Open-ended versus guided laboratory activities: Impact on students' beliefs about experimental physics

Abstract

Improving students' understanding of the nature of experimental physics is often an explicit or implicit goal of undergraduate laboratory physics courses. However, lab activities in traditional lab courses are typically characterized by highly structured, guided labs that often do not require or encourage students to engage authentically in the process of experimental physics. Alternatively, open-ended laboratory activities can provide a more authentic learning environment by, for example, allowing students to exercise greater autonomy in what and how physical phenomena are investigated. Engaging in authentic practices may be a critical part of improving students' beliefs around the nature of experimental physics. Here, we investigate the impact of open-ended activities in undergraduate lab courses on students' epistemologies and expectations about the nature of experimental physics, as well as their confidence and affect, as measured by the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey for Experimental Physics (E-CLASS). Using a national data set of student responses to the E-CLASS, we find that the inclusion of some open-ended lab activities in a lab course correlates with more expert-like postinstruction responses relative to courses that include only traditional guided lab activities. This finding holds when examining postinstruction E-CLASS scores while controlling for the variance associated with preinstruction scores, course level, student major, and student gender.

arXiv comment8 pages, 2 figures, submitted to Phys. Rev. - PER. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1606.02629

References in corpus (6)

• The Process of Transforming an Advanced Lab Course: Goals, Curriculum, and Assessments
• An epistemology and expectations survey about experimental physics: Development and initial results
• Students' epistemologies about experimental physics: Validating the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey for Experimental Physics
• Research-based assessment of students' beliefs about experimental physics: When is gender a factor?
• Alternative model for the administration and analysis of research-based assessments
• Development and Validation of the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey for Experimental Physics

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Value added or misattributed? A multi-institution study on the educational benefit of labs for reinforcing physics content
• Developing skills vs reinforcing concepts in physics labs: Insight from E-CLASS
• Students' views about the nature of experimental physics
• Authentic Science Experiences with STEM Datasets: Post-secondary Results and Potential Gender Influences
• Improvement or selection? A longitudinal analysis of students' views about experimental physics in their lab courses
• Lessons from Transforming Second-Year Honors Physics Lab
• Affordances and Challenges of Incorporating a Remote, Cloud-accessible Quantum Experiment into Undergraduate Courses
• Students' attitudes toward experimental physics in a conceptual inquiry-based introductory physics lab
• Qualitative observations in university physics laboratories: an example from classical mechanics
• The process of constructing new knowledge: an undergraduate laboratory exercise facilitated by a vacuum capacitor-resistor circuit
• 61 ways to measure the height of a building: an introduction to experimental practices
• Lessons from pendulums: A design comparison of three lab activities