The Impact of Modeling Assumptions in Galactic Chemical Evolution Models

Abstract

We use the OMEGA galactic chemical evolution code to investigate how the assumptions used for the treatment of galactic inflows and outflows impact numerical predictions. The goal is to determine how our capacity to reproduce the chemical evolution trends of a galaxy is affected by the choice of implementation used to include those physical processes. In pursuit of this goal, we experiment with three different prescriptions for galactic inflows and outflows and use OMEGA within a Markov Chain Monte Carlo code to recover the set of input parameters that best reproduces the chemical evolution of nine elements in the dwarf spheroidal galaxy Sculptor. This provides a consistent framework for comparing the best-fit solutions generated by our different models. Despite their different degrees of intended physical realism, we found that all three prescriptions can reproduce in an almost identical way the stellar abundance trends observed in Sculptor. While the three models have the same capacity to fit the data, the best values recovered for the parameters controlling the number of Type Ia supernovae and the strength of galactic outflows, are substantially different and in fact mutually exclusive from one model to another. For the purpose of understanding how a galaxy evolves, we conclude that only reproducing the evolution of a limited number of elements is insufficient and can lead to misleading conclusions. More elements or additional constraints such as the galaxy's star formation efficiency and the gas fraction are needed in order to break the degeneracy between the different modeling assumptions. Our results show that the successes and failures of chemical evolution models are predominantly driven by the input stellar yields, rather than by the complexity of the galaxy model itself. Simple models such as OMEGA are therefore sufficient to test and validate stellar yields.

16 pages, 9 figures, 1 table, accepted in ApJ

References in corpus (32)

• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• Theory of Star Formation
• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
• Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
• A primer on hierarchical galaxy formation: the semi-analytical approach
• The Cosmic Baryon Cycle and Galaxy Mass Assembly in the FIRE Simulations
• The kinematic status and mass content of the Sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• The Supernova Channel of Super-AGB Stars
• A blueprint for detecting supersymmetric dark matter in the Galactic halo
• Multi-Element Abundance Measurements from Medium-Resolution Spectra. II. Catalog of Stars in Milky Way Dwarf Satellite Galaxies
• Inflow, Outflow, Yields, and Stellar Population Mixing in Chemical Evolution Models
• Abundance gradients in the Milky Way for alpha elements, Iron peak elements, Barium, Lanthanum and Europium
• The first carbon-enhanced metal-poor star found in the Sculptor dwarf spheroidal
• Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models of Galaxy Formation
• The Chemical Evolution of Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies: Dissecting the Inner Regions and their Stellar Populations
• On Carbon Burning in Super Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars
• Effects of the galactic winds on the stellar metallicity distribution of dwarf spheroidal galaxies
• Detailed Chemical Evolution of Carina and Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies
• Cosmological implications of dwarf spheroidal chemical evolution
• Subclasses of Type Ia Supernovae as the origin of [α/Fe] ratios in dwarf spheroidal galaxies
• Chemodynamics of a Simulated Disc Galaxy: Initial Mass Functions and SNIa Progenitors
• Chemical evolution of classical and ultra-faint dwarf spheroidal galaxies
• Monolithic or hierarchical star formation? A new statistical analysis
• Chemical enrichment in very low-metallicity environments: Bootes I
• An Introduction to Galactic Chemical Evolution
• An inefficient dwarf: Chemical abundances and the evolution of the Ursa Minor dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• A low pre-infall mass for the Carina dwarf galaxy from disequilibrium modelling
• Modeling the chemical evolution of Omega Centauri using three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations
• A Test of Star Formation Laws in Disk Galaxies. II. Dependence on dynamical properties
• A New Chemical Evolution Model for Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies based on Observed Long Star Formation Histories
• The Chemistry of the Local Group

Cited by in corpus (76)

• Collapsars as a major source of r-process elements
• Neutron Star Mergers Might not be the Only Source of r-Process Elements in the Milky Way
• The Origin of r-Process Elements in the Milky Way
• Galactic Archaeology with asteroseismic ages: evidence for delayed gas infall in the formation of the Milky Way disc
• NuGrid Stellar Data Set. II. Stellar Yields from H to Bi for Stellar Models with Mzams = 1 to 25Msun and Z = 0.0001 to 0.02
• r-Process Nucleosynthesis: Connecting Rare-Isotope Beam Facilities with the Cosmos
• Simulating an Isolated Dwarf Galaxy with Multi-Channel Feedback and Chemical Yields from Individual Stars
• VLT/FLAMES high-resolution chemical abundances in Sculptor: a textbook dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• APOGEE DR16: a multi-zone chemical evolution model for the Galactic disc based on MCMC methods
• Advanced LIGO Constraints on Neutron Star Mergers and R-Process Sites
• Spatial variations in the Milky Way disc metallicity-age relation
• Galactic Archaeology with asteroseismic ages. II. Confirmation of a delayed gas infall using Bayesian analysis based on MCMC methods
• A new delay time distribution for merging neutron stars tested against Galactic and cosmic data
• Chemical evolution library for galaxy formation simulation
• Convective-reactive nucleosynthesis of K, Sc, Cl and p-process isotopes in O-C shell mergers
• Nucleosynthesis imprints from different Type Ia Supernova explosion scenarios and implications for galactic chemical evolution
• L-GALAXIES 2020: The evolution of radial metallicity profiles and global metallicities in disc galaxies
• The gas, metal and dust evolution in low-metallicity local and high-redshift galaxies
• i-Process Contribution of Rapidly Accreting White Dwarfs to the Solar Composition of First-Peak Neutron-Capture Elements
• Validating Semi-Analytic Models of High-Redshift Galaxy Formation using Radiation Hydrodynamical Simulations
• Beyond the two-infall model I. Indications for a recent gas infall with Gaia DR3 chemical abundances
• The evolution of CNO elements in galaxies
• Metal Mixing and Ejection in Dwarf Galaxies is Dependent on Nucleosynthetic Source
• Galactic Chemical Evolution of Radioactive Isotopes
• Observational and theoretical constraints on the formation and early evolution of the first dust grains in galaxies at 5 < z < 10
• The Impact of Nuclear Reaction Rate Uncertainties On The Evolution of Core-Collapse Supernova Progenitors
• The S2 Stream: the shreds of a primitive dwarf galaxy
• SYGMA: Stellar Yields for Galactic Modeling Applications
• Aluminium-26 from massive binary stars I: non-rotating models
• Simultaneous Constraints on the Star Formation History and Nucleosynthesis of Sculptor dSph
• On The Development of Multidimensional Progenitor Models For Core-collapse Supernovae
• Fluorine in the solar neighborhood: modelling the Galactic thick and thin discs
• Exploring the link between star and planet formation with Ariel
• Implications of inhomogeneous metal mixing for stellar archaeology
• Observing the metal-poor solar neighbourhood: a comparison of galactic chemical evolution predictions
• Star-formation driven outflows in local dwarf galaxies as revealed from [CII] observations by Herschel
• (Re)mind the gap: a hiatus in star formation history unveiled by APOGEE DR17
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. V. Non-LTE abundance ratios of [Ni/Fe] in Galactic stars and enrichment by sub-Chandrasekhar mass SNe
• Neutron Star Mergers as the Main Source of R-process: Natal Kicks And Inside-Out Evolution to The Rescue
• Metal-Poor Stars Observed with the Southern African Large Telescope
• On the Optimal Choice of Nucleosynthetic Yields, IMF and Number of SNe Ia for Chemical Evolution Modelling
• Markov Chain Monte Carlo Predictions of Neutron-rich Lanthanide Properties as a Probe of $r$-process Dynamics
• A simple and general method for solving detailed chemical evolution with delayed production of iron and other chemical elements
• The most metal-rich stars in the universe: chemical contributions of low and intermediate mass asymptotic giant branch stars with metallicities between $0.04\le Z\le \mathrm{0.10.}$
• Galactic Chemical Evolution of Radioactive Isotopes with an s-process Contribution
• Heavy element evolution in the inner regions of the Milky Way
• Chemical Evolution of Fluorine in the Milky Way
• Disc dichotomy signature in the vertical distribution of [Mg/Fe] and the delayed gas infall scenario
• $Chempy$: A flexible chemical evolution model for abundance fitting - Do the Sun's abundances alone constrain chemical evolution models?
• The chemical evolution of the solar neighbourhood for planet-hosting stars
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. VI. Origin and evolution of neutron-capture elements as probed by the Gaia-ESO survey
• IR characteristic emission and dust properties of star-forming galaxies at 4.5 $<$ z $<$ 6.2
• GalCEM I -- An Open-Source Detailed Isotopic Chemical Evolution Code
• Near-infrared chemical abundances of stars in the Sculptor dwarf galaxy
• Unveiling the chemical fingerprint of phosphorus-rich stars I. In the infrared region of APOGEE-2
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. IX. 3D NLTE abundances of metals in the context of Galactic Chemical Evolution Models and 4MOST
• Peeking beneath the precision floor -- II. Probing the chemo-dynamical histories of the potential globular cluster siblings, NGC 288 and NGC 362
• Nucleosynthetic Yields from Neutron Stars Accreting in Binary Common Envelopes
• Enrichment of the Galactic disc with neutron-capture elements: Gd, Dy, and Th
• Are Milky-Way-like galaxies like the Milky Way? A view from SDSS-IV/MaNGA
• Chromium Nucleosynthesis and Silicon-Carbon Shell Mergers in Massive Stars
• Using chemical evolution models of the Milky Way disk to constrain Type Ia supernova progenitors
• Magnesium isotope ratios in Milky Way and dwarf galaxy stars
• The ALPINE-ALMA [CII] Survey: Unveiling the baryon evolution in the ISM of $z\sim 5$ star-forming galaxies
• Silicon Isotopic Composition of Mainstream Presolar SiC Grains Revisited: The Impact of Nuclear Reaction Rate Uncertainties
• Reconstructing the Milky Way chemical map with Galactic Chemical Evolution tool OMEGA+ from SDSS-MWM
• Binary stellar evolution yields in galactic chemical evolution calculations
• Assessing stellar yields in Galaxy chemical evolution: observational stellar abundance patterns
• Inferring Galactic Parameters from Chemical Abundances: A Multi-Star Approach
• The LEGARE Project. I. Chemical evolution model of the Nuclear Stellar Disc in a Bayesian framework
• Impact of the latest 22Ne+α reaction rates on nucleosynthesis in massive stars and galactic chemical evolution
• Project ThaiPASS: International Outreach Blending Astronomy and Python
• Rapid early gas accretion for the inner Galactic disc
• Viability of novae as sources of Galactic lithium
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. X. Combining NLTE and machine learning for chemical diagnostics of 4 million stars in the 4MIDABLE-HR survey
• Blanco DECam Bulge Survey (BDBS) IV: Metallicity Distributions and Bulge Structure from 2.6 Million Red Clump Stars