Improvement or selection? A longitudinal analysis of students' views about experimental physics in their lab courses

Abstract

Laboratory courses represent a unique and potentially important component of the undergraduate physics curriculum, which can be designed to allow students to authentically engage with the process of experimental physics. Among other possible benefits, participation in these courses throughout the undergraduate physics curriculum presents an opportunity to develop students' understanding of the nature and importance of experimental physics within the discipline as a whole. Here, we present and compare both a longitudinal and pseudo-longitudinal analysis of students' responses to a research-based assessment targeting students' views about experimental physics -- the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey for Experimental Physics (E-CLASS) -- across multiple, required lab courses at a single institution. We find that, while pseudo-longitudinal averages showed increases in students' E-CLASS scores in each consecutive course, analysis of longitudinal data indicates that this increase was not driven by a cumulative impact of laboratory instruction. Rather, the increase was driven by a selection effect in which students who persisted into higher-level lab courses already had more expert-like beliefs, attitudes, and expectations than their peers when they started the lower-level courses.

6 pages, 1 figure, submitted as a short paper to Phys. Rev. PER

References in corpus (11)

• Teaching Critical Thinking
• Measuring the Impact of Introductory Physics Labs on Learning
• Measuring the impact of an instructional laboratory on the learning of introductory physics
• Value added or misattributed? A multi-institution study on the educational benefit of labs for reinforcing physics content
• Developing skills vs reinforcing concepts in physics labs: Insight from E-CLASS
• The Process of Transforming an Advanced Lab Course: Goals, Curriculum, and Assessments
• Open-ended versus guided laboratory activities: Impact on students' beliefs about experimental physics
• Students' epistemologies about experimental physics: Validating the Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey for Experimental Physics
• Research-based assessment of students' beliefs about experimental physics: When is gender a factor?
• Alternative model for the administration and analysis of research-based assessments
• Development and Evaluation of a Tutorial to Improve Students' Understanding of a Lock-in amplifier