Terrestrial Planet Formation Constrained by Mars and the Structure of the Asteroid Belt

Abstract

Reproducing the large Earth/Mars mass ratio requires a strong mass depletion in solids within the protoplanetary disk between 1 and 3 AU. The Grand Tack model invokes a specific migration history of the giant planets to remove most of the mass initially beyond 1 AU and to dynamically excite the asteroid belt. However, one could also invoke a steep density gradient created by inward drift and pile-up of small particles induced by gas-drag, as has been proposed to explain the formation of close-in super Earths. Here we show that the asteroid belt's orbital excitation provides a crucial constraint against this scenario for the Solar System. We performed a series of simulations of terrestrial planet formation and asteroid belt evolution starting from disks of planetesimals and planetary embryos with various radial density gradients and including Jupiter and Saturn on nearly circular and coplanar orbits. Disks with shallow density gradients reproduce the dynamical excitation of the asteroid belt by gravitational self-stirring but form Mars analogs significantly more massive than the real planet. In contrast, a disk with a surface density gradient proportional to $r^{-5.5}$ reproduces the Earth/Mars mass ratio but leaves the asteroid belt in a dynamical state that is far colder than the real belt. We conclude that no disk profile can simultaneously explain the structure of the terrestrial planets and asteroid belt. The asteroid belt must have been depleted and dynamically excited by a different mechanism such as, for instance, in the Grand Tack scenario.

Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (48)

• A low mass for Mars from Jupiter's early gas-driven migration
• The origins and concentrations of water, carbon, nitrogen and noble gases on Earth
• Asteroids Were Born Big
• Solar System evolution from compositional mapping of the asteroid belt
• Building Terrestrial Planets
• Making other Earths: Dynamical Simulations of Terrestrial Planet Formation and Water Delivery
• Forming the cores of giant planets from the radial pebble flux in protoplanetary discs
• Separating gas-giant and ice-giant planets by halting pebble accretion
• Building the Terrestrial Planets: Constrained Accretion in the Inner Solar System
• Collisions between Gravity-Dominated Bodies: 2. The Diversity of Impact Outcomes during the End Stage of Planet Formation
• Collisions Between Gravity-Dominated Bodies: 1. Outcome Regimes and Scaling Laws
• The origin of planetary impactors in the inner solar system
• High-resolution simulations of the final assembly of Earth-like planets 1: terrestrial accretion and dynamics
• Statistical Study of the Early Solar System's Instability with 4, 5 and 6 Giant Planets
• Reversing type II migration: resonance trapping of a lighter giant protoplanet
• Dynamics of the giant planets of the solar system in the gaseous proto-planetary disk and relationship to the current orbital architecture
• Formation of the Terrestrial Planets from a Narrow Annulus
• Water Delivery and Giant Impacts in the 'Grand Tack' Scenario
• Highly Siderophile Elements in the Earth's Mantle as a Clock for the Moon-forming Impact
• Inside-Out Planet Formation
• Evidence from the asteroid belt for a violent past evolution of Jupiter's orbit
• A decreased probability of habitable planet formation around low-mass stars
• A record of planet migration in the Main Asteroid Belt
• High-resolution simulations of the final assembly of Earth-like planets 2: water delivery and planetary habitability
• Young Solar System's Fifth Giant Planet?
• From planetesimals to terrestrial planets: N-body simulations including the effects of nebular gas and giant planets
• Constraints on resonant-trapping for two planets embedded in a protoplanetary disc
• No universal minimum-mass extrasolar nebula: Evidence against in-situ accretion of systems of hot super-Earths
• Formation of Terrestrial Planets from Protoplanets under a Realistic Accretion Condition
• Constructing the secular architecture of the solar system II: The terrestrial planets
• Lunar and Terrestrial Planet Formation in the Grand Tack Scenario
• Terrestrial Planet Formation in Disks with Varying Surface Density Profiles
• On the Migration of Jupiter and Saturn: Constraints from Linear Models of Secular Resonant Coupling with the Terrestrial Planets
• Gas giant planets as dynamical barriers to inward-migrating super-Earths
• Early Dynamical Evolution of the Solar System: Pinning Down the Initial Condition of the Nice Model
• Secular resonance sweeping of the main asteroid belt during planet migration
• Terrestrial Planet Formation in a protoplanetary disk with a local mass depletion: A successful scenario for the formation of Mars
• A Compound model for the origin of Earth's water
• Accretion in the Early Outer Solar System
• Dynamical Shakeup of Planetary Systems II. N-body simulations of Solar System terrestrial planet formation induced by secular resonance sweeping
• Outward migration of Jupiter and Saturn in 3:2 or 2:1 resonance in radiative disks: implications for the Grand Tack and Nice models
• Formation and accretion history of terrestrial planets from runaway growth through to late time: implications for orbital eccentricity
• The Grand Tack model: a critical review
• Two phase, inward-then-outward migration of Jupiter and Saturn in the gaseous Solar Nebula
• The Dynamical Evolution of the Asteroid Belt
• Terrestrial Planet Formation During the Migration and Resonance Crossings of the Giant Planets
• Earth and Terrestrial Planet Formation
• The Formation of Systems with Tightly-packed Inner Planets (STIPs) via Aerodynamic Drift

Cited by in corpus (66)

• Origin of water in the inner Solar System: Planetesimals scattered inward during Jupiter and Saturn's rapid gas accretion
• The habitability of Proxima Centauri b. I. Irradiation, rotation and volatile inventory from formation to the present
• Close-in planetesimal formation by pile-up of drifting pebbles
• Challenges in Planet Formation
• Mars' Growth Stunted by an Early Giant Planet Instability
• Planetesimal rings as the cause of the Solar System's planetary architecture
• The Delivery of Water During Terrestrial Planet Formation
• Characterizing Exoplanet Habitability
• Origin of Earth's water: sources and constraints
• Solar System Formation in the Context of Extra-Solar Planets
• The early instability scenario: terrestrial planet formation during the giant planet instability, and the effect of collisional fragmentation
• Formation, stratification, and mixing of the cores of Earth and Venus
• Full-lifetime simulations of multiple unequal-mass planets across all phases of stellar evolution
• Impact bombardment chronology of the terrestrial planets from 4.5 Ga to 3.5 Ga
• The Dynamical Evolution of the Asteroid Belt
• Analysis of terrestrial planet formation by the Grand Tack model: System architecture and tack location
• Solar System Physics for Exoplanet Research
• The Role of Early Giant Planet Instability in the Terrestrial Planet Formation
• The excitation of a primordial cold asteroid belt as an outcome of the planetary instability
• Excitation and depletion of the asteroid belt in the early instability scenario
• The Asteroid Belt as a Relic From a Chaotic Early Solar System
• Understanding planet formation using microgravity experiments
• Formation of Venus, Earth and Mars: Constrained by isotopes
• A record of the final phase of giant planet migration fossilized in the asteroid belt's orbital structure
• Growing Mars fast: High-resolution GPU simulations of embryo formation
• Terrestrial planet formation: Dynamical shake-up and the low mass of Mars
• The Fundamental Connections Between the Solar System and Exoplanetary Science
• The effect of a strong pressure bump in the Sun's natal disk: Terrestrial planet formation via planetesimal accretion rather than pebble accretion
• Dynamical Constraints on Mercury's Collisional Origin
• Jumping Jupiter can explain Mercury's orbit
• Constraining the Formation of the Four Terrestrial Planets in the Solar System
• The terrestrial planet formation paradox inferred from high-resolution N-body simulations
• Did Jupiter's core form in the innermost parts of the Sun's protoplanetary disk?
• Terrestrial Planet Formation: Constraining the Formation of Mercury
• Formation of Terrestrial Planets in Disks with Different Surface Density Profiles
• Formation of Terrestrial Planets
• Losing Oceans: The Effects of Composition on the Thermal Component of Impact-driven Atmospheric Loss
• Habitable planet formation around low-mass stars: Rapid accretion, rapid debris removal and the essential contribution of external giants
• Dynamical avenues for Mercury's origin I: The lone survivor of a primordial generation of short-period proto-planets
• Origin and dynamical evolution of the asteroid belt
• Born extra-eccentric: A broad spectrum of primordial configurations of the gas giants that match their present-day orbits
• Dynamical avenues for Mercury's origin II: in-situ formation in the inner terrestrial disk
• The early instability scenario: Mars' mass explained by Jupiter's orbit
• Isotopically distinct terrestrial planets via local accretion
• Stable habitable zones of single Jovian planet systems
• Explaining Mercury via a single giant impact is highly unlikely
• Effects of pebble accretion on the growth and composition of planetesimals in the inner Solar System
• Eccentricity distribution in the main asteroid belt
• Rethinking the role of the giant planet instability in terrestrial planet formation models
• Mercury's formation within the Early Instability Scenario
• Terrestrial planet and asteroid belt formation by Jupiter-Saturn chaotic excitation
• How much water was delivered from the asteroid belt to the Earth after its formation?
• N-body simulations of terrestrial planet growth with resonant dynamical friction
• Accretion regions of meteorite parent bodies inferred from a two-endmember isotopic mixing model
• Earth-size planet formation in the habitable zone of circumbinary stars
• Can narrow disks in the inner solar system explain the four terrestrial planets?
• Impact-induced Vaporization During Accretion of Planetary Bodies
• Planet formation: key mechanisms and global models
• Orbital structure of planetary systems formed by giant impacts: stellar mass dependence
• Terrestrial planet formation during giant planet formation and giant planet migration I: The first 5 million years
• The late formation of chondrites as a consequence of Jupiter-induced gaps and rings
• Evidence of a primordial isotopic gradient in the inner region of the solar protoplanetary disc
• Probing the Dark Solar System: Detecting Binary Asteroids with a Space-Based Interferometric Asteroid Explorer
• Formation of the four terrestrial planets in the Jupiter-Saturn chaotic excitation scenario: fundamental properties and water delivery
• Magnitude of stable iron isotope fractionation limited by multiple stages of terrestrial core formation
• Runaway Growth of Planetesimals Revisited: Presenting Criteria Required for Realistic Modeling of Planetesimal Growth