Quantum state smoothing cannot be assumed classical even when the filtering and retrofiltering are classical

Abstract

State smoothing is a technique to estimate a state at a particular time, conditioned on information obtained both before (past) and after (future) that time. For a classical system, the smoothed state is a normalized product of the $\text{filtered state}$ (a state conditioned only on the past measurement information and the initial preparation) and the $\text{retrofiltered effect}$ (depending only on the future measurement information). For the quantum case, whilst there are well-established analogues of the filtered state (${\rho }_{\mathrm{F}}$) and retrofiltered effect (${\hat{E}}_{\mathrm{R}}$), their product does not, in general, provide a valid quantum state for smoothing. However, this procedure does seem to work when ${\rho }_{\mathrm{F}}$ and ${\hat{E}}_{\mathrm{R}}$ are mutually diagonalizable. This fact has been used to obtain smoothed quantum states -- more pure than the filtered states -- in a number of experiments on continuously monitored quantum systems, in cavity QED and atomic systems. In this paper we show that there is an implicit assumption underlying this technique: that if all the information were known to the observer, the true system state would be one of the diagonal basis states. This assumption does not necessarily hold, as the missing information is quantum information. It could be known to the observer only if it were turned into a classical measurement record, but then its nature depends on the choice of measurement. We show by a simple model that, depending on that measurement choice, the smoothed quantum state can: agree with that from the classical method; disagree with it but still be co-diagonal with it; or not even be co-diagonal with it. That is, just because filtering and retrofiltering appear classical does not mean classical smoothing theory is applicable in quantum experiments.

20 Pages, 9 Figures. Comments are welcomed!

References in corpus (13)

• Quantum-enhanced optical phase tracking
• Time-Symmetric Quantum Theory of Smoothing
• Collision models can efficiently simulate any multipartite Markovian quantum dynamics
• Quantum theory of optical temporal phase and instantaneous frequency. II. Continuous time limit and state-variable approach to phase-locked loop design
• Unifying theory of quantum state estimation using past and future information
• Pushing the limits in real-time measurements of quantum dynamics
• Estimating a fluctuating magnetic field with a continuously monitored atomic ensemble
• Classicality with(out) decoherence: Concepts, relation to Markovianity, and a random matrix theory approach
• Quantum smoothing for classical mixtures
• Effective damping in the Raman cooling of trapped ions
• General criteria for quantum state smoothing with necessary and sufficient criteria for linear Gaussian quantum systems
• Quantum state smoothing as an optimal estimation problem with three different cost functions
• Smoothed quantum-classical states in time-irreversible hybrid dynamics

Cited by in corpus (3)

• Inequivalent ways to apply semi-classical smoothing to a quantum system
• A Retrodictive Approach to Quantum State Smoothing
• Quantum state smoothing when Alice assumes the wrong type of monitoring by Bob