A Slippery Slope: Systematic Uncertainties in the Line Width Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation

Abstract

The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation (BTFR) is a valuable observational tool and a critical test of galaxy formation theory. We explore the systematic uncertainty in the slope and the scatter of the observed line width BTFR utilizing homogeneously measured, unresolved HI observations for 930 isolated galaxies. We measure a fiducial relation of ${\log }_{10}{M}_{\mathrm{baryon}}=3.24{\log }_{10}{V}_{\mathrm{rot}}+3.21$ with observed scatter of 0.25 dex with $10^{7.4}<M_{\mathrm{baryon}}<10^{11.3}{M}_{\odot }$ where $V_{\mathrm{rot}}$ is measured from 20\% HI line widths. We vary the definitions of $M_{\mathrm{baryon}}$ and $V_{\mathrm{rot}}$, the sample selection, and the linear fitting algorithm. We obtain slopes ranging from 2.64 to 3.53 and scatter measurements ranging from 0.14 to 0.41~dex, indicating a systematic uncertainty of 0.25 in the BTFR slope derived from unresolved HI line widths. We compare our fiducial slope to literature measurements, where reported slopes range from 3.0 to 4.3 and scatter is either unmeasured, immeasurable or as large as 0.4~dex. Measurements derived from unresolved HI line widths tend to produce slopes of 3.3, while measurements derived from asymptotic rotation curves tend to produce slopes of 3.9. The largest factor affecting the BTFR slope is the definition of $V_{\mathrm{rot}}$. The sample definition, the mass range, and the linear fitting algorithm also significantly affect the measured BTFR. We find that galaxies in our sample with $V_{\mathrm{rot}}<100\mathrm{km}{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$ are consistent with the line width BTFR of more massive galaxies, but these galaxies drive most of the observed scatter. It is critical when comparing predictions to an observed BTFR that the $V_{\mathrm{rot}}$ definition, the sample selection and the fitting algorithm are similarly defined. We recommend direct statistical comparisons between data sets with commensurable properties as opposed to comparing BTFR power-law fits.

Accepted by the Astrophysical Journal, figures 2 and 3 present our key results, all data are available at http://www.astro.yale.edu/jdbradford/research.html

References in corpus (32)

• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• K-corrections and filter transformations in the ultraviolet, optical, and near infrared
• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Forming Disk Galaxies in Lambda CDM Simulations
• What is Driving the HI Velocity Dispersion?
• The small scatter of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation
• A Revised Model for the Formation of Disk Galaxies: Low Spin and Dark-Halo Expansion
• The Baryon Content of Extremely Low Mass Dwarf Galaxies
• Scaling Relations of Spiral Galaxies
• Color--Mass-to-Light Ratio Relations for Disk Galaxies
• A Novel Test of the Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Gas Rich Galaxies
• The velocity function in the local environment from LCDM and LWDM constrained simulations
• From Spitzer Galaxy Photometry to Tully-Fisher Distances
• The Impact of Feedback on Disk Galaxy Scaling Relations
• Weighing Galaxy Disks with the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
• A First Attempt to Calibrate the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation with Gas Dominated Galaxies
• A Survey of Galaxy Kinematics to z ~ 1 in the TKRS/GOODS-N Field. II. Evolution in the Tully-Fisher Relation
• The Tully-Fisher relation for S0 galaxies
• Dark and Baryonic Matter in Bright Spiral Galaxies: II. Radial Distributions for 34 Galaxies
• The mass discrepancy acceleration relation in a $\Lambda$CDM context
• On the baryonic, stellar, and luminous scaling relations of disk galaxies
• The high mass end of the Tully-Fisher relation
• HI velocity dispersion in NGC 1058
• An accurate measurement of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation with heavily gas-dominated ALFALFA galaxies
• The Calibration of the WISE W1 and W2 Tully-Fisher Relation
• Distances from Stellar Kinematics for Peculiar Virgo Cluster Spiral Galaxies
• The Structure of Rapidly Rotating Late-Type Spiral Galaxies: I. Photometry, HI and Optical Kinematics
• Testing cold dark matter with the low mass Tully-Fisher relation
• The distribution of dark and luminous matter inferred from extended rotation curves
• The different baryonic Tully-Fisher relations at low masses
• Disk Galaxy Scaling Relations in the SFI++: Intrinsic Scatter and Applications
• Giant disk galaxies : Where environment trumps mass in galaxy evolution

Cited by in corpus (39)

• The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation for different velocity definitions and implications for galaxy angular momentum
• Gas kinematics, morphology, and angular momentum in the FIRE simulations
• Gravitational probes of dark matter physics
• Reconciling the Diversity and Uniformity of Galactic Rotation Curves with Self-Interacting Dark Matter
• The evolution of the Tully-Fisher relation between z~2.3 and z~0.9 with KMOS^3D
• From light to baryonic mass: the effect of the stellar mass-to-light ratio on the Baryonic Tully-Fisher relation
• NIHAO XIV: Reproducing the observed diversity of dwarf galaxy rotation curve shapes in LCDM
• Gas Kinematics in FIRE Simulated Galaxies Compared to Spatially Unresolved HI Observations
• NIHAO XII: galactic uniformity in a ΛCDM universe
• MIGHTEE-HI: The baryonic Tully-Fisher relation over the last billion years
• The Effect of AGN on the Global HI Content of Isolated Low-Mass Galaxies
• A Study of Two Diffuse Dwarf Galaxies in the Field
• The new semianalytic code GalICS 2.0 - Reproducing the galaxy stellar mass function and the Tully-Fisher relation simultaneously
• NIHAO XVI: The properties and evolution of kinematically selected discs, bulges and stellar haloes
• On the Determination of Rotation Velocity and Dynamical Mass of Galaxies Based on Integrated H I Spectra
• The Spectroscopy and H-band Imaging of Virgo cluster galaxies (SHIVir) Survey: Scaling Relations and the Stellar-to-Total Mass Relation
• The radial acceleration relation in a $\Lambda$CDM universe
• Does the Milky Way Obey Spiral Galaxy Scaling Relations?
• Cosmicflows-4: The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation Providing ~10,000 Distances
• Relations between abundance characteristics and rotation velocity for star-forming MaNGA galaxies
• The many reasons that the rotation curves of low-mass galaxies can fail as tracers of their matter distributions
• The Intrinsic Scatter of Galaxy Scaling Relations
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: The Low-Redshift Stellar Mass Tully-Fisher Relation
• Another baryon miracle? Testing solutions to the "missing dwarfs" problem
• A Comparison of the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation in MaNGA and IllustrisTNG
• The Physical Origin of the Mass-Size Relation and Its Scatter of Disk Galaxies
• Testing Emergent Gravity with Isolated Dwarf Galaxies
• The radial acceleration relation is a natural consequence of the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation
• The Evolution of Molecular Gas Fraction Traced by the CO Tully-Fisher Relation
• HI imaging of dwarf star-forming galaxies: Masses, morphologies and gas deficiencies
• SAMI-HI: The HI view of the H$\alpha$ Tully-Fisher relation and data release
• Measuring the baryonic Tully-Fisher relation below the detection threshold
• A Generalist, Automated ALFALFA Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
• WALLABY Pilot Survey: Gas-Rich Galaxy Scaling Relations from Marginally-Resolved Kinematic Models
• Predictions for Detecting a Turndown in the Baryonic Tully Fisher Relation
• Parametrized Asymmetric Neutral hydrogen Disk Integrated Spectrum Characterization (PANDISC) I: Introduction to A Physically Motivated H I Model
• GAMA 526784: the progenitor of a globular cluster-rich ultra-diffuse galaxy? II. Molecular gas, neutral gas and environment
• The MeerKAT Fornax Survey V. H i kinematics and Fornax cluster membership of the dwarf galaxy ESO 358-60
• Extended Hernquist-Springel formalism for cosmic star formation