Features in the Broadband Eclipse Spectra of Exoplanets: Signal or Noise?

Abstract

A planet's emission spectrum contains information about atmospheric composition and structure. We compare the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC) of blackbody fits and idealized spectral retrieval fits for the 44 planets with published eclipse measurements in multiple thermal wavebands, mostly obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope. The evidence for spectral features depends on eclipse depth uncertainties. Spitzer has proven capable of eclipse precisions better than 1E-4 when multiple eclipses are analyzed simultaneously, but this feat has only been performed four times. It is harder to self-calibrate photometry when a single occultation is reduced and analyzed in isolation; we find that such measurements have not passed the test of repeatability. Single-eclipse measurements either have an uncertainty floor of 5E-4, or their uncertainties have been underestimated by a factor of 3. If one adopts these empirical uncertainties for single-eclipse measurements, then the evidence for molecular features all but disappears: blackbodies have better BIC than spectral retrieval for all planets, save HD 189733b, and the few planets poorly fit by blackbodies are also poorly fit by self-consistent radiative transfer models. This suggests that the features in extant broadband emission spectra are due to astrophysical and instrumental noise rather than molecular bands. Claims of stratospheric inversions, disequilibrium chemistry, and high C/O ratios based solely on photometry are premature. We recommend that observers be cautious of error estimates from self-calibration of small data sets, and that modelers compare the evidence for spectral models to that of simpler models such as blackbodies.

11 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables. MNRAS accepted

References in corpus (28)

• Detection of Thermal Emission from an Extrasolar Planet
• On the radiative equilibrium of irradiated planetary atmospheres
• Possible thermochemical disequilibrium in the atmosphere of the exoplanet GJ 436b
• The Broadband Infrared Emission Spectrum of the Exoplanet HD 189733b
• Strong Water Absorption in the Dayside Emission Spectrum of the Planet HD 189733b
• Theoretical Spectra and Light Curves of Close-in Extrasolar Giant Planets and Comparison with Data
• Theoretical Spectral Models of the Planet HD 209458b with a Thermal Inversion and Water Emission Bands
• Multi-Wavelength Constraints on the Day-Night Circulation Patterns of HD 189733b
• The phase-dependent Infrared brightness of the extrasolar planet upsilon Andromedae b
• Strong Infrared Emission from the Extrasolar Planet HD189733b
• Spitzer Transit and Secondary Eclipse Photometry of GJ 436b
• The 4.5 $\mu$m full-orbit phase curve of the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• A New 24 micron Phase Curve for upsilon Andromedae b
• Re-Evaluating WASP-12b: Strong Emission at 2.315 micron, Deeper Occultations, and an Isothermal Atmosphere
• Atmospheric Characterization of the Hot Jupiter Kepler-13Ab
• Deciphering the Atmospheric Composition of WASP-12b: A Comprehensive Analysis of its Dayside Emission
• Thermal Emission of Exoplanet XO-1b
• Spectra as Windows into Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Characterization of the hot Neptune GJ 436b with Spitzer and ground-based observations
• A Spitzer Search for Water in the Transiting Exoplanet HD189733b
• Hot Jupiter Variability in Eclipse Depth
• Limits on the 2.2 microns contrast ratio of the close orbiting planet HD 189733b
• Colour-Magnitude Diagrams of Transiting Exoplanets. I - Systems with parallaxes
• The GROUSE project III: Ks-band observations of the thermal emission from WASP-33b
• A new look at Spitzer primary transit observations of the exoplanet HD189733b
• A Ground-Based Search for Thermal Emission from the Exoplanet TrES-1
• The thermal emission of the exoplanets WASP-1b and WASP-2b
• Ground-based detection of the near-infrared emission from the dayside of WASP-5b

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Spitzer Secondary Eclipses of the Dense, Modestly-irradiated, Giant Exoplanet HAT-P-20b Using Pixel-Level Decorrelation
• Retrieving Temperatures and Abundances of Exoplanet Atmospheres with High-Resolution Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy
• Detection of H2O and evidence for TiO/VO in an ultra hot exoplanet atmosphere
• Exoplanetary Atmospheres - Chemistry, Formation Conditions, and Habitability
• HELIOS: An Open-source, GPU-accelerated Radiative Transfer Code For Self-consistent Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• Atmospheric Dynamics of Hot Exoplanets
• Spitzer Phase Curve Constraints for WASP-43b at 3.6 and 4.5 microns
• No Thermal Inversion and a Solar Water Abundance for the Hot Jupiter HD209458b from HST WFC3 Emission Spectroscopy
• High-Resolution Spectroscopic Detection of TiO and Stratosphere in the Day-side of WASP-33b
• Characterizing Transiting Planet Atmospheres through 2025
• HELIOS-Retrieval: An Open-source, Nested Sampling Atmospheric Retrieval Code, Application to the HR 8799 Exoplanets and Inferred Constraints for Planet Formation
• Observations of Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Balancing the Energy Budget of Short-Period Giant Planets: Evidence for Reflective Clouds and Optical Absorbers
• 3.6 and 4.5 $\mu$m $Spitzer$ Phase Curves of the Highly-Irradiated Hot Jupiters WASP-19b and HAT-P-7b
• A uniform analysis of HD209458b Spitzer/IRAC lightcurves with Gaussian process models
• Metal enrichment leads to low atmospheric C/O ratios in transiting giant exoplanets
• Statistical Characterization of Hot Jupiter Atmospheres using Spitzer's Secondary Eclipses
• Repeatability and Accuracy of Exoplanet Eclipse Depths Measured with Post-Cryogenic Spitzer
• Non-detection of TiO and VO in the atmosphere of WASP-121b using high-resolution spectroscopy
• Deciphering thermal phase curves of dry, tidally locked terrestrial planets
• Characterizing Rocky and Gaseous Exoplanets with 2-meter Class Space-based Coronagraphs
• Detection of a Westward Hotspot Offset in the Atmosphere of a Hot Gas Giant CoRoT-2b
• Detection of Fe and evidence for TiO in the dayside emission spectrum of WASP-33b
• Near-infrared Thermal Emission Detections of a number of hot Jupiters and the Systematics of Ground-based Near-infrared Photometry
• What are little worlds made of? Stellar abundances and the building blocks of planets
• A Comprehensive Reanalysis of $\text{Spitzer}$'s 4.5 $\mu$m Phase Curves, and the Phase Variations of the Ultra-hot Jupiters MASCARA-1b and KELT-16b
• The Implications of 3D Thermal Structure on 1D Atmospheric Retrieval
• An optical transmission spectrum of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-33b. First indication of AlO in an exoplanet
• Spitzer Secondary Eclipse Observations of Five Cool Gas Giant Planets and Empirical Trends in Cool Planet Emission Spectra
• Ks band secondary eclipses of WASP-19b and WASP-43b with the Anglo-Australian Telescope
• Secondary eclipse observations for seven hot-Jupiters from the Anglo-Australian Telescope
• Low albedos of hot to ultra-hot Jupiters in the optical to near-infrared transition regime
• CRIRES+ detection of CO emissions lines and temperature inversions on the dayside of WASP-18b and WASP-76b
• An Information-Theoretic Approach to Optimize JWST Observations and Retrievals of Transiting Exoplanet Atmospheres
• Hot Jupiter Diversity and the Onset of TiO/VO Revealed by a Large Grid of Non-Grey Global Circulation Models
• High-precision multi-wavelength eclipse photometry of the ultra-hot gas giant exoplanet WASP-103 b
• Storms or Systematics? The changing secondary eclipse depth of WASP-12b
• Inferring asymmetric limb cloudiness on exoplanets from transit light curves
• Evidence for chromium hydride in the atmosphere of Hot Jupiter WASP-31b
• Modeling synthetic spectra for transiting extrasolar giant planets: detectability of H${}_2$S and PH${}_3$ with JWST
• Constraining Exoplanet Metallicities and Aerosols with ARIEL: An Independent Study by the Contribution to ARIEL Spectroscopy of Exoplanets (CASE) Team
• Smaller than expected bright-spot offsets in Spitzer phase curves of the hot Jupiter Qatar-1b
• Emergent Spectral Fluxes of Hot Jupiters: an Abrupt Rise in Day Side Brightness Temperature Under Strong Irradiation
• How to Characterize the Atmosphere of a Transiting Exoplanet
• Estimating dayside effective temperatures of hot Jupiters and associated uncertainties through Gaussian process regression
• Exoplanetary Geophysics -- An Emerging Discipline
• Colour-magnitude diagrams of transiting Exoplanets -- III. A public code, nine strange planets, and the role of Phosphine
• Thermal Phase Curves of XO-3b: an Eccentric Hot Jupiter at the Deuterium Burning Limit
• The TESS light curve of the eccentric eclipsing binary 1SWASP J011351.29+314909.7 -- no evidence for a very hot M-dwarf companion
• Knot a Bad Idea: Testing BLISS Mapping for Spitzer Space Telescope Photometry
• Reassessing Exoplanet Light Curves with a Thermal Model
• Observations of Transiting Exoplanets with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific (PASP), December 2014
• Illusion and Reality in the Atmospheres of Exoplanets
• Atmospheric characterization of hot Jupiters using hierarchical models of Spitzer observations
• A new statistical method for characterizing the atmospheres of extrasolar planets
• Spectroscopic Evidence for a Temperature Inversion in the Dayside Atmosphere of the Hot Jupiter WASP-33b