Construction of microcanonical entropy on thermodynamic pillars

Abstract

A question that is currently highly debated is whether the microcanonical entropy should be expressed as the logarithm of the phase volume (volume entropy, also known as the Gibbs entropy) or as the logarithm of the density of states (surface entropy, also known as the Boltzmann entropy). Rather than postulating them and investigating the consequence of each definition, as is customary, here we adopt a bottom-up approach and construct the entropy expression within the microcanonical formalism upon two fundamental thermodynamic pillars: (i) The second law of thermodynamics as formulated for quasi-static processes: $\delta Q/T$ is an exact differential, and (ii) the law of ideal gases: $PV=k_{B}NT$. The first pillar implies that entropy must be some function of the phase volume $\Omega$. The second pillar singles out the logarithmic function among all possible functions. Hence the construction leads uniquely to the expression $S=k_B\ln \Omega$, that is the volume entropy. As a consequence any entropy expression other than that of Gibbs, e.g., the Boltzmann entropy, can lead to inconsistencies with the two thermodynamic pillars. We illustrate this with the prototypical example of a macroscopic collection of non-interacting spins in a magnetic field, and show that the Boltzmann entropy severely fails to predict the magnetization, even in the thermodynamic limit. The uniqueness of the Gibbs entropy, as well as the demonstrated potential harm of the Boltzmann entropy, provide compelling reasons for discarding the latter at once.

arXiv comment7 pages, 2 figures. v4: published version

References in corpus (8)

• Inconsistent thermostatistics and negative absolute temperatures
• Gibbs, Boltzmann, and negative temperatures
• Phase Transitions in Small Systems: Microcanonical vs. Canonical Ensembles
• System-size scaling of Boltzmann and alternate Gibbs entropies
• Derivation of Boltzmann Principle
• Finite Bath Fluctuation Theorem
• Does the Boltzmann principle need a dynamical correction?
• Thermodynamics with generalized ensembles: The class of dual orthodes

Cited by in corpus (43)

• {\it Colloquium:} Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics at Strong Coupling: Quantum and Classical
• Temperature in and out of equilibrium: a review of concepts, tools and attempts
• Efficiency of a quantum Otto heat engine operating under a reservoir at effective negative temperatures
• First and Second Law of Quantum Thermodynamics: A Consistent Derivation Based on a Microscopic Definition of Entropy
• Statistical Mechanics of Systems with Negative Temperature
• Consistent description of fluctuations requires negative temperatures
• On the dispute between Boltzmann and Gibbs entropy
• Negative temperatures and the definition of entropy
• Quantum systems correlated with a finite bath: nonequilibrium dynamics and thermodynamics
• Meaning of temperature in different thermostatistical ensembles
• The Gibbs "volume" entropy is incorrect
• Isotropic-Nematic Phase Transitions in Gravitational Systems
• Operational definition of the temperature of a quantum state
• Complete analysis of ensemble inequivalence in the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model
• In defence of negative temperature
• Phase transitions at high energy vindicate negative microcanonical temperature
• Isotropic-Nematic Phase Transitions in Gravitational Systems II: Higher Order Multipoles
• Relation between Boltzmann and Gibbs entropy and example with multinomial distribution
• The thermodynamic entropy of a macroscopic quantum system is a continuous function of energy
• Resonant relaxation in globular clusters
• Fluctuation relations and strong inequalities for thermally isolated systems
• Microcanonical entropy for classical systems
• Entropy and Temperature in finite isolated quantum systems
• Origin of Negative Temperatures in Systems Interacting with External Fields
• Entropy and the second law for driven, or quenched, thermally isolated systems
• Critique of the Gibbs volume entropy and its implication
• Nonlinear Stochastic Dynamics of Complex Systems, II: Potential of Entropic Force in Markov Systems with Nonequilibrium Steady State, Generalized Gibbs Function and Criticality
• The stumbling block of the Gibbs entropy: the reality of the negative absolute temperatures
• On the foundations of statistical mechanics
• Strong Coupling and non-Markovian Effects in the Statistical Notion of Temperature
• Negative temperature is cool for cooling
• Comparative Microscopic Study of Entropies and their Production
• Feasible platform to study negative temperatures
• Non-Clausius heat transfer: the example of harmonic chain with an impurity
• Increase of quantum volume entropy in presence of degenerate eigenenergies
• Resolving the Debate Between Boltzmann and Gibbs Entropy: Relative Energy Window Eliminates Thermodynamic Inconsistencies and Allows Negative Absolute Temperatures
• Resolving the debate about proposed expressions for the classical entropy
• How Geometrical Frustrated Systems Challenge our Notion of Thermodynamics
• Verification of finite bath fluctuation theorem for a non-ergodic system
• Taking the temperature of quantum many-body scars
• Equilibrium and Non-equilibrium Gross-Pitaevskii Lattice Dynamics: Interactions, Disorder, and Thermalization
• Effective Equations in complex systems: from Langevin to machine learning
• The statistics of mesoscopic systems and the physical interpretation of extensive and non-extensive entropies