
- Detecting crosstalk errors in quantum information processors
- Quantum stochastic processes and quantum non-Markovian phenomena
- Exploiting the causal tensor network structure of quantum processes to efficiently simulate non-Markovian path integrals
- Learning Quantum Systems
- Demonstration of non-Markovian process characterisation and control on a quantum processor
- Strong Coupling Thermodynamics of Open Quantum Systems
- Completely Positive Divisibility Does Not Mean Markovianity
- Open quantum system dynamics and the mean force Gibbs state
- Quantum Dynamics in Krylov Space: Methods and Applications
- Completely positive master equation for arbitrary driving and small level spacing
- Machine learning non-Markovian quantum dynamics
- Floquet Engineering to Reactivate a Dissipative Quantum Battery
- Optimized auxiliary oscillators for the simulation of general open quantum systems
- Non-Markovian Quantum Process Tomography
- Unifying Quantum and Classical Speed Limits on Observables
- When is a non-Markovian quantum process classical?
- Generalized theory of pseudomodes for exact descriptions of non-Markovian quantum processes
- Retrieving ideal precision in noisy quantum optical metrology
- Quantum Markov Order
- The Structure of Quantum Stochastic Processes with Finite Markov Order
- Non-Markovian quantum dynamics: What is it good for?
- Non-Markovian quantum dynamics: What does it mean?
- Non-Markovian dephasing and depolarizing channels
- Temporal self-similarity of quantum dynamical maps as a concept of memorylessness
- Experimental study of the thermodynamic uncertainty relation
- Efficient simulation of open quantum systems coupled to a fermionic bath
- Global Correlation and Local Information Flows in Controllable Non-Markovian Open Quantum Dynamics
- Facets of quantum information under non-Markovian evolution
- Accuracy of the quantum regression theorem for photon emission from a quantum dot
- Non-Markovian Sensing of a Quantum Reservoir
- Witnessing quantum memory in non-Markovian processes
- Experimental realization of high-fidelity teleportation via non-Markovian open quantum system
- Phase covariant qubit dynamics and divisibility
- There is no general connection between the quantum speed limit and non-Markovianity
- Experimental investigation of the effect of classical noise on quantum non-Markovian dynamics
- Synchronization and Non-Markovianity in open quantum systems
- Precursors of non-Markovianity
- Information flow versus divisibility for qubit evolution
- Capturing non-Markovian dynamics with the reaction coordinate method
- Experimental characterisation of a non-Markovian quantum process
- Non-Markovian thermal operations boosting the performance of quantum heat engines
- Experimental emulation of quantum non-Markovian dynamics and coherence protection in the presence of information backflow
- Entropic bounds on information backflow
- Quantum non-Markovianity: Overview and recent developments
- Resource theories of multi-time processes: A window into quantum non-Markovianity
- Classicality, Markovianity and local detailed balance from pure state dynamics
- Open system dynamics from thermodynamic compatibility
- On the dynamics of initially correlated open quantum systems: theory and applications
- Estimating the degree of non-Markovianity using machine learning
- Rate operator unravelling for open quantum system dynamics
- Capacity of non-Markovianity to boost the efficiency of molecular switches
- The interplay between local and non-local master equations: exact and approximated dynamics
- Diagrammatic method for many-body non-Markovian dynamics: memory effects and entanglement transitions
- Convex Combinations of Pauli Semigroups: Geometry, Measure and an Application
- Non-perturbative effects in corrections to quantum master equation arising in Bogolubov-van Hove limit
- Entanglement negativity as a universal non-Markovianity witness
- Information backflow as a resource for entanglement
- Fingerprint and universal Markovian closure of structured bosonic environments
- Hidden non-Markovianity in open quantum systems
- Quantum thermo-dynamical construction for driven open quantum systems
- On the universal constraints for relaxation rates for quantum dynamical semigroup
- Experimental investigation of Markovian and non-Markovian channel addition
- A discrete memory-kernel for multi-time correlations in non-Markovian quantum processes
- Experimental Demonstration of Instrument-specific Quantum Memory Effects and Non-Markovian Process Recovery for Common-Cause Processes
- Non-Markovian effects in the spin-boson model at zero temperature
- Entropic and trace distance based measures of non-Markovianity
- Unifying theory of quantum state estimation using past and future information
- Quantum regression beyond the Born-Markov approximation for generalized spin-boson models
- Enhancing quantum transport efficiency by tuning non-Markovian dephasing
- Quantum regression in dephasing phenomena
- Quantum simulation of non-Markovianity using the quantum Zeno effect
- Convex combinations of CP-divisible Pauli channels that are not semigroups
- A Practical Introduction to Benchmarking and Characterization of Quantum Computers
- Non-Markovian Memory Strength Bounds Quantum Process Recoverability
- Thermodynamics and the quantum speed limit in the non-Markovian regime
- Simple and maximally robust processes with no classical common-cause or direct-cause explanation
- MPSDynamics.jl: Tensor network simulations for finite-temperature (non-Markovian) open quantum system dynamics
- How quantum evolution with memory is generated in a time-local way
- Ping-pong quantum key distribution with trusted noise: non-Markovian advantage
- Extracting Quantum Dynamical Resources: Consumption of Non-Markovianity for Noise Reduction
- Non-Markovianity, information backflow and system-environment correlation for open-quantum-system processes
- A gradient algorithm for Hamiltonian identification of open quantum systems
- Classicality with(out) decoherence: Concepts, relation to Markovianity, and a random matrix theory approach
- Derivation of the Redfield quantum master equation and corrections to it by the Bogoliubov method
- Quantum non-Markovian environment-to-system backflows of information: non-operational vs. operational approaches
- Threshold for a discrete-variable sensor of quantum reservoirs
- Resource-efficient digital characterization and control of classical non-Gaussian noise
- Atomic Quantum Technologies for Quantum Matter and Fundamental Physics Applications
- Relaxation of Multitime Statistics in Quantum Systems
- On Markovianity and classicality in multilevel spin-boson models
- First Principles Numerical Demonstration of Emergent Decoherent Histories
- Non-Markovian dynamics under time-translation symmetry
- Equivalence between non-Markovian dynamics and correlation backflows
- Characterising the Hierarchy of Multi-time Quantum Processes with Classical Memory
- Interferometric Approach to Open Quantum Systems and Non-Markovian Dynamics
- Quantum causal correlations and non-Markovianity of quantum evolution
- Dissipative generators, divisible dynamical maps and Kadison-Schwarz inequality
- Quantum metrology with one auxiliary particle in a correlated bath and its quantum simulation
- Multipartite correlations in quantum collision models
- Quantum Uncertainty Principles for Measurements with Interventions
- Markovian semigroup from mixing non-invertible dynamical maps
- Quantum state smoothing: Why the types of observed and unobserved measurements matter
- Noisy quantum gyroscope
- On the connection between microscopic description and memory effects in open quantum system dynamics
- Quantum master equations for a system interacting with quantum gas in the low density limit and for the semiclassical collision model
- Local disclosure of quantum memory in non-Markovian dynamics
- Experimental Control of the Degree of Non-Classicality via Quantum Coherence
- Remote sensing and faithful quantum teleportation through non-localized qubits
- Fitting quantum noise models to tomography data
- Evolution equations for quantum semi-Markov dynamics
- Engineering fidelity of the generalized Pauli channels via legitimate memory kernels
- Optimizing performance of quantum operations with non-Markovian decoherence: the tortoise or the hare?
- Topological Protection and Control of Quantum Markovianity
- Memory Effects in Quantum Processes
- Dissipative dynamics of quantum correlation quantifiers under decoherence channels
- Singularities, mixing and non-Markovianity of Pauli dynamical maps
- Non-Markovian memory in IBMQX4
- Quantum probing topological phase transitions by non-Markovianity
- Dephasing dynamics of an impurity coupled to an anharmonic environment
- Entanglement dynamics of coupled quantum oscillators in independent nonMarkovian baths
- Activating information backflow with the assistance of quantum SWITCH
- Quantum speed limit time: role of coherence
- Transfer-tensor description of memory effects in open-system dynamics and multi-time statistics
- Noise mitigation in quantum teleportation
- Generalized Quantum Fluctuation Theorem for Energy Exchange
- Trajectory tracking for non-Markovian quantum systems
- Invertibility as a witness of Markovianity of the quantum dynamical maps
- Photonic dephasing dynamics and role of initial correlations
- Relating Heat and Entanglement in Strong Coupling Thermodynamics
- The effect of quantum memory on quantum speed limit time for CP-(in)divisible channels
- Strongly coupled quantum Otto cycle with single qubit bath
- From Non-Markovian Dissipation to Spatiotemporal Control of Quantum Nanodevices
- Non-perturbative treatment of open-system multi-time expectation values in Gaussian bosonic environments
- On the classicality of quantum dephasing processes
- Perturbation theory for operational quantum non-Markovianity
- Harnessing quantumness of states using discrete Wigner functions under (non)-Markovian quantum channels
- Exact dynamics and thermalization of open quantum systems coupled to reservoir through particle exchanges
- Noninvertibility as a requirement for creating a semigroup under convex combinations of channels
- Memory in quantum processes with indefinite time direction and causal order
- Exact Hidden Markovian Dynamics in Quantum Circuits
- Pseudomode treatment of strong-coupling quantum thermodynamics
- Measure of not-completely-positive qubit maps: the general case
- Non-Markovian noise that cannot be dynamically decoupled by periodic spin echo pulses
- Unruh effect and information flow
- Long-time Markovianity of multi-level systems in the rotating wave approximation
- Detection of Bidirectional System-Environment Information Exchanges
- Non-Markovian effect on quantum optical metrology under dissipative environment
- Continuous and time-discrete non-Markovian system-reservoir interactions: Dissipative coherent quantum feedback in Liouville space
- Measure of positive and not completely positive single-qubit Pauli maps
- Measurement-induced cooling of a qubit in structured environments
- Control of quantum noise: on the role of dilations
- Non-Markovianity criteria for mixtures of noninvertible Pauli dynamical maps
- Construction of propagators for divisible dynamical maps
- A solvable class of non-Markovian quantum multipartite dynamics
- Quantum processes as thermodynamic resources: the role of non-Markovianity
- Quantum Markov monogamy inequalities
- Capturing long-range memory structures with tree-geometry process tensors
- Protecting quantum correlations of negative quantum states using weak measurement under non-Markovian noise
- Noninvertibility and non-Markovianity of quantum dynamical maps
- Phase covariant channel: Quantum speed limit of evolution
- Exploring Non-Markovianity in Ergodic Channels: Measuring Memory Retention through Ergotropy
- Memory effects in quantum dynamics modelled by quantum renewal processes
- Grassmann time-evolving matrix product operators: An efficient numerical approach for fermionic path integral simulations
- Limitations to Dynamical Error Suppression and Gate-Error Virtualization from Temporally Correlated Nonclassical Noise
- Quantum optimal control in quantum technologies. Strategic report on current status, visions and goals for research in Europe
- Hidden Quantum Memory: Is Memory There When Somebody Looks?
- Collisional open quantum dynamics with a generally correlated environment: Exact solvability in tensor networks
- Experimental Snapshot Verification of non-Markovianity with Unknown System-Probe Coupling
- Quantumness of channels
- Non-Hermitian quantum walks and non-Markovianity: the coin-position interaction
- Nearly Markovian maps and entanglement-based bound on corresponding non-Markovianity
- Quantum circuit simulation of superchannels
- Information Loss Pathways in a Numerically Exact Simulation of a non-Markovian Open Quantum System
- Positivity and complete positivity of differentiable quantum processes
- Relations between Markovian and non-Markovian correlations in multitime quantum processes
- Dressed Quantum Trajectories: Novel Approach to the non-Markovian Dynamics of Open Quantum Systems on a Wide Time Scale
- Comparison of Distances and Entropic Distinguishability Quantifiers for the Detection of Memory Effects
- Distributing Memory Effects in an Open Two-Qubit System
- Non-monotonic population and coherence evolution in Markovian open-system dynamics
- Renormalization group for open quantum systems using environment temperature as flow parameter
- Non-Markovian modeling of Fermi-Bose systems coupled to one or several Fermi-Bose thermal baths
- Noise-adapted Quantum Error Correction for Non-Markovian Noise
- Preparations and Weak Quantum Control can Witness non-Markovianity
- Making Quantum Collision Models Exact
- Non-Markovianity of subsystem dynamics in isolated quantum many-body systems
- Time-delayed quantum feedback and incomplete decoherence suppression with no-knowledge measurement
- Memory effects in multipartite systems coupled by non-diagonal dephasing mechanisms
- Prethermalization of quantum systems interacting with non-equilibrium environments
- Quantum non-Markovian "casual bystander" environments
- Experimental realization of quantum non-Markovianity through the convex mixing of Pauli semigroups on an NMR quantum processor
- Semi-device-independent certification of quantum non-Markovianity using sequential Random Access Codes
- Influence of initial states on memory effects: A study of early-time superradiance
- Boson-boson pure-dephasing model with non-Markovian properties
- Entropic witness for quantum memory in open system dynamics
- Unitary Evolutions Sourced By Interacting Quantum Memories: Closed Quantum Systems Directing Themselves Using Their State Histories
- Quantum state smoothing cannot be assumed classical even when the filtering and retrofiltering are classical
- Non-Markovian dynamics of the electronic subsystem in a laser-driven molecule: Characterization and connections with electronic-vibrational entanglement and electronic coherence
- On the non-Markovianity of quantum semi-Markov processes
- Hamiltonian characterisation of multi-time processes with classical memory
- On the eternal non-Markovianity of non-unital quantum channels
- How to describe collective decay of uncoupled modes in the input-output formalism
- System-environment quantum information flow
- Spectral signatures of the Markovian to Non-Markovian transition in open quantum systems
- Influence of polarization and the environment on wave-particle duality
- Two-time correlation functions beyond quantum regression theorem: Effect of external noise
- Open quantum systems in thermal non-ergodic environments
- Digital simulation of convex mixtures of Markovian and non-Markovian single qubit Pauli channels on NISQ devices
- Non-Markovianity in the Adapted Caldeira-Leggett model
- Unidirectional information flow and positive divisibility are nonequivalent notions of quantum Markovianity for noninvertible dynamics
- Verifying Quantum Memory in the Dynamics of Spin Boson Models
- Correlated and Critical Phenomena in Multipartite Quantum Non-Markovianity
- Non-Markovianity in the time evolution of open quantum systems assessed by means of quantum state distance
- Jaynes-Cummings atoms coupled to a structured environment: Leakage elimination operators and the Petz recovery maps
- A family of quantum von Neumann architecture
- Optimality and Complexity in Measured Quantum-State Stochastic Processes
- Necessary Criteria for Markovian Divisibility of Linear Maps
- Experimental simulation of quantum superchannels
- Eventually entanglement breaking divisible quantum dynamics
- Lindblad-like quantum tomography for non-Markovian quantum dynamical maps
- Information flow-enhanced precision in collisional quantum thermometry
- Fermionic duality: General symmetry of open systems with strong dissipation and memory
- Eternally non-Markovian dynamics of a qubit interacting with a single-photon wavepacket
- Upper bounds on the leakage of private data and operational approach to markovianity
- Quantum enhancement of qutrit dynamics through driving field and photonic band-gap crystal
- Information back-flow in quantum non-Markovian dynamics and its connection to teleportation
- Memory effects displayed in the evolution of continuous variable system
- Excitation-damping quantum channels
- Quantum state-preparation control in noisy environment via most-likely paths
- Pure non-Markovian evolutions
- Classical Invasive Description of Informationally-Complete Quantum Processes
- Detecting Markovianity of Quantum Processes via Recurrent Neural Networks
- Coarse-grained dynamics in quantum many-body systems using the maximum entropy principle
- Completely positive trace-preserving maps for higher-order unraveling of Lindblad master equations
- Phase space measures of information flow in open systems: A quantum and classical perspective of non-Markovianity
- Theory-independent monitoring of the decoherence of a superconducting qubit with generalized contextuality
- -Positive Maps: New Characterizations and a Generation Method
- A Fractional Calculus Framework for Open Quantum Dynamics: From Liouville to Lindblad to Memory Kernels
- Exact dynamics and bound states of a cavity coupled to a two-dimensional reservoir
- Protecting spin squeezing from decoherence
- Efficient measure of information backflow with a quasistochastic process
- Quantum state smoothing when Alice assumes the wrong type of monitoring by Bob
- Toy Model Challenging Prevailing Definitions of Classicality
- Decoherence-free subspaces and Markovian revival of genuine multipartite entanglement in a dissipative system
- Quantum walks under superposition of causal order
- Quantum vs Classical Thermal Transport at Low Temperatures
- Control of memory effects in a spin-boson system by periodic driving
- Superactivation of memory effects in a classical Markov environment
- Collective Quantum Batteries and Charger-Battery Setup in Open Quantum Systems: Impact of Inter-Qubit Interactions, Dissipation, and Quantum Criticality
- Open quantum dynamics with singularities: Master equations and degree of non-Markovianity
- Temporal nonclassicality in continuous-time quantum walks
- Third quantization with Hartree approximation for open-system bosonic transport
- Infinite dimensional dynamical maps
- From Superradiance to Superabsorption: An Exact Treatment of Non-Markovian Cooperative Radiation
- Geometric signature of non-Markovian dynamics
- Polaron effects on the information backflow in Jaynes-Cummings model
- Quantum non-Markovianity elusive to interventions
- Bohmian Mechanics as a Practical Tool
- Non-Markovianity-based ultrasensitive parameter estimation
- Unification of stochastic matrices and quantum operations for N-level systems
- Efficient learning and optimizing non-Gaussian correlated noise in digitally controlled qubit systems
- Quantifying Irreversibility via Bayesian Subjectivity for Classical & Quantum Linear Maps