Incompatible Multiple Consistent Sets of Histories and Measures of Quantumness
arXiv:1704.01783 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.96.012123
Abstract
In the consistent histories (CH) approach to quantum theory probabilities are assigned to histories subject to a consistency condition of negligible interference. The approach has the feature that a given physical situation admits multiple sets of consistent histories that cannot in general be united into a single consistent set, leading to a number of counter-intuitive or contrary properties if propositions from different consistent sets are combined indiscriminately. An alternative viewpoint is proposed in which multiple consistent sets are classified according to whether or not there exists any unifying probability for combinations of incompatible sets which replicates the consistent histories result when restricted to a single consistent set. A number of examples are exhibited in which this classification can be made, in some cases with the assistance of the Bell, CHSH or Leggett-Garg inequalities together with Fine's theorem. When a unifying probability exists logical deductions in different consistent sets can in fact be combined, an extension of the "single framework rule". It is argued that this classification coincides with intuitive notions of the boundary between classical and quantum regimes and in particular, the absence of a unifying probability for certain combinations of consistent sets is regarded as a measure of the "quantumness" of the system. The proposed approach and results are closely related to recent work on the classification of quasi-probabilities and this connection is discussed.
arXiv comment29 pages. Second revised version with discussion of the sample space and non-uniqueness of the unifying probability and small errors corrected
References in corpus (31)
- Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical
- Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
- Contextuality for preparations, transformations, and unsharp measurements
- Leggett-Garg Inequalities
- On the Consistent Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanics
- Quantum Logic and the Histories Approach to Quantum Theory
- Consistent Histories and Quantum Reasoning
- Do we really understand quantum mechanics?
- Choice of Consistent Family, and Quantum Incompatibility
- Quantum temporal logic and decoherence functionals in the histories approach to generalised quantum theory
- Properties of Consistent Histories
- Consistent Sets Yield Contrary Inferences in Quantum Theory
- Somewhere in the Universe: Where is the Information Stored When Histories Decohere?
- The Leggett-Garg Inequalities and No-Signalling in Time: A Quasi-Probability Approach
- Consistent Quantum Counterfactuals
- Linearly Positive Histories: Probabilities for a Robust Family of Sequences of Quantum Events
- EPR, Bell, and Quantum Locality
- Anomalies of weakened decoherence criteria for quantum histories
- Comment on ``Consistent Sets Yield Contrary Inferences in Quantum Theory''
- The Three-Box Paradox Revisited
- Can the Decoherent Histories Description of Reality be Considered Satisfactory?
- The New Quantum Logic
- Two Proofs of Fine's Theorem
- Negative Probabilities, Fine's Theorem and Linear Positivity
- How the Quantum Universe Became Classical
- Consistent Sets and Contrary Inferences: Reply to Griffiths and Hartle
- On the Consistency of the Consistent Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanics
- About the Notion of Truth in the Decoherent Histories Approach: a reply to Griffiths
- Consistent histories, quantum truth functionals, and hidden variables
- Contrary Inferences in Consistent Histories and a Set Selection Criterion
- Does a Quantum Particle Know its Own Energy?