The Maunder minimum (1645--1715) was indeed a Grand minimum: A reassessment of multiple datasets
arXiv:1507.05191 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201526652
Abstract
Aims: Although the time of the Maunder minimum (1645--1715) is widely known as a period of extremely low solar activity, claims are still debated that solar activity during that period might still have been moderate, even higher than the current solar cycle #24. We have revisited all the existing pieces of evidence and datasets, both direct and indirect, to assess the level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum. Methods: We discuss the East Asian naked-eye sunspot observations, the telescopic solar observations, the fraction of sunspot active days, the latitudinal extent of sunspot positions, auroral sightings at high latitudes, cosmogenic radionuclide data as well as solar eclipse observations for that period. We also consider peculiar features of the Sun (very strong hemispheric asymmetry of sunspot location, unusual differential rotation and the lack of the K-corona) that imply a special mode of solar activity during the Maunder minimum. Results: The level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum is reassessed on the basis of all available data sets. Conclusions: We conclude that solar activity was indeed at an exceptionally low level during the Maunder minimum. Although the exact level is still unclear, it was definitely below that during the Dalton minimum around 1800 and significantly below that of the current solar cycle #24. Claims of a moderate-to-high level of solar activity during the Maunder minimum are rejected at a high confidence level.
arXiv commentAccepted to Astron. Astrophys
References in corpus (36)
- Revisiting the Sunspot Number
- Grand minima and maxima of solar activity: New observational constraints
- Evolution of the solar irradiance during the Holocene
- Solar Irradiance Variability and Climate
- A new approach to long-term reconstruction of the solar irradiance leads to large historical solar forcing
- Magnetic Cycles in a Convective Dynamo Simulation of a Young Solar-type Star
- Historical Sunspot Observations: A Review
- A new model of cosmogenic production of radiocarbon 14C in the atmosphere
- Cyclic magnetic activity due to turbulent convection in spherical wedge geometry
- Dipole Collapse and Dynamo Waves in Global Direct Numerical Simulations
- Evidence for distinct modes of solar activity
- The solar magnetic field since 1700: I. Characteristics of sunspot group emergence and reconstruction of the butterfly diagram
- Dipolar versus multipolar dynamos: the influence of the background density stratification
- Sunspot positions and sizes for 1825-1867 from the observations by Samuel Heinrich Schwabe
- A Solar Dynamo Model Driven by Mean-Field Alpha and Babcock-Leighton Sources: Fluctuations, Grand-Minima-Maxima and Hemispheric Asymmetry in Sunspot Cycles
- The origin of grand minima in the sunspot cycle
- Alpha effect and turbulent diffusion from convection
- A solar cycle lost in 1793--1800: Early sunspot observations resolve the old mystery
- The butterfly diagram in the 18th century
- Revisited sunspot data: A new scenario for the onset of the Maunder minimum
- Solar Grand Minima and random fluctuations in dynamo parameters
- Level and length of cyclic solar activity during the Maunder minimum as deduced from the active day statistics
- The solar magnetic field since 1700: II. Physical reconstruction of total, polar and open flux
- Modeling the Sun's open magnetic flux and the heliospheric current sheet
- Modelling total solar irradiance since 1878 from simulated magnetograms
- Redefining the limit dates for the Maunder Minimum
- Sunspot latitudes during the Maunder Minimum: a machine-readable catalogue from previous studies
- A Simple Method to Check the Reliability of Annual Sunspot Number in the Historical Period 1610-1847
- Revised Group Sunspot Number for 1640, 1652, and 1741
- Digitization of sunspot drawings by Spörer made in 1861-1894
- Width of Sunspot Generating Zone and Reconstruction of Butterfly Diagram
- Reconstructing Past Solar Activity using Meridian Solar Observations: the Case of the Royal Observatory of the Spanish Navy (1833-1840)
- The solar differential rotation in the 18th century
- The Sunspot Catalogues of Carrington, Peters, and de la Rue: Quality Control and Machine-readable Versions
- Long-term Spatial and Temporal Variations of Aurora Borealis Events in the Period 1700--1905
- A Note on the Relationship between Sunspot Numbers and Active Days
Cited by in corpus (62)
- Solar cycle prediction
- Reconstruction of the Sunspot Group Number: the Backbone Method
- A Revised Collection of Sunspot Group Numbers
- A New Calibrated Sunspot Group Series Since 1749: Statistics of Active Day Fractions
- Visualization of the challenges and limitations of the long-term sunspot number record
- Solar cyclic activity over the last millennium reconstructed from annual 14C data
- Multiple dynamo modes as a mechanism for long-term solar activity variations
- Solar activity over nine millennia: A consistent multi-proxy reconstruction
- Re-calibration of the Sunspot Number: Status Report
- How much has the Sun influenced Northern Hemisphere temperature trends? An ongoing debate
- North-south asymmetry in Rieger-type periodicity during solar cycles 19-23
- Models for the long-term variations of solar activity
- Long-term modulation of solar cycles
- Evolution of solar and stellar dynamo theory
- Thaddäus Derfflinger's sunspot observations during 1802-1824: A primary reference to understand the Dalton Minimum
- Reconstruction of spectral solar irradiance since 1700 from simulated magnetograms
- Convective dynamo action in a spherical shell: symmetries and modulation
- Robustness of Solar-Cycle Empirical Rules Across Different Series Including an Updated ADF Sunspot Group Series
- Sunspot characteristics at the onset of the Maunder Minimum based on the observations of Hevelius
- Space climate and space weather over the past 400 years: 2. Proxy indicators of geomagnetic storm and substorm
- The Dalton Minimum and John Dalton's Auroral Observations
- Sunspot Observations during the Maunder Minimum from the Correspondence of John Flamsteed
- Strong evidence of low levels of solar activity during the Maunder Minimum
- Reconstructed sunspot positions in the Maunder Minimum based on the correspondence of Gottfried Kirch
- The umbra-penumbra area ratio of sunspots during the Maunder Minimum
- Extreme value theory applied to the millennial sunspot number series
- Sunspot numbers based on historic records in the 1610s - early telescopic observations by Simon Marius and others
- An Optical Atmospheric Phenomenon Observed in 1670 over the City of Astrakhan Was not a Mid-Latitude Aurora
- Reanalyses of the Sunspot Observations of Fogelius and Siverus: Two "Long-Term" Observers during the Maunder Minimum
- The Solar Corona during the Total Eclipse on 16 June 1806: Graphical Evidence of the Coronal Structure during the Dalton Minimum
- Iwahashi Zenbei's Sunspot Drawings in 1793 in Japan
- Revisiting Christoph Scheiner's Sunspot Records: a New Perspective on Solar Activity of the Early Telescopic Era
- Dependence of the Sunspot-group Size on the Level of Solar Activity and its Influence on the Calibration of Solar Observers
- Number of Sunspot Groups from the Galileo-Scheiner controversy revisited
- Solar Angular Momentum Loss Over the Past Several Millennia
- The effect of telescope aperture, scattered light, and human vision on early measurements of sunspot and group numbers
- Daniel Mögling's sunspot observations in 1626 - 1629: A manuscript reference for the solar activity before the Maunder Minimum
- Stephan Prantner's Sunspot Observations during the Dalton Minimum
- Sunspot Observations by Hisako Koyama: 1945-1996
- Variations of 14-C around AD 775 and AD 1795 - due to solar activity
- Revisiting Kunitomo's Sunspot Drawings during 1835-1836 in Japan
- Sunspot Drawings by Japanese Official Astronomers in 1749-1750
- No evidence for synchronization of the solar cycle by a "clock"
- Cyclic variations in the main components of the solar large-scale magnetic field
- Candidate Auroral Observations during the Major Solar-Terrestrial Storm in May 1680: Implication for Space Weather Events during the Maunder Minimum
- Intense geomagnetic storm during Maunder minimum possibly by a quiescent filament eruption
- Sunspot observations by Charles Malapert during the period 1618-1626: a key dataset to understand solar activity before the Maunder minimum
- The Celestial Sign in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle in the 770s: Insights on Contemporary Solar Activity
- Monitoring the Solar Radius from the Royal Observatory of the Spanish Navy during the Last Quarter-Millennium
- On the use of naked-eye sunspot observations during the Maunder Minimum
- Parity fluctuations in stellar dynamos
- Cosmic Meteorology
- Could a Hexagonal Sunspot Have Been Observed During the Maunder Minimum?
- Sunspot positions from observations by Flaugergues in the Dalton Minimum
- Long-term evolution of the heliospheric magnetic field inferred from cosmogenic Ti activity in meteorites
- A possible case of sporadic aurora observed at Rio de Janeiro
- A Transit of Venus Possibly Misinterpreted as an Unaided-Eye Sunspot Observation in China on 9 December 1874
- Sunspot Records by Antonio Colla just after the Dalton Minimum
- Indirect solar wind measurements using archival cometary tail observations
- Cyclic sunspot activity during the first millennium CE as reconstructed from radiocarbon
- Recovery of the Solar Cycle from Maunder-like Grand Minima Episodes: A Quantification of the Necessary Polar Flux Threshold through Solar Dynamo Simulations
- Centennial solar EUV irradiance from ionospheric currents: Varying sunspot-EUV irradiance relation and modified spot-facula ratio