Disentangling the origin of chemical differences using GHOST

Abstract

Aims. We explore different scenarios to explain the chemical difference found in the remarkable giant-giant binary system HD 138202 + CD-30 12303. For the first time, we suggest how to distinguish these scenarios by taking advantage of the extensive convective envelopes of giant stars. Methods. We carried out a high-precision determination of stellar parameters and abundances by applying a full line-by-line differential analysis on GHOST high-resolution spectra. Results. We found a significant chemical difference between the two stars (0.08 dex), which is largely unexpected considering the insensitivity of giant stars to planetary ingestion and diffusion effects. We tested the possibility of engulfment events by using several different combinations of stellar mass, ingested mass, metallicity of the engulfed object and different convective envelopes. However, the planetary ingestion scenario does not seem to explain the observed differences. For the first time, we distinguished the source of chemical differences using a giant-giant binary system. By ruling out other possible scenarios such as planet formation and evolutionary effects between the two stars, we suggest that primordial inhomogeneities might explain the observed differences. This remarkable result implies that the metallicity differences that were observed in at least some main-sequence binary systems might be related to primordial inhomogeneities rather than engulfment events. We also discuss the important implications of finding primordial inhomogeneities, which affect chemical tagging and other fields such as planet formation. We strongly encourage the use of giant-giant pairs. They are a relevant complement to main-sequence pairs for determining the origin of the observed chemical differences in multiple systems. [abridged]

11 pages, 7 figures, 4 tables. A&A Letters accepted

References in corpus (74)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the construction of stellar isochrones
• Gravity modes as a way to distinguish between hydrogen- and helium-burning red giant stars
• The effective temperature scale of FGK stars. II. Teff : color : [Fe/H] calibrations
• The peculiar solar composition and its possible relation to planet formation
• A million binaries from Gaia eDR3: sample selection and validation of Gaia parallax uncertainties
• The Mass-Metallicity Relation for Giant Planets
• Departures from LTE for neutral Li in late-type stars
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars. III. Spectroscopic stellar parameters
• The APOGEE red-clump catalog: Precise distances, velocities, and high-resolution elemental abundances over a large area of the Milky Way's disk
• Atomic Diffusion and Mixing in Old Stars I. VLT/FLAMES-UVES Observations of Stars in NGC 6397
• Formation of the Widest Binaries from Dynamical Unfolding of Triple Systems
• Evolved stars hint to an external origin of enhanced metallicity in planet-hosting stars
• The influence of atomic diffusion on stellar ages and chemical tagging
• Comoving stars in Gaia DR1: An abundance of very wide separation co-moving pairs
• Elemental abundance differences in the 16 Cygni binary system: a signature of gas giant planet formation?
• A critical investigation on the discrepancy between the observational and theoretical Red Giant luminosity function "Bump"
• The chemical homogeneity of open clusters
• Stellar parameters and chemical abundances of 223 evolved stars with and without planets
• Visual Binaries in the Orion Nebula Cluster
• Observable Signatures of Planet Accretion in Red Giant Stars I: Rapid Rotation and Light Element Replenishment
• Fine structure of the red giant clump from HIPPARCOS data, and distance determinations based on its mean magnitude
• Stellar Chemical Abundances: In Pursuit of the Highest Achievable Precision
• 18 Sco: a solar twin rich in refractory and neutron-capture elements. Implications for chemical tagging
• The statistical properties of stars and their dependence on metallicity
• High-precision stellar abundances of the elements - methods and applications
• Abundance differences between components of wide binaries
• Metal-rich accretion and thermohaline instabilities in exoplanets-host stars: consequences on the light elements abundances
• On Lithium-Rich Red Giants. I. Engulfment of Sub-Stellar Companions
• The Hyades open cluster is chemically inhomogeneous
• Galactic Doppelganger: The chemical similarity among field stars and among stars with a common birth origin
• Kronos & Krios: Evidence for accretion of a massive, rocky planetary system in a comoving pair of solar-type stars
• Seismic diagnostics of red giants: first comparison with stellar models
• Chemical Abundances of Main-Sequence, Turnoff, Subgiant and red giant Stars from APOGEE spectra II: Atomic Diffusion in M67 Stars
• Early turbulent mixing as the origin of chemical homogeneity in open star clusters
• Testing the universality of star formation - I. Multiplicity in nearby star-forming regions
• STARFORGE: The effects of protostellar outflows on the IMF
• A high precision chemical abundance analysis of the HAT-P-1 stellar binary: constraints on planet formation
• The Role of Planet Accretion in Creating the Next Generation of Red Giant Rapid Rotators
• Search for an exosphere in sodium and calcium in the transmission spectrum of exoplanet 55 Cancri e
• Chemical (in)homogeneity and atomic diffusion in the open cluster M67
• The lithium abundances for a large sample of red giants
• The GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. X. Differential abundances in the XO-2 planet hosting binary
• Signatures of rocky planet engulfment in HAT-P-4. Implications for chemical tagging studies
• Fingerprints of giant planets in the composition of solar twins
• Evolved stars and the origin of abundance trends in planet hosts
• Chemical evidence for planetary ingestion in a quarter of Sun-like stars
• Lithium in red giant stars: Constraining non-standard mixing with large surveys in the Gaia era
• The chemical composition of HIP34407/HIP34426 and other twin-star comoving pairs
• Eating Planets for Lunch and Dinner: Signatures of Planet Consumption by Evolving Stars
• The Magellan PFS Planet Search Program: Radial Velocity and Stellar Abundance Analyses of the 360 AU, Metal-Poor Binary "Twins" HD 133131A & B
• Detailed chemical compositions of planet hosting stars: I. Exploration of possible planet signatures
• Structure and evolution of the first CoRoT exoplanets: Probing the Brown Dwarf/Planet overlapping mass regime
• Differential abundances of open clusters and their tidal tails: chemical tagging and chemical homogeneity
• Exploring the Extremes: Characterizing a New Population of Old and Cold Brown Dwarfs
• Revisiting the pre-main-sequence evolution of stars II. Consequences of planet formation on stellar surface composition
• Mixing of metals during star cluster formation: statistics and implications for chemical tagging
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: chemical signatures of rocky accretion in a young solar-type star
• A temperature condensation trend in the debris-disk binary system Zet2 Ret
• HD 80606: Searching the chemical signature of planet formation
• Blind chemical tagging with DBSCAN: prospects for spectroscopic surveys
• Planet Engulfment Detections are Rare According to Observations and Stellar Modeling
• Chemical inhomogeneities in the Pleiades: signatures of rocky-forming material in stellar atmospheres
• Detailed elemental abundances of binary stars: Searching for signatures of planet formation and atomic diffusion
• Astrometric confirmation of young low-mass binaries and multiple systems in the Chamaeleon star-forming regions
• High-precision analysis of binary stars with planets. I. Searching for condensation temperature trends in the HD 106515 system
• SPECIES II. Stellar parameters of the EXPRESS program giant star sample
• Stellar abundance of binary stars: their role in determining the formation location of super-Earths and ice giants
• The peculiar chemical pattern of the WASP-160 binary system: signatures of planetary formation and evolution?
• Using non-solar-scaled opacities to derive stellar parameters. Toward high-precision parameters and abundances
• Unveiling the Structure and Dynamics of Red Giants with Asteroseismology
• Very massive star winds as sources of the short-lived radioactive isotope ${}^{26}$Al

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Host-star and exoplanet composition: Polluted white dwarf reveals depletion of moderately refractory elements in planetary material
• Searching for lambda Boo stars in binary systems
• The Formation of Double Hot Jupiter Systems through von Zeipel-Lidov-Kozai Migration
• Evolution of the ZTF SLRN-2020 star-planet merger