Inconsistent thermostatistics and negative absolute temperatures

Abstract

A considerable body of experimental and theoretical work claims the existence of negative absolute temperatures in spin systems and ultra-cold quantum gases. Here, we clarify that such findings can be attributed to the use of a popular yet inconsistent entropy definition, which violates fundamental thermodynamic relations and fails to produce sensible results for simple analytically tractable classical and quantum systems. Within a mathematically consistent thermodynamic formalism, based on an entropy concept originally derived by Gibbs, absolute temperature remains positive even for systems with bounded spectrum. We address spurious arguments against the Gibbs formalism and comment briefly on heat engines with efficiencies greater than one.

19 pages, 1 figure; comments welcome

References in corpus (7)

• Fluctuation Theorem for Arbitrary Open Quantum Systems
• Negative Absolute Temperature for Motional Degrees of Freedom
• Phase Transitions in Small Systems: Microcanonical vs. Canonical Ensembles
• Equilibration rates and negative absolute temperatures for ultracold atoms in optical lattices
• Derivation of Boltzmann Principle
• Nonlocal observables and lightcone-averaging in relativistic thermodynamics
• Thermodynamics with generalized ensembles: The class of dual orthodes

Cited by in corpus (90)

• {\it Colloquium:} Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics at Strong Coupling: Quantum and Classical
• Thermometry in the quantum regime: Recent theoretical progress
• Temperature in and out of equilibrium: a review of concepts, tools and attempts
• Thermodynamics of quantum systems under dynamical control
• Efficiency of a quantum Otto heat engine operating under a reservoir at effective negative temperatures
• First and Second Law of Quantum Thermodynamics: A Consistent Derivation Based on a Microscopic Definition of Entropy
• Gibbs, Boltzmann, and negative temperatures
• Quantum Engines and Refrigerators
• Heat-machine control by quantum-state preparation: from quantum engines to refrigerators
• Direct measurement of nonequilibrium system entropy is consistent with Gibbs-Shannon form
• Most energetic passive states
• Weakly nonergodic dynamics in the Gross--Pitaevskii lattice
• Construction of microcanonical entropy on thermodynamic pillars
• Statistical Mechanics of Systems with Negative Temperature
• Consistent description of fluctuations requires negative temperatures
• On the dispute between Boltzmann and Gibbs entropy
• Negative temperatures and the definition of entropy
• Observation of light thermalization to negative temperature Rayleigh-Jeans equilibrium states in multimode optical fibers
• System-size scaling of Boltzmann and alternate Gibbs entropies
• Meaning of temperature in different thermostatistical ensembles
• Quantum systems correlated with a finite bath: nonequilibrium dynamics and thermodynamics
• Available energy and ground states of collisionless plasmas
• The Gibbs "volume" entropy is incorrect
• Canonical free-energy barrier of particle and polymer cluster formation
• Isotropic-Nematic Phase Transitions in Gravitational Systems
• Complete analysis of ensemble inequivalence in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model
• In defence of negative temperature
• Phase transitions at high energy vindicate negative microcanonical temperature
• Typical and extreme entropies of long-lived isolated quantum systems
• Statistical mechanics of systems with long-range interactions and negative absolute temperature
• Quantum Fluctuation Relations for Ensembles of Wave Functions
• Isotropic-Nematic Phase Transitions in Gravitational Systems II: Higher Order Multipoles
• Relation between Boltzmann and Gibbs entropy and example with multinomial distribution
• Topological Approach to Microcanonical Thermodynamics and Phase Transition of Interacting Classical Spins
• The thermodynamic entropy of a macroscopic quantum system is a continuous function of energy
• Cosmology with Negative Absolute Temperatures
• Comment on "Consistent thermostatistics forbids negative absolute temperatures"
• Resonant relaxation in globular clusters
• Beyond Gibbs-Boltzmann-Shannon: General Entropies -- The Gibbs-Lorentzian Example
• Fluctuation relations and strong inequalities for thermally isolated systems
• Tropical limit and the micro-macro correspondence
• Entropy and Temperature in finite isolated quantum systems
• Geometrical aspects in the analysis of microcanonical phase-transitions
• Microcanonical entropy for classical systems
• Entropy and the second law for driven, or quenched, thermally isolated systems
• Temperature as a quantum observable
• Fluctuations in partitioning systems with few degrees of freedom
• Relaxation dynamics in double-spin systems
• Critique of the Gibbs volume entropy and its implication
• Multi-temperature atomic ensemble: nonequilibrium evolution after ultrafast electronic excitation
• Negative temperature states as exact equilibrium solutions of the Wave Kinetic equation for one dimensional lattices
• Derivation of a Langevin equation in a system with multiple scales: the case of negative temperatures
• Brownian Thermometry Beyond Equilibrium
• Nonlinear Stochastic Dynamics of Complex Systems, II: Potential of Entropic Force in Markov Systems with Nonequilibrium Steady State, Generalized Gibbs Function and Criticality
• Information-theoretic foundations of thermodynamics in general probabilistic theories
• The stumbling block of the Gibbs entropy: the reality of the negative absolute temperatures
• What Is the Temperature? Modern Outlook on the Concept of Temperature
• Phase transitions, critical behavior and microstructure of the FRW universe in the framework of higher order GUP
• Comparative Microscopic Study of Entropies and their Production
• Quantifying Information Extraction using Generalized Quantum Measurements
• Work, Heat and Internal Energy in Open Quantum Systems: A Comparison of Four Approaches from the Autonomous System Framework
• Negative-temperature Fourier transport in one-dimensional systems
• Feasible platform to study negative temperatures
• Non-Clausius heat transfer: the example of harmonic chain with an impurity
• A microcanonical entropy correcting finite-size effects in small systems
• A Note on the Entropy Force in Kinetic Theory and Black Holes
• Canonical density matrices from eigenstates of mixed systems
• Correlations in interacting electron liquids: Many-body statistics and hyperuniformity
• Resolving the Debate Between Boltzmann and Gibbs Entropy: Relative Energy Window Eliminates Thermodynamic Inconsistencies and Allows Negative Absolute Temperatures
• Reply to Frenkel and Warren [arXiv:1403.4299v1]
• Increase of quantum volume entropy in presence of degenerate eigenenergies
• Internal temperature of quantum chaotic systems at the nanoscale and its detection by a microscopic thermometer
• Reply to Schneider et al. [arXiv:1407.4127v1]
• How Geometrical Frustrated Systems Challenge our Notion of Thermodynamics
• Resolving the debate about proposed expressions for the classical entropy
• H-theorem at negative temperature: the random exchange model with bounds
• Quantum work fluctuations versus macrorealism in terms of non-extensive entropies
• Coarse-graining and symplectic non-squeezing
• Taking the temperature of quantum many-body scars
• Dynamics of HIV Infection: an entropic-energetic view
• Ensemble equivalence for mean field models and plurisubharmonicity
• Thermodynamic laws in isolated systems
• The statistics of mesoscopic systems and the physical interpretation of extensive and non-extensive entropies
• Detecting temperature fluctuations at equilibrium
• Perturbation Theory in a Microcanonical Ensemble
• Quantifying Stability of Quantum Statistical Ensembles
• Sampling and statistical physics via symmetry
• Equilibrium and Non-equilibrium Gross-Pitaevskii Lattice Dynamics: Interactions, Disorder, and Thermalization
• Effective Equations in complex systems: from Langevin to machine learning
• On the definition of the measurement unit for extreme quantity values: some considerations on the case of temperature and the kelvin scale