How proper are Bayesian models in the astronomical literature?
arXiv:1712.03549 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2326
Abstract
The well-known Bayes theorem assumes that a posterior distribution is a probability distribution. However, the posterior distribution may no longer be a probability distribution if an improper prior distribution (non-probability measure) such as an unbounded uniform prior is used. Improper priors are often used in the astronomical literature to reflect a lack of prior knowledge, but checking whether the resulting posterior is a probability distribution is sometimes neglected. It turns out that 23 articles out of 75 articles (30.7%) published online in two renowned astronomy journals (ApJ and MNRAS) between Jan 1, 2017 and Oct 15, 2017 make use of Bayesian analyses without rigorously establishing posterior propriety. A disturbing aspect is that a Gibbs-type Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method can produce a seemingly reasonable posterior sample even when the posterior is not a probability distribution (Hobert and Casella, 1996). In such cases, researchers may erroneously make probabilistic inferences without noticing that the MCMC sample is from a non-existing probability distribution. We review why checking posterior propriety is fundamental in Bayesian analyses, and discuss how to set up scientifically motivated proper priors.
References in corpus (92)
- emcee: The MCMC Hammer
- Modeling the Time Variability of SDSS Stripe 82 Quasars as a Damped Random Walk
- HD 209458b in New Light: Evidence of Nitrogen Chemistry, Patchy Clouds and Sub-Solar Water
- Standing on the shoulders of Dwarfs: the asteroseismic LEGACY sample I - oscillation mode parameters
- First evidence of running cosmic vacuum: challenging the concordance model
- KiDS-450: The tomographic weak lensing power spectrum and constraints on cosmological parameters
- Firefly (Fitting IteRativEly For Likelihood analYsis): a full spectral fitting code
- Finding counterparts for All-sky X-ray surveys with Nway: a Bayesian algorithm for cross-matching multiple catalogues
- The Radio Spectral Energy Distribution and Star Formation Rate Calibration in Galaxies
- Constraining Formation Models of Binary Black Holes with Gravitational-Wave Observations
- Cosmic Neutrino Pevatrons: A Brand New Pathway to Astronomy, Astrophysics, and Particle Physics
- Deriving a multivariate CO-to-H conversion function using the [CII]/CO(1-0) ratio and its application to molecular gas scaling relations
- Bombs and flares at the surface and lower atmosphere of the Sun
- Determining stellar parameters of asteroseismic targets: going beyond the use of scaling relations
- Emulating Simulations of Cosmic Dawn for 21cm Power Spectrum Constraints on Cosmology, Reionization, and X-ray Heating
- Wide Binaries in Tycho-{\it Gaia}: Search Method and the Distribution of Orbital Separations
- The Fornax Deep Survey with VST. II. Fornax A: a two-phase assembly caught on act
- WISDOM Project - II: Molecular gas measurement of the supermassive black hole mass in NGC4697
- Photometric redshifts for the next generation of deep radio continuum surveys - I: Template fitting
- Apparent cosmic acceleration from type Ia supernovae
- A Multi-Membership Catalogue for 1876 Open Clusters using UCAC4 data
- The Grism Lens-Amplified Survey from Space (GLASS) X. Sub-kpc resolution gas-phase metallicity maps at cosmic noon behind the Hubble Frontier Fields cluster MACS1149.6+2223
- From Neutron Star Observables to the Equation of State. II. Bayesian Inference of Equation of State Pressures
- The Type Ia Supernova Color-Magnitude Relation and Host Galaxy Dust: A Simple Hierarchical Bayesian Model
- A Comprehensive Study of Ly Emission in the High-redshift Galaxy Population
- SPIDERS: Selection of spectroscopic targets using AGN candidates detected in all-sky X-ray surveys
- Daily monitoring of TeV gamma-ray emission from Mrk 421, Mrk 501, and the Crab Nebula with HAWC
- A fast estimator for the bispectrum and beyond - A practical method for measuring non-Gaussianity in 21-cm maps
- HICOSMO - Cosmology with a complete sample of galaxy clusters: II. Cosmological results
- The Spectral Energy Distribution of Powerful Starburst Galaxies I: Modelling the Radio Continuum
- Understanding the Scatter in the Spatially-resolved Star Formation Main Sequence of Local Massive Spiral Galaxies
- The resolved stellar populations around 12 Type IIP supernovae
- Artificial intelligence applied to the automatic analysis of absorption spectra. Objective measurement of the fine structure constant
- CLASH: Accurate Photometric Redshifts with 14 HST bands in Massive Galaxy Cluster Cores
- The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters XIV: Bayesian Single-Population Analysis of 69 Globular Clusters
- Orbits of massive satellite galaxies: II. Bayesian Estimates of the Milky Way and Andromeda masses using high precision astrometry and cosmological simulations
- Approximate Bayesian Computation in Large Scale Structure: constraining the galaxy-halo connection
- CoMaLit-V. Mass forecasting with proxies. Method and application to weak lensing calibrated samples
- 2D Bayesian automated tilted-ring fitting of disk galaxies in large HI galaxy surveys: 2DBAT
- Extending the Calibration of CIV-Based Single-Epoch Black Hole Mass Estimators for Active Galactic Nuclei
- The Production of Cold Gas Within Galaxy Outflows
- Extreme radio-wave scattering associated with hot stars
- Growth of First Galaxies: Impacts of Star Formation and Stellar Feedback
- Centroid vetting of transiting planet candidates from the Next Generation Transit Survey
- Jet formation in solar atmosphere due to magnetic reconnection
- Bayesian Mass Estimates of the Milky Way: including measurement uncertainties with hierarchical Bayes
- Bayesian Redshift Classification of Emission-line Galaxies with Photometric Equivalent Widths
- CODEX Weak Lensing: Concentration of Galaxy Clusters at z ~ 0.5
- Modelling the Milky Way's globular cluster system
- Detecting Damped Lyman- Absorbers with Gaussian Processes
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: Dynamical models of flattened, rotating globular clusters
- The Relationship Between Brightest Cluster Galaxy Star Formation and the Intracluster Medium in CLASH
- Exploding Satellites -- The Tidal Debris of the Ultra-Faint Dwarf Galaxy Hercules
- Polarised kink waves in magnetic elements: evidence for chromospheric helical waves
- Wavelet-Bayesian inference of cosmic strings embedded in the cosmic microwave background
- Robust, open-source removal of systematics in Kepler data
- Exploring the IMF of star clusters: a joint SLUG and LEGUS effort
- The Thermal Proximity Effect: A New Probe of He II Reionization History and the Quasar Lifetime
- Bayesian Estimates of Astronomical Time Delays between Gravitationally Lensed Stochastic Light Curves
- Resolved stellar streams around NGC4631 from a Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam survey
- The Clustering of Galaxies in the Completed SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: Cosmic Flows and Cosmic Web from Luminous Red Galaxies
- Taming outliers in pulsar-timing datasets with hierarchical likelihoods and Hamiltonian sampling
- Luminous Infrared Galaxies with the Submillimeter Array V: Molecular Gas in Intermediate to Late-stage Mergers
- Inference of Unresolved Point Sources At High Galactic Latitudes Using Probabilistic Catalogs
- Galactic googly: the rotation-metallicity bias in the inner stellar halo of the Milky Way
- How to make a mature accreting magnetar
- Doubly imaged quasar SDSS J1515+1511: time delay and lensing galaxies
- Balmer filaments in Tycho's supernova remnant: an interplay between cosmic-ray and broad-neutral precursors
- A novel method to automatically detect and measure the ages of star clusters in nearby galaxies: Application to the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Observed Faraday Effects in Damped Lyman-Alpha Absorbers and Lyman Limit Systems: The Magnetised Environment of Galactic Building Blocks at Redshift=2
- Removing biases in resolved stellar mass-maps of galaxy disks through successive Bayesian marginalization
- On the detection probability of neutron star glitches
- Comparison of damping mechanisms for transverse waves in solar coronal loops
- Galaxy properties from J-PAS narrow-band photometry
- Joint Bayesian Estimation of Quasar Continua and the Lyman-Alpha Forest Flux Probability Distribution Function
- MC^2: A deeper look at ZwCl 2341.1+0000 with Bayesian galaxy clustering and weak lensing analyses
- Resolving the Discrepancy of Distance to M60, a Giant Elliptical Galaxy in Virgo
- Rapid Optical Variations Correlated with X-rays in the 2015 Second Outburst of V404 Cygni (GS 2023338)
- Can Turbulence Dominate Depolarization of Optical Blazars?
- Spatial structure of several diffuse interstellar band carriers
- A geometric approach to non-linear correlations with intrinsic scatter
- Sparse Bayesian Inference and the Temperature Structure of the Solar Corona
- Searching for planetary signals in Doppler time series: a performance evaluation of tools for periodograms analysis
- A Hierarchical Model for the Ages of Galactic Halo White Dwarfs
- Data-dependent Posterior Propriety of Bayesian Beta-Binomial-Logit Model
- Surprise in simplicity: an unusual spectral evolution of a single pulse GRB 151006A
- The Rest-Frame Golenetskii Correlation via a Hierarchical Bayesian Analysis
- Maximum a posteriori estimation through simulated annealing for binary asteroid orbit determination
- Faint Object Detection in Multi-Epoch Observations via Catalog Data Fusion
- Resonant structure, formation and stability of the planetary system HD155358
- A new statistical method for characterizing the atmospheres of extrasolar planets
- Frequency Coverage Properties of a Uniform Shrinkage Prior Distribution
Cited by in corpus (18)
- Juliet: a versatile modelling tool for transiting and non-transiting exoplanetary systems
- Constraints on the sum of the neutrino masses in dynamical dark energy models with are tighter than those obtained in CDM
- A massive stellar bulge in a regularly rotating galaxy 1.2 billion years after the Big Bang
- Time Delay Lens Modelling Challenge
- A Bayesian direct method implementation to fit emission line spectra: Application to the primordial He abundance determination
- Looking at Blazar Light Curve Periodicities with Gaussian Processes
- JINGLE V: Dust properties of nearby galaxies derived from hierarchical Bayesian SED fitting
- A New Method to Constrain the Appearance and Disappearance of Observed Jellyfish Galaxy Tails
- Modeling Stochastic Variability in Multi-Band Time Series Data
- Mapping the Growth of Supermassive Black Holes as a Function of Galaxy Stellar Mass and Redshift
- Incorporating Measurement Error in Astronomical Object Classification
- A search for thermal gyro-synchrotron emission from hot stellar coronae
- Six Maxims of Statistical Acumen for Astronomical Data Analysis
- Realizing the potential of astrostatistics and astroinformatics
- Re-examining the Bayesian colour excess estimation for the local star-forming galaxies observed in the HETDEX Pilot Survey
- GPU-Accelerated Hierarchical Bayesian Inference with Application to Modeling Cosmic Populations: CUDAHM
- A Robust Bayesian Meta-Analysis for Estimating the Hubble Constant via Time Delay Cosmography
- The paper "How proper are Bayesian models in the astronomical literature?" [arXiv:1712.03549] by Tak, Ghosh and Ellis is improper