Contrary Inferences in Consistent Histories and a Set Selection Criterion
arXiv:1402.3733 · doi:10.1007/s10701-014-9837-6
Abstract
The best developed formulation of closed system quantum theory that handles multiple-time statements, is the consistent (or decoherent) histories approach. The most important weaknesses of the approach is that it gives rise to many different consistent sets, and it has been argued that a complete interpretation should be accompanied with a natural mechanism leading to a (possibly) unique preferred consistent set. The existence of multiple consistent sets becomes more problematic because it allows the existence of contrary inferences (Kent 1997). We analyse the conceptual difficulties that arise from the existence of multiple consistent sets and provide a suggestion for a natural set selection criterion. This criterion does not lead to a unique physical consistent set, however it evades the existence of consistent sets with contrary inferences. The criterion is based on the concept of preclusion and the requirement that probability one propositions and their inferences should be noncontextual. The allowed consistent sets turn-out to be compatible with coevents which are the ontology of an alternative, histories based, formulation.
arXiv comment13 pages. Accepted in Found Phys. V2 expanded after reviewing
References in corpus (25)
- Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
- Quantum Mechanics as Quantum Measure Theory
- On the Consistent Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanics
- Choice of Consistent Family, and Quantum Incompatibility
- Properties of Consistent Histories
- Consistent Sets Yield Contrary Inferences in Quantum Theory
- Topos Theory and Consistent Histories: The Internal Logic of the Set of all Consistent Sets
- Quantum Dynamics without the Wave Function
- Quasiclassical Coarse Graining and Thermodynamic Entropy
- Linearly Positive Histories: Probabilities for a Robust Family of Sequences of Quantum Events
- An exercise in "anhomomorphic logic"
- Comment on ``Consistent Sets Yield Contrary Inferences in Quantum Theory''
- The Random Walk in Generalized Quantum Theory
- Linear Positivity and Virtual Probability
- The New Quantum Logic
- Consistent Sets and Contrary Inferences: Reply to Griffiths and Hartle
- The Kochen-Specker Theorem Revisited in Quantum Measure Theory
- A histories perspective on characterising quantum non-locality
- Hilbert Spaces from Path Integrals
- On the Consistency of the Consistent Histories Approach to Quantum Mechanics
- Dynamics & Predictions in the Co-Event Interpretation
- Spacetime Coarse Grainings in the Decoherent Histories Approach to Quantum Theory
- Quantum Histories and Their Implications
- The coevent formulation of quantum theory
- Does a Quantum Particle Know its Own Energy?