Evidence for a mixed mass composition at the `ankle' in the cosmic-ray spectrum

Abstract

We report a first measurement for ultra-high energy cosmic rays of the correlation between the depth of shower maximum and the signal in the water Cherenkov stations of air-showers registered simultaneously by the fluorescence and the surface detectors of the Pierre Auger Observatory. Such a correlation measurement is a unique feature of a hybrid air-shower observatory with sensitivity to both the electromagnetic and muonic components. It allows an accurate determination of the spread of primary masses in the cosmic-ray flux. Up till now, constraints on the spread of primary masses have been dominated by systematic uncertainties. The present correlation measurement is not affected by systematics in the measurement of the depth of shower maximum or the signal in the water Cherenkov stations. The analysis relies on general characteristics of air showers and is thus robust also with respect to uncertainties in hadronic event generators. The observed correlation in the energy range around the `ankle' at $\lg (E/\mathrm{eV})=18.5-19.0$ differs significantly from expectations for pure primary cosmic-ray compositions. A light composition made up of proton and helium only is equally inconsistent with observations. The data are explained well by a mixed composition including nuclei with mass $A>4$. Scenarios such as the proton dip model, with almost pure compositions, are thus disfavoured as the sole explanation of the ultrahigh-energy cosmic-ray flux at Earth.

arXiv commentPublished version. Added journal reference and DOI. Added Report Number

References in corpus (24)

• EPOS LHC : test of collective hadronization with LHC data
• Monte Carlo treatment of hadronic interactions in enhanced Pomeron scheme: I. QGSJET-II model
• Cosmic ray event generator Sibyll 2.1
• On astrophysical solution to ultra high energy cosmic rays
• Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurements at Energies above 10^17.8 eV
• Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Composition Implications
• One-dimensional Hybrid Approach to Extensive Air Shower Simulation
• Measurement of the proton-air cross-section at $\sqrt{s}=57$ TeV with the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Muons in air showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Mean number in highly inclined events
• Trigger and Aperture of the Surface Detector Array of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Study of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Ray Composition Using Telescope Array's Middle Drum Detector and Surface Array in Hybrid Mode
• The Offline Software Framework of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Dip in UHECR spectrum as signature of proton interaction with CMB
• Hadronic Multiparticle Production at Ultra-High Energies and Extensive Air Showers
• UHE nuclei propagation and the interpretation of the ankle in the cosmic-ray spectrum
• Muons in air showers at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurement of atmospheric production depth
• Hybrid simulations of extensive air showers
• Interpretation of the Depths of Maximum of Extensive Air Showers Measured by the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Cosmogenic Neutrinos Challenge the Cosmic Ray Proton Dip Model
• Azimuthal asymmetry in the risetime of the surface detector signals of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• The Lateral Trigger Probability function for the Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Ray Showers detected by the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Sensitivity of the correlation between the depth of shower maximum and the muon shower size to the cosmic ray composition
• The hadronic models for cosmic ray physics: the FLUKA code solutions
• Reconstruction accuracy of the surface detector array of the Pierre Auger Observatory

Cited by in corpus (62)

• Combined fit of spectrum and composition data as measured by the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Indication of anisotropy in arrival directions of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays through comparison to the flux pattern of extragalactic gamma-ray sources
• Radio detection of Cosmic-Ray Air Showers and High-Energy Neutrinos
• Multi-Messenger Astrophysics
• Features of the energy spectrum of cosmic rays above $2.5\times 10^{18}$ eV using the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays
• Large-scale cosmic-ray anisotropies above 4 EeV measured by the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Probing the origin of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays with neutrinos in the EeV energy range using the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Cosmogenic photon and neutrino fluxes in the Auger era
• A new view on Auger data and cosmogenic neutrinos in light of different nuclear disintegration and air-shower models
• Neutrino Interferometry for High-Precision Tests of Lorentz Symmetry with IceCube
• AugerPrime: the Pierre Auger Observatory Upgrade
• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays: The Intersection of the Cosmic and Energy Frontiers
• Constraining the sources of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays across and above the ankle with the spectrum and composition data measured at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Acceleration of ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays in starburst superwinds
• Progress towards characterizing ultrahigh energy cosmic ray sources
• Prompt neutrino fluxes in the atmosphere with PROSA parton distribution functions
• A minimal model for extragalactic cosmic rays and neutrinos
• Strange fireball as an explanation of the muon excess in Auger data
• Studies of an air-shower imaging system for the detection of ultrahigh-energy neutrinos
• Nuclear Physics Meets the Sources of the Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
• Probing the energy spectrum of hadrons in proton air interactions at ultrahigh energies through the fluctuations of the muon content of extensive air showers
• Production and propagation of ultra-high energy photons using CRPropa 3
• A targeted search for point sources of EeV photons with the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Performance and science reach of POEMMA for ultrahigh-energy particles
• Reconstruction of Events Recorded with the Surface Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• What can be learnt from UHECR anisotropies observations? Paper I : large-scale anisotropies and composition features
• Testing Hadronic-Model Predictions of Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles and Ground-Particle Signals using Hybrid Data of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Acceleration and propagation of ultra high energy cosmic rays
• Improved bound on isotropic Lorentz violation in the photon sector from extensive air showers
• Depth of maximum of air-shower profiles: testing the compatibility of measurements performed at the Pierre Auger Observatory and the Telescope Array experiment
• Impact of using the ultra-high-energy cosmic ray arrival energies to constrain source associations
• High-Energy Galactic Cosmic Rays (Astro2020 Science White Paper)
• Ultrahigh-Energy Cosmic Ray Composition from the Distribution of Arrival Directions
• What is the nature and origin of the highest-energy particles in the universe?
• Constraining the energy spectrum of neutral pions in ultra-high-energy proton-air interactions
• Anisotropies of Ultra-high Energy Cosmic Rays Dominated by a Single Source in the Presence of Deflections
• Quantum gravity phenomenology at the dawn of the multi-messenger era -- A review
• Determination of the Cosmic-Ray Chemical Composition: Open Issues and Prospects
• Modeling Strangeness Enhancements to resolve the Muon Excess in Cosmic Ray Extensive Air Shower Data
• A new bound on Lorentz violation based on the absence of vacuum Cherenkov radiation in ultra-high energy air showers
• The spectra and composition of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays and the measurement of the proton-air cross section
• Ultrarelativistic generalized Lorentzian thermodynamics and the differential cosmic ray energy flux
• Lorentz invariance violation as an explanation of muon excess in Auger data
• AugerPrime -- The upgrade of the Pierre Auger Observatory
• New test of Lorentz symmetry using ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays
• Modification of the Dipole in Arrival Directions of Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays due to the Galactic Magnetic Field
• Evidence for UHECR origin in starburst galaxies
• A relook at the GZK Neutrino-Photon Connection: Impact of Extra-galactic Radio Background & UHECR properties
• A Heavy-Metal Scenario of Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays
• Past, Present and Future of UHECR Observations
• Combined Fit of Spectrum and Composition for FR0 Radio-galaxy-emitted Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays with Resulting Secondary Photons and Neutrinos
• Model-independent Evidence for an Increase in the Mean Mass of Cosmic Rays above 3 EeV
• Particle Spectra and Mass Composition in the Ultra-High Energy Region in the Framework of the Galactic Origin of Cosmic Rays
• Towards solving the mass-composition problem in ultra high energy cosmic rays
• Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays: Recent Results and Future Plans of Auger
• Composition determination of cosmic rays from the muon content of the showers
• On the efficiency of the evaluation of the primary cosmic ray composition using lateral distributions of air shower electromagnetic component
• UHECR primary identification using the lateral profile of muons in EAS
• UHECRs Propagation and their Multimessengers: Upper limits and the Impact of the Extragalactic Magnetic Field
• Ultrahigh energy cosmic ray nuclei from remnants of dead quasars
• Air Shower Detection by Arrays of Radio Antennas (ISVHECRI 2018)