Constructing cities, deconstructing scaling laws
arXiv:1301.1674 · doi:10.1098/rsif.2014.0745
Abstract
Cities can be characterised and modelled through different urban measures. Consistency within these observables is crucial in order to advance towards a science of cities. Bettencourt et al have proposed that many of these urban measures can be predicted through universal scaling laws. We develop a framework to consistently define cities, using commuting to work and population density thresholds, and construct thousands of realisations of systems of cities with different boundaries for England and Wales. These serve as a laboratory for the scaling analysis of a large set of urban indicators. The analysis shows that population size alone does not provide enough information to describe or predict the state of a city as previously proposed, indicating that the expected scaling laws are not corroborated. We found that most urban indicators scale linearly with city size regardless of the definition of the urban boundaries. However, when non-linear correlations are present, the exponent fluctuates considerably.
arXiv commentAccepted for publication, Journal of the Royal Society Interface
References in corpus (9)
- Power-law distributions in empirical data
- Laws of Population Growth
- Modeling Urban Growth Patterns with Correlated Percolation
- How congestion shapes cities: from mobility patterns to scaling
- Large cities are less green
- Robust Statistical Tests of Dragon-Kings beyond Power Law Distributions
- Distance weighted city growth
- Spatially distributed social complex networks
- Statistical Outliers and Dragon-Kings as Bose-Condensed Droplets
Cited by in corpus (87)
- Social physics
- From mobile phone data to the spatial structure of cities
- Effects of changing population or density on urban carbon dioxide emissions
- Paradoxical Interpretations of Urban Scaling Laws
- The systematic structure and predictability of urban business diversity
- The statistical physics of Cities
- From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities
- Cities and Regions in Britain through hierarchical percolation
- Is this scaling nonlinear?
- Computational Socioeconomics
- Fitting heavy tailed distributions: the poweRlaw package
- Explaining the Prevalence, Scaling and Variance of Urban Phenomena
- Field theory for recurrent mobility
- Comparing and modeling land use organization in cities
- Defining urban agglomerations to detect agglomeration economies
- Urban Geography and Scaling of Contemporary Indian Cities
- Cities through the Prism of People's Spending Behavior
- The non-linear health consequences of living in larger cities
- Evolution of urban scaling: evidence from Brazil
- Mapping parcel-level urban areas for a large geographical area
- Structure of 311 Service Requests as a Signature of Urban Location
- Human Mobility in Large Cities as a Proxy for Crime
- Scale-adjusted metrics for predicting the evolution of urban indicators and quantifying the performance of cities
- Emergence of metapopulations and echo chambers in mobile agents
- Rural to urban population density scaling of crime and property transactions in English and Welsh Parliamentary Constituencies
- The Economic Complexity of US Metropolitan Areas
- Urban Scaling of Cities in the Netherlands
- Understanding the mesoscopic scaling patterns within cities
- Human diffusion and city influence
- Large cities are less efficient for sustainable transport: The ABC of mobility
- Association between population distribution and urban GDP scaling
- A common trajectory recapitulated by urban economies
- The size distribution, scaling properties and spatial organization of urban clusters: a global and regional perspective
- Fractal Dimensions Derived from Spatial Allometric Scaling of Urban Form
- More crime in cities? On the scaling laws of crime and the inadequacy of per capita rankings -- a cross-country study
- Multi-Scaling Allometric Analysis for Urban and Regional Development
- Constructing multi-level urban clusters based on population distributions and interactions
- Modeling the origin of urban output scaling laws
- Cities as nuclei of sustainability?
- Commuting network effect on urban wealth scaling
- Analysis on the urban street network of Korea: Connections between topology and meta-information
- Spatial interactions in urban scaling laws
- On the relation between Transversal and Longitudinal Scaling in Cities
- Robustness and Closeness Centrality for Self-Organized and Planned Cities
- Assessing the attraction of cities on venture capital from a scaling law perspective
- Mobile phone indicators and their relation to the socioeconomic organisation of cities
- Unveiling Relationships Between Crime and Property in England and Wales Via Density Scale-Adjusted Metrics and Network Tools
- City limits in the age of smartphones and urban scaling
- Truncated lognormal distributions and scaling in the size of naturally defined population clusters
- Some recent advances in urban system science: models and data
- The solutions to uncertainty problem of urban fractal dimension calculation
- A worldwide model for boundaries of urban settlements
- Exploring the Level of Urbanization Based on Zipf's Scaling Exponent
- How the geometry of cities explains urban scaling laws and determines their exponents
- Hierarchical Scaling in Systems of Natural Cities
- Lognormals, Power Laws and Double Power Laws in the Distribution of Frequencies of Harmonic Codewords from Classical Music
- Scaling Behavior of Public Procurement Activity
- The geography and carbon footprint of mobile phone use in Cote d'Ivoire
- Cross-sectional Urban Scaling Fails in Predicting Temporal Growth of Cities
- Two Sets of Simple Formulae to Estimating Fractal Dimension of Irregular Boundaries
- Complexity in patterns of racial segregation
- Telling apart <I>Felidae</I> and <I>Ursidae</I> from the distribution of nucleotides in mitochondrial DNA
- Seeing the Forest for the Trees: Scaling Analysis of Energy in Great Lakes Water Supplies
- Diffusive resettlement: irreversible urban transitions in closed systems
- Life Between the City and the Village: Comparative Analysis of Service Access in Indian Urban Slums
- Characteristic Scales, Scaling, and Geospatial Analysis
- Towards Understanding the Impact of Human Mobility on Police Allocation
- The Atlas for the Aspiring Network Scientist
- Twitter Activity Timeline as a Signature of Urban Neighborhood
- Revealing configurational attractors in the evolution of modern Australian and US cities
- Tracking Urban Activity Growth Globally with Big Location Data
- Approaches to the classification of complex systems: Words, texts, and more
- On the scaling of functional spaces, from smart cities to cloud computing
- Hamiltonian Modeling of Macro-Economic Urban Dynamics
- The Adequate Bootstrap
- From Urban Segregation to Spatial Pattern Detection
- Predicting Urban Innovation from the Workforce Mobility Network in US
- A self-consistent assessment of multi-dimensional fitness of cities
- Dynamics of racial segregation and gentrification in New York City
- A Generalized Population Dynamics Model of a City and an Algorithm for Engineering Regime Shifts
- Opportunities at the Mathematics/Future Cities Interface
- Fractal Patterns in Spatial Distribution of Population by Age Group
- The scaling of income inequality in cities
- Change of impervious space in German cities: A scaling law analysis
- Observing cities as a complex system
- Derivation of Relations between Scaling Exponents and Standard Deviation Ratios
- Prediction of 'artificial' urban archetypes at the pedestrian-scale through a synthesis of domain expertise with machine learning methods