Sensitivity bias in the mass-radius distribution from Transit Timing Variations and Radial Velocity measurements

Abstract

Motivated by recent discussions, both in private and in the literature, we use a Monte Carlo simulation of planetary systems to investigate sources of bias in determining the mass-radius distribution of exoplanets for the two primary techniques used to measure planetary masses---Radial Velocities (RVs) and Transit Timing Variations (TTVs). We assert that mass measurements derived from these two methods are comparably reliable---as the physics underlying their respective signals is well understood. Nevertheless, their sensitivity to planet mass varies with the properties of the planets themselves. We find that for a given planet size, the RV method tends to find planets with higher mass while the sensitivity of TTVs is more uniform. This ``sensitivity bias'' implies that a complete census of TTV systems is likely to yield a more robust estimate of the mass-radius distribution provided there are not important physical differences between planets near and far from mean-motion resonance. We discuss differences in the sensitivity of the two methods with orbital period and system architecture, which may compound the discrepancies between them (e.g., short period planets detectable by RVs may be more dense due to atmospheric loss). We advocate for continued mass measurements using both approaches as a means both to measure the masses of more planets and to identify potential differences in planet structure that may result from their dynamical and environmental histories.

9 pages. lots of figures. For submission to MNRAS

References in corpus (9)

• DHP Framework: Digital Health Passports Using Blockchain -- Use case on international tourism during the COVID-19 pandemic
• KEPLER's First Rocky Planet: Kepler-10b
• Resonant Repulsion of Kepler Planet Pairs
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler. IX. Catalog of the Full Long-Cadence Data Set
• Analytic Approximations for Transit Light Curve Observables, Uncertainties, and Covariances
• The period ratio distribution of Kepler's candidate multiplanet systems
• Measurement of planet masses with transit timing variations due to synodic "chopping" effects
• Transit Light Curves with Finite Integration Time: Fisher Information Analysis
• Doppler Monitoring of the WASP-47 Multiplanet System

Cited by in corpus (36)

• Revisited Mass-Radius relations for exoplanets below 120 Earth masses
• Kepler Planet Masses and Eccentricities from TTV Analysis
• The Featureless Transmission Spectra of Two Super-Puff Planets
• Correlations between compositions and orbits established by the giant impact era of planet formation
• Tidally-Induced Radius Inflation of Sub-Neptunes
• The Planetary Mass-Radius Relation and its Dependence on Orbital Period as Measured by Transit Timing Variations and Radial Velocities
• TOI-1136 is a Young, Coplanar, Aligned Planetary System in a Pristine Resonant Chain
• Diffuser-Assisted Infrared Transit Photometry for Four Dynamically Interacting \textit{Kepler} Systems
• The BEBOP radial-velocity survey for circumbinary planets I. Eight years of CORALIE observations of 47 single-line eclipsing binaries and abundance constraints on the masses of circumbinary planets
• Five Planets Transiting a Ninth Magnitude Star
• The Compositional Diversity of Low-Mass Exoplanets
• Evidence for Hidden Nearby Companions to Hot Jupiters
• An Overabundance of Low-density Neptune-like Planets
• The Kepler-19 system: a thick-envelope super-Earth with two Neptune-mass companions characterized using Radial Velocities and Transit Timing Variations
• A Joint Mass-Radius-Period Distribution of Exoplanets
• HARPS-N radial velocities confirm the low densities of the Kepler-9 planets
• Doppler Monitoring of five K2 Transiting Planetary Systems
• Two Transiting Low Density Sub-Saturns from K2
• A spectral approach to transit timing variations
• A Minimum Mass Nebula for M Dwarfs
• Generalized Peas-in-a-Pod: Extending Intra-System Mass Uniformity to Non-TTV Systems via the Gini Index
• Resonant sub-Neptunes are puffier
• Following up the Kepler field: Masses of Targets for transit timing and atmospheric characterization
• TESS Observations of Kepler systems with Transit Timing Variations
• On the Orbital Spacing Pattern of Kepler Multiple Planet Systems
• A Quantitative Comparison of Exoplanet Catalogs
• Host Star Dependence of Small Planet Mass-Radius Distributions
• Enhanced Size Uniformity for Near-resonant Planets
• A Gap in the Mass Distribution for Warm Neptune and Terrestrial Planets
• TOI-1749: an M dwarf with a Trio of Planets including a Near-Resonant Pair
• Transit Depth Variations Reveal TOI-216 b to be a Super-Puff
• Predicting exoplanet mass from radius and incident flux: A Bayesian mixture model
• Can metal-rich worlds form by giant impacts?
• Nauyaca: a new tool to determine planetary masses and orbital elements through transit timing analysis
• Mass Upper Bounds for Over 50 Kepler Planets Using Low-S/N Transit Timing Variations
• The Occurrence-weighted Median Planets Discovered by Transit Surveys Orbiting Solar-type Stars and Their Implications for Planet Formation and Evolution