Galactic Doppelganger: The chemical similarity among field stars and among stars with a common birth origin
arXiv:1701.07829 · doi:10.3847/1538-4357/aa9d8e
Abstract
We explore to which extent stars within Galactic disk open clusters resemble each other in the high-dimensional space of their photospheric element abundances, and contrast this with pairs of field stars. Our analysis is based on abundances for 20 elements, homogeneously derived from APOGEE spectra (with carefully quantified uncertainties, with a median value of dex). We consider 90 red giant stars in seven open clusters and find that most stars within a cluster have abundances in most elements that are indistinguishable (in a -sense) from those of the other members, as expected for stellar birth siblings. An analogous analysis among pairs of field stars shows that highly significant abundance differences in the 20-dimensional space can be established for the vast majority of these pairs, and that the APOGEE-based abundance measurements have high discriminating power. However, pairs of field stars whose abundances are indistinguishable even at 0.03~dex precision exist: percent of all field star pairs, and percent of field star pairs at the same (solar) metallicity [Fe/H] = . Most of these pairs are presumably not birth siblings from the same cluster, but rather doppelganger. Our analysis implies that 'chemical tagging' in the strict sense, identifying birth siblings for typical disk stars through their abundance similarity alone, will not work with such data. However, our approach shows that abundances have extremely valuable information for probabilistic chemo-orbital modeling and combined with velocities, we have identified new cluster members from the field.
arXiv commentsubmitted to ApJ
References in corpus (44)
- The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
- The New Galaxy: Signatures of its Formation
- The GALAH Survey: Scientific Motivation
- The PPMXL catalog of positions and proper motions on the ICRS. Combining USNO-B1.0 and 2MASS
- ASPCAP: The Apogee Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundances Pipeline
- The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Fifth Data Release
- The Thirteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: First Spectroscopic Data from the SDSS-IV Survey MApping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory
- The spatial structure of mono-abundance sub-populations of the Milky Way disk
- The Data Reduction Pipeline for the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
- Abundances, Stellar Parameters, and Spectra From the SDSS-III/APOGEE Survey
- Target Selection for the Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
- The Cannon: A data-driven approach to stellar label determination
- Red giant masses and ages derived from carbon and nitrogen abundances
- Atomic Diffusion and Mixing in Old Stars I. VLT/FLAMES-UVES Observations of Stars in NGC 6397
- Chemical tagging with APOGEE: Discovery of a large population of N-rich stars in the inner Galaxy
- Chemical Cartography with APOGEE: Large-scale Mean Metallicity Maps of the Milky Way
- The Long-term Evolution of the Galactic Disk Traced by Dissolving Star Clusters
- The influence of atomic diffusion on stellar ages and chemical tagging
- Exploring Anticorrelations and Light Element Variations in Northern Globular Clusters Observed by the APOGEE Survey
- Calibrations of Atmospheric Parameters Obtained from the First Year of SDSS-III APOGEE Observations
- The chemical homogeneity of open clusters
- Chemical Homogeneity in Collinder 261 and Implications for Chemical Tagging
- Label Transfer from APOGEE to LAMOST: Precise Stellar Parameters for 450,000 LAMOST Giants
- Stellar Radial Velocities in the Old Open Cluster M67 (NGC 2682) I. Memberships, Binaries, and Kinematics
- The Open Cluster Chemical Analysis and Mapping Survey: Local Galactic Metallicity Gradient with APOGEE using SDSS DR10
- The Hyades open cluster is chemically inhomogeneous
- Chemical tagging in the SDSS-III/APOGEE survey: new identifications of halo stars with globular cluster origins
- The chemical compositions of solar twins in the open cluster M67
- Project overview and update on WEAVE: the next generation wide-field spectroscopy facility for the William Herschel Telescope
- Comprehensive abundance analysis of red giants in the open clusters NGC 752, NGC 1817, NGC 2360 and NGC 2506
- Exploring Halo Substructure with Giant Stars: Substructure in the Local Halo as Seen in the Grid Giant Star Survey Including Extended Tidal Debris from Omega Centauri
- The RAVE-on catalog of stellar atmospheric parameters and chemical abundances for chemo-dynamic studies in the Gaia era
- Sodium and Oxygen Abundances in the Open Cluster NGC 6791 from APOGEE H-Band Spectroscopy
- Chemical tagging can work: Identification of stellar phase-space structures purely by chemical-abundance similarity
- Prospects for chemically tagging stars in the Galaxy
- O and Na abundance patterns in open clusters of the Galactic disk
- Quantitative chemical tagging, stellar ages and the chemo-dynamical evolution of the Galactic disc
- Quantifying Chemical Tagging: Towards Robust Group Finding in the Galaxy
- Comprehensive abundance analysis of red giants in the open clusters NGC 1342, 1662, 1912, 2354 and 2447
- Chemical Abundances in a Sample of Red Giants in the Open Cluster NGC 2420 from APOGEE
- APOGEE chemical tagging constraint on the maximum star cluster mass in the -enhanced Galactic disk
- MOONS: a Multi-Object Optical and Near-infrared Spectrograph for the VLT
- The Open Cluster NGC 7789: I. Radial Velocities for Giant Stars
- Prospecting for chemical tags among open clusters
Cited by in corpus (61)
- Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time
- The GALAH+ Survey: Third Data Release
- APOGEE Data and Spectral Analysis from SDSS Data Release 16: Seven Years of Observations Including First Results from APOGEE-South
- The Payne: self-consistent ab initio fitting of stellar spectra
- Accuracy and precision of industrial stellar abundances
- Measuring Radial Orbit Migration in the Milky Way Disk
- High-precision stellar abundances of the elements - methods and applications
- Identical or fraternal twins? : The chemical homogeneity of wide binaries from Gaia DR2
- The GALAH Survey: Chemical tagging and chrono-chemodynamics of accreted halo stars with GALAH+ DR3 and eDR3
- Dissecting stellar chemical abundance space with t-SNE
- In the Galactic disk, stellar [Fe/H] and age predict orbits and precise [X/Fe]
- Breaking Degeneracies in Formation Histories by Measuring Refractory Content in Gas Giants
- Temperatures and Metallicities of M dwarfs in the APOGEE Survey
- How magnetic activity alters what we learn from stellar spectra
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: Evidence of atomic diffusion in M67?
- How Many Elements Matter?
- Osaka Feedback Model: Isolated Disk Galaxy Simulations
- Spectrophotometric parallaxes with linear models: Accurate distances for luminous red-giant stars
- Rotation and Lithium Confirmation of a 500 Parsec Halo for the Open Cluster NGC 2516
- Unmixing the Galactic Halo with RR Lyrae tagging
- Using APOGEE Wide Binaries to Test Chemical Tagging with Dwarf Stars
- Abundances in the Milky Way across five nucleosynthetic channels from 4 million LAMOST stars
- Strong chemical tagging with APOGEE: 21 candidate star clusters that have dissolved across the Milky Way disc
- Open Cluster Chemical Homogeneity Throughout the Milky Way
- Distant Relatives: The Chemical Homogeneity of Comoving Pairs Identified in Gaia
- Mixing of metals during star cluster formation: statistics and implications for chemical tagging
- Blind chemical tagging with DBSCAN: prospects for spectroscopic surveys
- Planet Engulfment Detections are Rare According to Observations and Stellar Modeling
- Reliability and limitations of inferring birth radii in the Milky Way disk
- Simulating a metallicity-dependent initial mass function: Consequences for feedback and chemical abundances
- A Dynamical Model for Clustered Star Formation in the Galactic Disk
- On the Identification of Wide Binaries in the Kepler Field
- From birth associations to field stars: mapping the small-scale orbit distribution in the Galactic disc
- The Chemical Nature of the Young 120-Myr-old Nearby Pisces-Eridanus Stellar Stream Flowing through the Galactic Disk
- Spectroscopy of the Young Stellar Association Price-Whelan 1: Origin in the Magellanic Leading Arm and Constraints on the Milky Way Hot Halo
- On the Optimal Choice of Nucleosynthetic Yields, IMF and Number of SNe Ia for Chemical Evolution Modelling
- Machine learning in APOGEE: Identification of stellar populations through chemical abundances
- Disentangled Representation Learning for Astronomical Chemical Tagging
- Age-metallicity dependent stellar kinematics of the Milky Way disc from LAMOST and Gaia
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: The inner disc, intermediate-age open cluster Pismis 18
- The GALAH survey: Co-orbiting stars and chemical tagging
- Disconnecting the Dots: Re-Examining the Nature of Stellar "Strings" in the Milky Way
- A data-driven model of nucleosynthesis with chemical tagging in a lower-dimensional latent space
- The AMBRE Project: searching for the closest solar siblings
- The Implications of Local Fluctuations in the Galactic Midplane for Dynamical Analysis in the Gaia Era
- The galaxy-wide stellar initial mass function in the presence of cluster-to-cluster IMF variations
- Searching for Solar Siblings in APOGEE and DR2 with N-body Simulations
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: Chemical tagging in the thin disk. Open clusters blindly recovered in the elemental abundance space
- Searching for the extra-tidal stars of globular clusters using high-dimensional analysis and a core particle spray code
- Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST
- A Model RRNet for Spectral Information Exploitation and LAMOST Medium-resolution Spectrum Parameter Estimation
- Using heritability of stellar chemistry to reveal the history of the Milky Way
- The breakdown of current gyrochronology as evidenced by old coeval stars
- A GALAH View of the Chemical Homogeneity and Ages of Stellar Strings Identified in Gaia
- Reliable stellar abundances of individual stars with the MUSE integral-field spectrograph
- Parameter Estimation of LAMOST Medium-resolution Stellar Spectra
- Measuring Dwarf Galaxy Intrinsic Abundance Scatter with Mid-resolution Spectroscopic Surveys: Calibrating APOGEE Abundance Errors
- The Astrophysical Variance in Gaia-RVS Spectra
- A baseline on the relation between chemical patterns and birth stellar cluster
- On the connection between nitrogen-enhanced field stars and the Galactic globular clusters
- Deep chemical tagging -- Identifying open clusters and moving groups in chemical space with graph attention networks