A comparative study of radio halo occurrence in SZ and X-ray selected galaxy cluster samples

Abstract

We aim at an unbiased census of the radio halo population in galaxy clusters and test whether current low number counts of radio halos have arisen from selection biases. We construct near-complete samples based on X-ray and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect cluster catalogues and search for diffuse, extended (Mpc-scale) emission near the cluster centers by analyzing data from the National Radio Astronomy Observatory Very Large Array Sky Survey. We remove compact sources using a matched filtering algorithm and model the diffuse emission using two independent methods. The relation between radio halo power at 1.4 GHz and mass observables is modelled using a power law, allowing for a 'dropout' population of clusters hosting no radio halo emission. An extensive suite of simulations is used to check for biases in our methods. Our findings suggest that the fraction of targets hosting radio halos may have to be revised upwards for clusters selected using the SZ effect: while approximately 60 per cent of the X-ray selected targets are found to contain no extended radio emission, in agreement with previous findings, the corresponding fraction in the SZ selected samples is roughly 20 per cent. We propose a simple explanation for this selection difference based on the distinct time evolution of the SZ and X-ray observables during cluster mergers, and a bias towards relaxed, cool-core clusters in the X-ray selection.

19 pages, 15 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Moderate revisions, with results unchanged

References in corpus (7)

• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Radio signature of cosmological structure formation shocks
• GMRT Radio Halo Survey in galaxy clusters at z = 0.2 -- 0.4. II.The eBCS clusters and analysis of the complete sample
• The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - II. Effects on global X-ray and SZ properties and their scaling relations
• Double relics in Abell 2345 and Abell 1240: spectral index and polarization analysis
• New scaling relations in cluster radio halos and the re-acceleration model
• The Contribution of Radio Galaxy Contamination to Measurements of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Decrement in Massive Galaxy Clusters at 140 GHz with Bolocam

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Cosmic rays in galaxy clusters and their non-thermal emission
• Diffuse Radio Emission from Galaxy Clusters
• Evidence for particle re-acceleration in the radio relic in the galaxy cluster PLCKG287.0 +32.9
• The fraction of cool-core clusters in X-ray vs. SZ samples using Chandra observations
• The cool core state of Planck SZ-selected clusters versus X-ray selected samples: evidence for cool core bias
• On the occurrence of Radio Halos in galaxy clusters - Insight from a mass-selected sample
• The Extended GMRT Radio Halo Survey II: Further results and analysis of the full sample
• The Radio Relics and Halo of El Gordo, a Massive $z=0.870$ Cluster Merger
• On the Physics of Radio Halos in Galaxy Clusters: Scaling Relations and Luminosity Functions
• A Multi-component Matched Filter Cluster Confirmation Tool for eROSITA: Initial Application to the RASS and DES-SV Datasets
• On the absence of radio halos in clusters with double relics
• Mpc-scale diffuse radio emission in two massive cool-core clusters of galaxies
• Can giant radio halos probe the merging rate of galaxy clusters?
• The discovery of radio halos in the Frontier Fields clusters Abell S1063 and Abell 370
• High $\beta$ Effects on Cosmic Ray Streaming in Galaxy Clusters
• The impact of the SZ effect on cm-wavelength (1-30 GHz) observation of galaxy cluster radio relics
• A radio halo surrounding the Brightest Cluster Galaxy in RXCJ0232.2-4420: a mini-halo in transition ?
• Radio halos in SZ-selected clusters of galaxies: the making of a halo?
• Diffuse galaxy cluster emission at 168 MHz within the Murchison Widefield Array Epoch of Reionization 0-hour field
• MERGHERS Pilot: MeerKAT discovery of diffuse emission in nine massive Sunyaev-Zel'dovich-selected galaxy clusters from ACT
• MeerKAT's View of the Bullet Cluster 1E 0657-55.8
• Diffuse radio emission from non-Planck galaxy clusters in the LoTSS-DR2 fields
• Exploring diffuse radio emission in galaxy clusters and groups with the uGMRT and the SKA
• The thermal and non-thermal components within and between galaxy clusters Abell 399 and Abell 401
• A giant radio halo in a low-mass SZ-selected galaxy cluster: ACT-CL J0256.5+0006
• Substructure analysis of the RXCJ0232.2-4420 galaxy cluster
• Radio halos in a mass-selected sample of 75 galaxy clusters. I. Sample selection and data analysis
• White Paper: Radio Emission and Polarization Properties of Galaxy Clusters with VLASS
• "SZ spectroscopy" in the coming decade: Galaxy cluster cosmology and astrophysics in the submillimeter